Romelu Lukaku | United confirm deal subject to medical and personal terms

How do you feel about the imminent signing of Romelu Lukaku?

  • Muppetastic!

    Votes: 456 20.6%
  • Happy enough

    Votes: 1,222 55.2%
  • Ambivalent

    Votes: 370 16.7%
  • Disappointed

    Votes: 112 5.1%
  • Oh please god no!

    Votes: 54 2.4%

  • Total voters
    2,214
Status
Not open for further replies.
There are doubts, but then again there were doubts regarding all of our potential markets, whether that's Morata, Belotti or Lukaku. There are many arguments to be made for Lukaku to be a success at United. Now it's just a matter of being positive and believing in those.

Fair points. I don't think Morata or Belotti would have been better options. I just think it's just a sign of the quality of the market and what constitutes a "huge signing" these days.
 
The good thing about Lukaku is how much he improved last season. That game against Bournemouth shows the player he is now. A really top centre forward. Still, he is not the finished article as proven with his performance against us at OT. But at least we are buying players for the future now.

Against Bournemouth. Exactly.
 
A highly talented young French player that's 3RD choice for both LW and CF position in UTD on the on side. The richest French club that is always looking to sign top French talent and can offer them first team football in most cases, CL and trophies guaranteed every year, if your smart enough you can see potential PSG bid looming, especially considering they're probably shipping off Di Maria to Inter and Moura is also tagged for exit with Roma showing the biggest interest in him plus not to mention that Aubameyang deal failed.
Stop digging.
 
A highly talented young French player that's 3RD choice for both LW and CF position in UTD on the on side. The richest French club that is always looking to sign top French talent and can offer them first team football in most cases, CL and trophies guaranteed every year, if your smart enough you can see potential PSG bid looming, especially considering they're probably shipping off Di Maria to Inter and Moura is also tagged for exit with Roma showing the biggest interest in him plus not to mention that Aubameyang deal failed.

right, so mystic meg stuff then? :lol: i'd hazard a guess that "3+3=8 if you're smart enough" reasoning is how most tabloids write their columns

anyway this isn't even amusing anymore. maybe you're right and we'll sell him to psg.
 
Anyone else not terribly excited about Lukaku?

I think my problem is that with every big signing I seem to rate it by asking, "Would Fergie have signed him?"

I think he's just a big lump. Can you see him forcing one in in the 92nd minute? I don't.

He scored 25 league goals last year. Would love to see against who against.

His stats:
0.46 goals per game
45% on target
60 big chances missed

Last season
0.5 goals per game
50% on target
8 big chances missed

£75m for the sake of buying someone, or indeed so someone else doesn't sign him.

Incredibly uninspiring.

I feel the same. I really can't understand why coming into this thread people are seemingly as excited as if we signed Ronaldinho in his prime. I remember being excited by him when he was like 18 and bought by Chelsea because he was a beast but since then? Meh. Admittedly I don't watch enough of him but I can't help but feel that we overpaid by about 30m. I guess he'll do his talking out on the pitch. You can't say 'one for the future' about a 24 year old unless you're saying he's gong to turn out like Zlatan. One for the future is a 16/17 year old.
 
It's confusing seeing people talking to themselves, until I realise they're actually replying to that WUM GlastonSpur. The ignore feature is wonderful, I highly recommend it.
 
Add-ons are additional monies that usually end up being paid.

I'm not sure why there is so much push-back on the £90m figure, unless it's embarrassment.
So if you had a new job where you had the possibility of earning bonuses you would include those bonuses when you quoted your salary?

I don't know why there is so much desperation on your part to inflate the price. Perhaps it's disappointment that we haven't blown nearly as much money as you would have hoped.
 
Hard work starts for him now. Granted he scored x numbers of goals for Everton and is league's second highest scorer in last five years, he is about to change to a team with an entirely different setup, entirely different mentality and entirely different reputation/responsibilities.

I, personally like strikers who are more clever and contribute more to the overall gameplay but have to admit that strikers of the mold of Lukaku are the ones who actually do really well at Old Trafford, especially when it comes to keeping the goal tally moving upwards. I never rated Hernandez due to him being unable to be involved our overall gameplay but over the years, post his departure, I have learned to admire his knack for scoring goals, some very crucial ones at that. I wouldn't mind having him back here now. So, I am fairly open to the idea of Lukaku leading the line for us and am optimistic about his future here, excited even. Our transfer dealings have reached a point where buying traditional wingers and out and out goal scorers feels like a welcome change and maybe not doing that more often is what modern day United had been doing wrong in the transfer market for the past four years.
 

No, I always use the total fee, including all potential add-ons .... because in most cases the add-ons end up being paid.

I don't include agents fees, because usually these are not individually cited.

Add-ons are additional monies that usually end up being paid.

I'm not sure why there is so much push-back on the £90m figure, unless it's embarrassment.

No, it doesn't.

It cites "an initial £75m", and then cites "£15m in add-ons". Add-ons are not part of any initial fee.

Yes, and it's quite clear that the deal is £75m initially, plus £15m in potential add-ons.

No - we're citing the deal reported by the BBC, which is £75m + an additional potential £15m. The question you should be asking is why so many United fans are trying to deny these figures.

Yes, and the total deal is potentially £90m ... and most add-ons end up being paid.

