Scott McTominay | Napoli

Ah, you watch football with your eyes closed until a goal goes in. Fair enough, I can see why you'd be a McTominay fan.

Even then I don't really understand it. He averaged about 3 goals a season at Utd.

His best ever scoring season last year that apparently cemented him as this lifelong goalscoring beast saw him score 1 more goal than Hojlund currently has this season.
 
We'll never have a proper United team until fans and the manager wake up to us needing CM'S or attacking CM's who can receive, turn and pass a football.

You've watched us struggle for years with McTominay in the team. Watching us struggle to control games.

That we haven't yet improved doesn't justify sticking with what wasn't working.

Last season was a disaster as well remember.
Nobody said we don't need CMs who are comfortable on the ball and generally much much better outfield players. That's nothing to do with McT, he was never good enough to be a regular CM feature for a team like Manchester United, he only had a certain skill set that was useful for a team lacking goal output and general quality all over the field. We struggle for years because we waste 60m pounds on crap player like Mount or washed up past greats like Casemiro, without an ounce of planning and vision. We will probably do the same with Ugarte, trying to partner him with Bruno who is borderline good enough CAM and never a CM. And to fans like you, you will grab on someone like McT and point out how we struggle because of a squad player, while overlooking much bigger issues.

You pulled a very laughable line when you mentioned Mount who is absolute crap and useless just like he demonstrated today. I bet McT would have been much more of use to this team of ours today than Mount was.
 
Ah, you watch football with your eyes closed until a goal goes in. Fair enough, I can see why you'd be a McTominay fan.
And you probably watch football on whoscored rating website? I bet you think Bruno is the best CAM in the league don't you sunshine?
 
Nobody said we don't need CMs who are comfortable on the ball and generally much much better outfield players. That's nothing to do with McT, he was never good enough to be a regular CM feature for a team like Manchester United, he only had a certain skill set that was useful for a team lacking goal output and general quality all over the field. We struggle for years because we waste 60m pounds on crap player like Mount or washed up past greats like Casemiro, without an ounce of planning and vision. We will probably do the same with Ugarte, trying to partner him with Bruno who is borderline good enough CAM and never a CM. And to fans like you, you will grab on someone like McT and point out how we struggle because of a squad player, while overlooking much bigger issues.

You pulled a very laughable line when you mentioned Mount who is absolute crap and useless just like he demonstrated today. I bet McT would have been much more of use to this team of ours today than Mount was.

Bud if you want McTominay as the number 10 at United what can I say. We're a million miles apart on this.
 
And you probably watch football on whoscored rating website? I bet you think Bruno is the best CAM in the league don't you sunshine?
Nah, I watch actual games, which is how I know that Scott McTominay can't help you control a game, receive the ball in deep positions, take the ball on the half turn, turn away from pressure in tight spaces, see a pass beyond the obvious, create chances or generally do anything else you'd actually want a central midfielder to do with the ball.
 
Nah, I watch actual games, which is how I know that Scott McTominay can't help you control a game, receive the ball in deep positions, take the ball on the half turn, turn away from pressure in tight spaces, see a pass beyond the obvious, create chances or generally do anything else you'd actually want a central midfielder to do with the ball.
Well yeah because he's not a central midfielder. We've been over this already

It's like complaining about Bruno Fernandes not being able to win headers, mark his man, dominate the box or have recovery pace to close down attackers who get in behind
 
Bud if you want McTominay as the number 10 at United what can I say. We're a million miles apart on this.
It's not about what I want. You pointed out to his passing stats and why nobody should miss him, and how Mount was better. I think that's very laughable take, that's all.
 
Well yeah because he's not a central midfielder. We've been over this already
He can't do any of the things you want from a 10 or second striker either unless you're Sean Dyche or the upmarket version, Conte.
 
