Skills
Snitch
- Joined
- Jan 17, 2012
- Messages
- 43,212
Fed has won the French once and reached the final 5 times, losing 4 times to the clay GOAT. That's weaker than Nadal at Wimbledon, but not "far, far" weaker.
Federer also has 2 standout clay matches that should count towards this - he ended Nadal's multi-year, 81 match, streak on clay, and he ended Djokovic's 2011 unbeaten run at the French Open.
I'd say they are a lot weaker. Nadal's taken Federer (who a lot consider the grass court goat) twice to 5 sets to Wimbledon (winning it once), while it's never been close at the French between them. Nole has been a much worthier competitor on clay for Nadal.