It's absurd, isn't it? He's been consistently shit all season, has shown no signs of meeting the required standards, and then after one decent performance you have half the Caf suddenly saying we should sign him permanently!
Sofyan Amrabat | 2023/24 Performances
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
- Status
Think this season has been so rancid that people are grasping onto anything remotely positive. One decent performance = raves. One short speech thanking the fans = raves.
I thought his game against Chelsea was better to be honest, he seemed quite up and down during the game last night. I do wonder if the issues with passing last night would be less prevalent if he had had more time in the team. I think he'd give us more in midfield than Case has to be honest, but at this point it's too late to see much more and we should be letting him return to Fiorentina.
People on here wanting to sign him. Now we are below scraping the barrel!
He's a Sunday league player at best.
He's a Sunday league player at best.
Like I said before, he should've been utilised much more than he has been. But he's not a player we should sign and I see opportunity and bigger potential in signing either Mandela Keita (Royal Antwerp) or Youssouf Fofana (Monaco) who is entering the last year of his contract. Both players would likely be value signings and have the attributes that suit the EPL.
It's comments like this where you just can't take some posters seriously. Played great in the World Cup and Serie A but he's a sunday league player. Delusional.
I'm not here to appease sheep. The **** of manager has now become the **** of of team selection.
I pointed out that Amrabat didn't have a very good game and you're now talking about the team selection for The FA Cup final. I don't really care about that.
Surely its better to have a midfielder who might misplace some passes but actually wants to be on the ball.
As opposed to a midfielder whose weakness is their unwillingness to receive and pass.
Can we drop the hyperbole.
Shown glimpses last night but ultimately just not good enough for the long term. It’s amazing how 1 performance can completely flip 10 months of shite on its head
Send the bugger back
Send the bugger back
Yeah, I don't know. Seems pretty mediocre to me all things said and done.
Obviously not a Sunday League player (see above), but let's say replaceable in the extreme.
Obviously not a Sunday League player (see above), but let's say replaceable in the extreme.
Think he should've been given more games than he got, but his disasterclass against City pretty much sealed the deal.
Maybe we'll regret not buying him, like Sabitzer, but I wouldn't lose sleep if we don't.
Maybe we'll regret not buying him, like Sabitzer, but I wouldn't lose sleep if we don't.
He played well apart from all the shit things he did. Normally I would admit to how facetious that comment is, but it is actually true and very Fred-like for him. Some really amateurish looking moments which he immediately shook off and kept working hard, being aggressive and making a decent impact on the game.
Very handsy though, loves a shove in the back, know there was a game earlier in the season where he blatantly shoved someone from behind in the box and got away with it, and then again last night.
Very handsy though, loves a shove in the back, know there was a game earlier in the season where he blatantly shoved someone from behind in the box and got away with it, and then again last night.
I'm shocked
I agreed with more or less every post from you I've seen so this is a shocker.I feel I'm more lenient than most on here - but I'll be disappointed if we sign him after the season he's had. I'm sure there's a player in there, but I don't think its at the level we hope to be at.
He’s the kind of erratic player that could drop an absolute calamity at any moment. Absolutely no way should we be signing this average midfielder permanently.
Not saying it’s the same thing but I remember when Mata had a shite season and put in a couple of decent performances in fairly meaningless games and people were saying he should be kept for the following season.
Watching Amrabat it’s clear he’s not really suited to the PL. he might have the odd good game but he’s behind the pace of the game most times and his defensive nous is limited to fouling anyone near him. He’s a calm player in possession and will keep the ball moving but you can find similar midfielders in every team except the bottom five probably.
We can do much better.
Watching Amrabat it’s clear he’s not really suited to the PL. he might have the odd good game but he’s behind the pace of the game most times and his defensive nous is limited to fouling anyone near him. He’s a calm player in possession and will keep the ball moving but you can find similar midfielders in every team except the bottom five probably.
We can do much better.
It just all depends who leaves for me. We can do better but as we failed to do with Fred, you've got to replace everyone you get rid of.