Nah, I watch actual games, which is how I know that Scott McTominay can't help you control a game, receive the ball in deep positions, take the ball on the half turn, turn away from pressure in tight spaces, see a pass beyond the obvious, create chances or generally do anything else you'd actually want a central midfielder to do with the ball.
And here is the actual problem with some of you. We have players like Ugarte and Bruno all season playing in central midfield, Casemiro and Mainoo today, and we still control feck all of the game. You still think McT was going to make or break our control of games when he was here? Not sure who was watching games with their eyes closed buddy. You also call out on stats, when you have the best stats merchant in the league in Bruno, and he is a constant in all of our midfields while we lack control. The problem? It must have been McT? ;)
 
It's not about what I want. You pointed out to his passing stats and why nobody should miss him, and how Mount was better. I think that's very laughable take, that's all.

And you don't care how a 10 at United passes the ball. Your words.

I prefer a 10 who can, you know, pass the round thing.

Mount isn't the answer, nobody has said that. I just think he's a more talented player. It's irrelevant though given Mount can't stick three games together.
 
He can't do any of the things you want from a 10 or second striker either unless you're Sean Dyche or the upmarket version, Conte.
Bizarre take when considering Conte is one of the most successful managers of this era

Like seriously, your club keeps hiring significantly worse managers than Conte and then complain that it's all the players fault for looking like the worst coached team in the world
 
He can't do any of the things you want from a 10 or second striker either unless you're Sean Dyche or the upmarket version, Conte.
Or unless you're Amorim, where Harry Maguire looks the most dangerous forward in the team
 
And you don't care how a 10 at United passes the ball. Your words.

I prefer a 10 who can, you know, pass the round thing.

Mount isn't the answer, nobody has said that. I just think he's a more talented player. It's irrelevant though given Mount can't stick three games together.
And here we go again, firstly we weren't even talking about a 10 at United, you originally posted about his passing stats. In my opinion his best role was b2b for us, since he was sometimes very good ball carrier but otherwise technically limited. I know what I prefer from a United midfield, you picked one thing and choose to use it as a beating stick. Scotty had his uses if you had low expectations from him, which I did to be hones.

McT whether you think is more or less talented than Mount had one thing more useful for us than, and that was a goal threat when we needed something different, Mount offer nothing on the flip side. And goal scoring is the most important think in football however we twist it, don't you agree?
 
And here is the actual problem with some of you. We have players like Ugarte and Bruno all season playing in central midfield, Casemiro and Mainoo today, and we still control feck all of the game. You still think McT was going to make or break our control of games when he was here? Not sure who was watching games with their eyes closed buddy. You also call out on stats, when you have the best stats merchant in the league in Bruno, and he is a constant in all of our midfields while we lack control. The problem? It must have been McT? ;)
We really didn't control the game until we made our subs.
 
And here we go again, firstly we weren't even talking about a 10 at United, you originally posted about his passing stats. In my opinion his best role was b2b for us, since he was sometimes very good ball carrier but otherwise technically limited. I know what I prefer from a United midfield, you picked one thing and choose to use it as a beating stick. Scotty had his uses if you had low expectations from him, which I did to be hones.

McT whether you think is more or less talented than Mount had one thing more useful for us than, and that was a goal threat when we needed something different, Mount offer nothing on the flip side. And goal scoring is the most important think in football however we twist it, don't you agree?

Look you can keep changing McTominays position but I think wherever you play in a United midfield you need a good first touch, vision and passing ability. You don't obviously. Enough said about that I think as we can't agree.

I'm hesitant to get dragged into a Mount vs McTomiany debate because as I mentioned its irrelevant. Mount arriving doesn't mean selling McTominay was the wrong decision. The two aren't connected.

But before Mount was basically permanently injured who out of the two do you think had the better goal scoring record?
 
Look you can keep changing McTominays position but I think wherever you play in a United midfield you need a good first touch, vision and passing ability. You don't obviously. Enough said about that I think as we can't agree.

I'm hesitant to get dragged into a Mount vs McTomiany debate because as I mentioned its irrelevant. Mount arriving doesn't mean selling McTominay was the wrong decision. The two aren't connected.

But before Mount was basically permanently injured who out of the two do you think had the better goal scoring record?
I imagine mctominay.
 
I imagine mctominay.

I think Mount.

