Romelu Lukaku | United confirm deal subject to medical and personal terms

How do you feel about the imminent signing of Romelu Lukaku?

  • Muppetastic!

    Votes: 456 20.6%
  • Happy enough

    Votes: 1,222 55.2%
  • Ambivalent

    Votes: 370 16.7%
  • Disappointed

    Votes: 112 5.1%
  • Oh please god no!

    Votes: 54 2.4%

  • Total voters
    2,214
Status
Not open for further replies.
Watching that makes me rememner what a great season he had. We actually played some nice football that season. Even rooney looks good in that video.
I don't think he'll ever have the same season playing off Lukaku. Not unless Lukaku decides to develop Welbeck-levels of selfless off-the-ball running. But, then, that's not we're paying £75m for, so it's a hopeless scenario.

We're going to need new wingers (proper wingers, not AMs playing nominally out wide), and one of Martial or Rashford will leave next season. It seems like an unnecessary complication to introduce, when we're already deeply mired in transition.
 
I've heard a lot of nonsense today about Lukaku being a bit of a flat track bully and only scoring against the rubbish. If that's the case then great, it's not the four or five head to heads with the big boys that win you titles it's beating most of the 15 or 16 lesser teams and if he only does the business against those and helps us to turn draws into wins then quite simply we will win the title.

We'd have won it last season if we'd had a man who could stick the ball in the net against Burnley, WBA, Hull, Stoke, Swansea and so on.
 
Can you imagine the sort of apocalyptic meltdown there'd be if we were chasing him all summer and Chelsea swooped in and got him? Ed would be torn to pieces. I wonder how Chelsea fans are taking it?

The Caf' would break under the strain of the new threads being created, all full of angst and outrage, there'd be a huge release of furious energy across twitter, on sports media comment sections, Manchester United's Facebook page would become a tea party of the damned.

It'd be glorious.
 
Can you imagine the sort of apocalyptic meltdown there'd be if we were chasing him all summer and Chelsea swooped in and got him? Ed would be torn to pieces. I wonder how Chelsea fans are taking it?
That's the genius of this transfer though. If we get him, celebration. If we don't, we *genuinely* never wanted him. It's perfect.
 
Seems to be some bitter Everton fans too.
can't blame Them. He kind of always made it seem that he only saw to use them as a stepping stone to launch his career. Didn't look like he had any love for the club and was openly talking about moving. Strikes me as a lad that will celebrate the moment he scores vs them
 
can't blame Them. He kind of always made it seem that he only saw to use them as a stepping stone to launch his career. Didn't look like he had any love for the club and was openly talking about moving. Strikes me as a lad that will celebrate the moment he scores vs them
I remember he didn't celebrate when he scored vs West Brom but I do agree with everything else you said. He has used them as a stepping stone almost openly.
 
Just to clarify, I think he's a top player. He'll be a success in the long run. But this is a backwards step in terms of balancing the squad. Lukaku as our first choice striker will create as many problems as it will solves, as far as player recruitment is concerned.

Mourinho's just extended our transition phase by an extra season, imo.
 
Just to clarify, I think he's a top player. He'll be a success in the long run. But this is a backwards step in terms of balancing the squad. Lukaku as our first choice striker will create as many problems as it will solve as far as player recruitment is concerned.

Mourinho's just extended our transition phase by an extra season, imo.
How?
 
Morata plays across the width of the pitch and makes a lot of runs that open up space for wide forwards to exploit by cutting in.

Lukaku plays within the width of the penalty area and almost only takes up positions in the box to get on the end of chances that are created from wide positions. Not too dissimilar to Zlatan, albeit a hell of a lot more mobile.

Neither Martial nor Rashford are widemen, but they can cut in from wide if the striker creates the space for them to do so. As such, Lukaku is the wrong man to do that for them.

To illustrate, here's a vid of Martial's best season. Bear in mind that he created relatively little from the left. Almost all of his good work related to him getting on the end of chances. Even at his best, he was little more than a striker stuck out on the wing. Look at this past season and you'll see how stranded he looked tethered to the touchline for whole matches as Ibrahimovic got into the very positions he wanted to be in. Lukaku will only exacerbate that. The same applies to Rashford (although not quite to the same extent as Rashford can at least cross the ball).

Other than the Liverpool goal, Martial was a central striker in all but name:



None of which is to say Lukaku is a bad player. He's not. He's probably about par with Morata. But he's a cog for the wrong machine. Putting up this outlay effectively means undermining the existing quality we have in attack, rather than supporting it.



It is what it is , Morata may be more a right fit, He was quoted an unrealistic price and also was untested in epl for such a price. I belive if martial and MKh are freed up of defensive duties with a proper midfeild balance they will score a lot more as well. and I have seen lukaku sometimes drifting out wide. Mourinho will find a solution.
 
Just to clarify, I think he's a top player. He'll be a success in the long run. But this is a backwards step in terms of balancing the squad. Lukaku as our first choice striker will create as many problems as it will solves, as far as player recruitment is concerned.

Mourinho's just extended our transition phase by an extra season, imo.

This post doesn't make sense at all mate
 
Probably explains why Mourinho is insistent on signing Perisic. Wants a winger to create more space up front for a player like Lukaku who isn't the best with the ball at his feet.
 
Exactly Point to Point. :D Exellent assesment.

Fergie's gambling instinct was the thing which made it Absolutely rocking. That is why Fergie time existed and that's why we scored so many late goals and never gave up until the very end. Mourinho is not the clone of fergie but he thinks the same in lots of ways and that's why he has won the league and won every where in the world, and can Use some of the same Dynamics in Posession while in attack To make us better against all the smaller teams we drew last year as our transition was never resulting in some counter attacking dynamics.

