Sneijder or Arteta

M160RA

Full Member
Joined
Nov 6, 2005
Messages
5,085
Let's assume that FM is wrong (:eek:)...

Who would be a better addition to the squad for us?
 
I'd say Arteta, more versatile and suited for PL.
 
I like both of them, but I'd say Arteta has looked a real class act, I haven't watched Sneijder play in ages so it'd be Arteta for me. Really creative and tidy in possession, scores goals and has fanastic versatility. Same can easily be said for Sneijder, I think Arteta has an edge in terms of passing and inventiveness though
 
Arteta, as I don't fancy Sneijder as Scholes replacement at all. Nevertheless, I'm also afraid that Arteta isn't anywhere near this level but a bit of learning at Old Trafford could serve him well and develop him into a really fine midfielder.

He's also more versatile.
 
I'd take Arteta purely because he's already proven himself in the PL. Think he'd also be a bit more solid defensively actually.
 
I don't know why Premiership experience should be a factor.
 
Arteta, im a big fan of him TBH. he would make a great addition, verstile, PL experience and good age.
 
Arteta's not bad, but he'd want to piss of to Spain at the first sight of a straw donkey. Even if he's only gonna be a squad player I wouldn't want that kind of unsettling influence in the dressing room.

I've never seen anything too inspiring in Sneijder either, for that matter.
 
Arteta's not bad, but he'd want to piss of to Spain at the first sight of a straw donkey. Even if he's only gonna be a squad player I wouldn't want that kind of unsettling influence in the dressing room.

I've never seen anything too inspiring in Sneijder either, for that matter.
He played briefly in Spain before returning to Britain, I don't see why he'd automatically jump at the chance of moving back there
 
Speaking of Arteta,what about Cahill?I think he's a cracking player,and wouldn't break the bank

Plays for an English side, is a regular there and could be mentioned in the same breath as their most important players.

12+ million.
 
Arteta over Sneijder!! U mans having a laff... Sneijder all the way He's more tecnically gifted and works his socks off like Scholes
 
Arteta over Sneijder!! U mans having a laff... Sneijder all the way He's more tecnically gifted and works his socks off like Scholes
No we're are not. No way in hell Sneijder is more technically gifted. He is just way better at shooting and free kicks. The two most underated midfielders in Europe imo.


I want both though. You can only want one if you like. You dig?:D