McTominay only started properly being a goal threat last season really when he got 10 overall. Before that he got 3,2,7, 5,2,0.

Theres not much in it either way when we're saying the one thing McTominay has over Mount is goals.

It doesn't matter really because Mount can't get on the pitch but my point was about talent.
 
I think Mount.

McTominay only started properly being a goal threat last season really when he got 10 overall. Before that he got 3,2,7, 5,2,0.

Theres not much in it either way when we're saying the one thing McTominay has over Mount is goals.

It doesn't matter really because Mount can't get on the pitch but my point was about talent.
McTominay was miss profiled by United. Playing as a 6 or a deep 8 instead of 8/10 goalscoring midfielder before last season.
 
We're a strange fanbase. Existing players not being good enough is not justification enough to pine for McTominay. I liked the guy, and he'd have no doubt been useful this season from the bench - but he just wasnt good enough for where we want to be. The same can be said for many of our players, and I expect they will be offloaded too. Ultimately if we're talking about him being in a more advanced role, and offloading him meant it was easier to sign Zirkzee for example, it is not an example of poor squad management.

Squads take a few windows to turn over, and one way or another McTominay was going to have to go.
 
McTominay was miss profiled by United. Playing as a 6 or a deep 8 instead of 8/10 goalscoring midfielder before last season.

Yeah agree.

But Mounts last three seasons before the injuries hit he got 8,9 and 13. 11 for Derby, 14 for Vitesse.

So roughly the same as McTominay when he plays as a 10 or second striker.

There's nothing in it in terms of goals.
 
Yeah agree.

But Mounts last three seasons before the injuries hit he got 8,9 and 13. 11 for Derby, 14 for Vitesse.

So roughly the same as McTominay when he plays as a 10 or second striker.

There's nothing in it in terms of goals.

I never liked Scott's weakness as a ball player. Like Fellaini, if you don't have that in this league, you're at best an impact sub at the level we want to be at.

I'm delighted at how well he's doing in Italy. Seems like a decent bloke.
 
I never liked Scott's weakness as a ball player. Like Fellaini, if you don't have that in this league, you're at best an impact sub at the level we want to be at.

I'm delighted at how well he's doing in Italy. Seems like a decent bloke.

He does. Watched him since his U21 days so very happy for him.

I'd have kept and used him as a 9, rotating with Hojlund this season. Far from perfect but would have helped in the short term.
 
He does. Watched him since his U21 days so very happy for him.

I'd have kept and used him as a 9, rotating with Hojlund this season. Far from perfect but would have helped in the short term.

Oh it'd be better to have him now than not have him for sure. But we needed to shift him for financial reasons, which is very annoying. He made the Ugarte signing possible? And that's a plus for me.
 
He strikes again. I hope we have a league winners clause hahaha
 
Commentator suggesting he could be Serie A player of the season if Napoli win the title.

He’s scored some of the biggest/most critical goals for Napoli this season so if they win the title there’s definitely a shout. He’s been one of the top players for Napoli this season no doubt
 
And people wanted him out and even said players like Rice are better. Just laughable. This guy is leading Napoli towards League title.
 
And people wanted him out and even said players like Rice are better. Just laughable. This guy is leading Napoli towards League title.
Rice is better let's not be silly. He's a very good player though and not the reason we were doing badly. Although people on here blamed him and Fred (Another one underrated by our fans).
 
I have a feeling his goals will be crucial for Napoli’s title push in these last 5 games. He has a knack of coming up big with the game winner/equalizer.

Already scored 4-5 big goals this season for the Partenopei.

He did it again!
 
Rice is better let's not be silly. He's a very good player though and not the reason we were doing badly. Although people on here blamed him and Fred (Another one underrated by our fans).

Fred and Scottie are good players that will work in the right situations/set-up.
 
Genuine question, if McT ends up winning the title for Napoli where does that rank in British players abroad in achievements?
 
He’s scored some of the biggest/most critical goals for Napoli this season so if they win the title there’s definitely a shout. He’s been one of the top players for Napoli this season no doubt
Surely, Orsolini scored Napoli's most important goal ;)