If him and Casemiro both leave, we need two defensive midfielders but knowing us we'll sign one and if that player then gets injured/suspended etc we're back to square one again.
If him and Casemiro both leave, we need two defensive midfielders but knowing us we'll sign one and if that player then gets injured/suspended etc we're back to square one again.
Personally I would get rid and give some time to one of the youth team or Daniel Gore instead.
We definitely need to get and experienced (but not over the top as Casemiro) DM to play alongside Mainoo
We definitely need to get and experienced (but not over the top as Casemiro) DM to play alongside Mainoo
In fairness, he's never really had a chance to actually get up to speed with the pace of the PL.
Agreed we can do better though... hopefully.
The clanger for the Newcastle goal that he stuck his leg out and missed, any decent defensive midfielder would have judged the ball better, took it in his chest and passed forwards. He’s looked ok but that’s mostly down to the manager getting his head out of his arse and putting a warm body in front of the makeshift defensive unit.
How is Gore doing on loan?
Not sure as he has been injured quite a lot, but he and Kobbie had a great understanding with the youth team and complimented each other well
You cant fail to replace Amrabat, unless we sign someone in their late 20s from the bottom half of the championship or something
would love to see these people calling an international footballer a sunday league player actually play 10 minutes against him let alone 90 minutes
yeah people are always a bit over the top here. Regardless though, it is hilarious to see people saying we should actually bring him back .
He's obviously not a sunday league player. You can just rubbish any poster who says that about any of our players, they are trolls and not worth pretending they're worth conversing with
He just isnt a top 4 in the premier league player, similar to the fact he wasnt a top 4 in serie A player and I think we'd agree that the premier league is a step above
He is an ideal squad player for united, extremely professional, a good footballer. He's not good enough to be our starting #6, but still good to habe
If he had been an ideal squad player then he would have proven that this season. Hes an ideal squad player for a lower mid table team or a starter for a team scrapping for survival
Totally agree.
He has been what we need the last two games, I now feel like we ought to get him. Where has he been all season?
Been okay lately. 30m in todays market is okay value but we have other priorities I think
What the hell has he shown to be worth 30 million?
He's not though, the only thing he's shown all season whenever he's played is that he's extremely out of his depth at this level
He's been average at best. Average for a midfielder in the premier league would be a starter at a mid table club, and the starters at the mid table clubs are better than him. So I'm being kind to call the performances average.
What I have no doubt is that if Casemiro put in his last 2 performances everyone would be at his throat like they were earlier in the season when he put in far better performances but like Amrabat made some careless mistakes to give opponents chances ruining the performances
The two games where we won lost one deservedly and the other where the other team lost despite creating enough good chances to score 4-6 goals? We should have given him more chances, I don't really understand why ETH didn't give him a shot in more games but the chances he had, he was above average at best. People have to stop talking about us spending money on squad players right now. Our first team needs serious work, the time to buy squad players isn't now.
The state of this. Now we are below scraping the barrel with the quality of posting.
Agreed. Should have listened to you.
He's not good enough, he's lacking in mobility in my opinion and his passing is equally lacking. Even last night, in what was a better performance for him, he found himself on the wrong side of his man often and was having to make silly fouls etc. He's the type of player that city will be hoping plays in the final as their players will tie him in knots if they're on their game. Quick passing around him and the ability to go past him, the bigger pitch at Wembley, he'll struggle if he plays.
You can go through the league and there's many midfielders more equipped than him.
You can go through the league and there's many midfielders more equipped than him.
People forget how much time foreign players take to adjust to the premier league. We would have sold Vidic and Evra going by todays expectations.
Funnily, It seems like the biggest problem Amrabat has is that he’s slow in everything - turn, reactions, passing, decision making etc. He has struggled to adapt to the pace of the league and now that we see visible signs that he is finally doing that, people want him gone.
Funnily, It seems like the biggest problem Amrabat has is that he’s slow in everything - turn, reactions, passing, decision making etc. He has struggled to adapt to the pace of the league and now that we see visible signs that he is finally doing that, people want him gone.
He's not though. He still hasn't shown himself to be anywhere near the standard required, even for a squad player.
- Status