The table would look rather different if you convert it to goals-scored-per-minutes played.

Someone seems awfully bothered about Manchester United buying Lukaku.
 
The table would look rather different if you convert it to goals-scored-per-minutes played.

The fact that he only missed one game last season is a great thing by United standards. That's worth about 30m£ for us.
 
He's better than a lot of what is available right now, so can't really complain. That video of his first touches was pretty worrisome, but hopefully his other qualities will overshadow his shortcomings. And that video of him and Pogba shows that he's genuinely excited to be here, and I've always got time for players that actually *want* to be here.
 
Reports of him being arrested in LA for disturbing the peace:confused:. Not sure if true yet.
On July 2nd after neighbours called the cops regarding a noisy house party. He wasn't charged, or even taken to the police station. Wonder why it's taken until now to emerge. :rolleyes:

Oh, and why is a Spurs fan in here arguing about the fee?
 
I was about to post about this too. Their all round play is different, but of a similar level. Kane scores more because he has better players around him but I don't see a big difference either way.

If Lukaku is worth £75m then Kane is worth £70-80m. He'll go for more when he goes because Levy and English tax, but that's the only big difference.

Lol ... check the goals-scored-per-minutes-played stats.
 
It's not even a particularly big fee any more. Two or three players will go for more this summer, and the first £100m player is imminent.

Not my ideal signing but the market for strikers isn't great at the moment. Everyone wanted Griezmann but he turned us down, so who else were we going to sign? Mbappe would have cost £120m, Aubemayang is 27, Morata has never been a regular starter and would, by all accounts, have cost just as much if not more.

Hopefully it'll come off, but United are so strong financially that we can offload and replace him in a couple of years if it doesn't.
 
On July 2nd after neighbours called the cops regarding a noisy house party. He wasn't charged, or even taken to the police station. Wonder why it's taken until now to emerge. :rolleyes:

Oh, and why is a Spurs fan in here arguing about the fee?
Good to hear, Also, I have just read that all that happened was they gave him a citation.
 
Someone seems awfully bothered about Manchester United buying Lukaku.
He cares about business more than he cares about football. I don't know why he doesn't just support McDonalds or Coca-Cola.

For what it's worth, he can dissect a single deal all he likes. United are still better at business than Spurs. And we're more successful on the pitch, too. I reckon the first of those two points hurts him more.
 
So if you had a new job where you had the possibility of earning bonuses you would include those bonuses when you quoted your salary?

I don't know why there is so much desperation on your part to inflate the price. Perhaps it's disappointment that we haven't blown nearly as much money as you would have hoped.

I'm not inflating then price. I'm citing the total potential fee, which I always do for all players for all clubs whenever I cite fees.
 
Seeing as Lukaku is costing £90m, I can only wonder at Kane's valuation.
who cares really though? :lol:

The fee could be 100m and I wouldn't care, the only fans that tend to give a shit and cite fees all the time are the jealous ones that know their club can't compete in this market.
 
His Instagram has gone from 479k to 518k overnight. The United effect I imagine .
 
It's confusing seeing people talking to themselves, until I realise they're actually replying to that WUM GlastonSpur. The ignore feature is wonderful, I highly recommend it.

The guy doesn't wind me up nearly as much as the United fans who entertain him all the time despite the ridiculous topics he wants to talk about. All of us know the actual price, all of us know about add ons, most of us aren't remotely concerned but still people have to come out to defend United's dealing and carry out borderline nonsensical discussions.

What winds me up is the garbage posts I have to read before I stumble onto a quality post actually talking about the things that matter in this transfer.
 
I'm not inflating then price. I'm citing the total potential fee, which I always do for all players for all clubs whenever I cite fees.
Potential. So the fee is not 90mil is it? It's not difficult to comprehend. This is what you said.:

Seeing as Lukaku is costing £90m, I can only wonder at Kane's valuation.
 
Lol ... check the goals-scored-per-minutes-played stats.

Take out the pens.

Last two seasons goals from open play:

Lukaku 23+ 17=40
Kane 25 + 20 =45

Assists


Lukaku 12
Kane 8

Goals and Assists combined.

52v 53.

Not much in it.
 
Never mind. You don't like the £90m figure. I get it.
This is what you said:

Seeing as Lukaku is costing £90m, I can only wonder at Kane's valuation.
Is costing, 'is'. Now tell me how that, in any way, nods to a potential price?

Can you enlighten us with that these addons are. Why they will definitely be paid? How you know most add ons are paid? What stats you used to come to this conclusion?
 
Excited about this one now. First time in ages we've spent big on a striker, I think he's going to be great for us.
 
Take out the pens.

Last two seasons goals from open play:

Lukaku 23+ 17=40
Kane 25 + 20 =45

Assists

Kane 8
Lukaku 12

Goals and Assists combined.

52v 53.

Not much in it.

I see, take out the pens. Then switch from starting in 2012-13 (as compared to the original post) to just looking at the last 2 seasons. Then add in assists rather than just goals. And hey presto ....
 
Take out the pens.

Last two seasons goals from open play:

Lukaku 23+ 17=40
Kane 25 + 20 =45

Assists


Lukaku 12
Kane 8

Goals and Assists combined.

52v 53.

Not much in it.

That's a knock out punch. He will ignore it though.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.