Alsowhat you said about the european Philosophies being antidote to the fergie way was one of the exact reasons for Him being an under achiver in the european competions. Its a Key Paradox and difference between the PL and CL.

But one thing I would like to add in this is the Education and Play style Lvg Set up in two years for united and built his Foundations on was exactly that same european Philosophies and principles Of possesion based system. A high press and High line helps in recovering the ball in a proactive way which contributes in defense in a better way and wins back the ball proactively in the midddle itself

And Mourinho after the 3 defeats realized that and adapted to the same tactics and philosophies, so we found all the smaller teams park the bus against us. If we Play the same way this season like last season with a Mobile attacking focal point and Also add some same fergie /mourinho Direct counter attacking dynamics in the build up and play a Mix of Possesion based Principles while adding directness and faster transition In posession When Required to score goals and create more space The goal scoring problems can be solved , While Having to Be proactive and high press in defense to win the posession back in the middle itself without having to drop a deep line defense will see us getting to a better level in european stages as well against top class european sides too because this team is capable of doing that with High pressing midfeilders like Herrera and Pogba Or a new DM and also defenders who can play a high line in bailly and lindelof with ball playing abilities in posession Like a Pep or klopp team does or barcelona or real madrid or bayern do too because of those similar possession based principles. They executed it better because they had great player to do so in the midfeild , Which i belive we also have.
Cheers! I pretty much agree with everything. The thing I am not sure about though is the implication that we or anybody else really, can just change styles and be able to play directly or win the ball high up and play pro actively whenever needed. If that was possible, every manager would do that as obviously it's the best strategy; be ready for every scenario. The reality however is you need practice and tons of it. One of the reasons Barcelona became so brilliant at what they did is that they were trying to do it every game for example. The other point is Mourinho himself. He has never built a team that can play a highly demanding tactical setup which is what is needed if you want to play higher up. The main reasons for that are exactly what I mentioned before, it takes time and practice and with that naturally mistakes and he is simply not willing or incapable of doing that. So I wouldn't be sure that we can mix styles that easily regardless of the calibre of players we have.
 
Wrong, wrong and wrong. They bought him, did play him but he wasn't their number 1 striker, Real activated a buy back clause to get him back.
Fine, my mistake. He scored 15 goals in 63 appearances. Seems they did play him, but he did not score. What is your point? He was not up to standard?
 
Fine, my mistake. He scored 15 goals in 63 appearances. Seems they did play him, but he did not score. What is your point? He was not up to standard?
What are you talking about? I said in my post he wasn't their number 1 striker. They had Tevez in his first season at Juve and Dybala the year after. They were their first choice forwards.

The point of my post was you were wrong, three times. In one post.
 
Fine, my mistake. He scored 15 goals in 63 appearances. Seems they did play him, but he did not score. What is your point? He was not up to standard?
He had to be bedded in since he was struggling with life in Italy in the beginning. A lot of those appearances were also subs. By the end of his time there he was trusted to start their biggest game and scored both in the CL semi and final. Real then bought him back at the amount stipulated.
 
What are you talking about? I said in my post he wasn't their number 1 striker. They had Tevez in his first season at Juve and Dybala the year after. They were their first choice forwards.

The point of my post was you were wrong, three times. In one post.
Mandzukic, not Dybala.
 
I remember he didn't celebrate when he scored vs West Brom but I do agree with everything else you said. He has used them as a stepping stone almost openly.
I don't mind really this. If you have the ambition to be the best in the business then Everton are always going to be a stepping stone. Even Rooney realised that at 18 despite supporting the club his whole life.
 
Just to clarify, I think he's a top player. He'll be a success in the long run. But this is a backwards step in terms of balancing the squad. Lukaku as our first choice striker will create as many problems as it will solves, as far as player recruitment is concerned.

Mourinho's just extended our transition phase by an extra season, imo.

That depends if you view our transition to be the United of old or a stubborn Mourinho side. If the latter, I think Lukaku suits us fine. He seems the ideal Mourinho 9, I'm quite surprised he ever sold him.
 
In the last two premier league season's only Harry Kane - 54 and Sergio Aguero - 44 have scored more goals than Lukaku - 43... and he did it for Everton who finished 11th & 7th in those two season's.
 
Last edited:
He's a powerhouse centre forward and he's only 24. Can operate as a target man but can also run at players. He'll add more to the team (in a "whole is greater than the sum of its parts" fashion) than Ibra in my opinion. Ibra's hold up play is absolutely superb, one of the best in the world, but I think his immobility was his Achilles' heel.

We still need to add another goal scorer. Not so much to replace Rooney's output, but to replace the output you'd expect of our one of our top 3 highest paid players.

Add two players like Perisic and Matic/Fabinho plus a left back and it could be an incredible window.
 
Premier league goals scored against the top 6 clubs last season.. Lukaku - 4... Kane - 3... Aguero - 3... Costa - 2...

Yeah but can he do it on rainy Monday night in Stoke?

I'm so glad someone got stats to calm the haters. This perfectly shows he just gets goals, which is what we need. We may also need more creativity, but no reason that can't also come this transfer window.
 
Only Rooney, Ronaldo, Owen and Fowler scored as many EPL goals by the age of 23

Only Andy Cole, Shearer, Fowler, Kevin Phillips, Henry, Ronaldo, Drogba, Rooney, van Persie, Suarez, Aguero, Kane have ever scored more than him in a season.
Only Cole, Fowler, Ronaldo, Phillips have scored more in a season at a younger age.

How is this a risky move?
 
That is a very good stat. I think people are missing the point when it comes to Lukaku. Sure, he's not a beautiful player to watch but he's a World class finisher. One of the deadliest around. Get some movement around him and some space and he will score for fun even in games he looks average.
 
I just watched a video of all his goals for Everton.

He has the knack for being at the right place at the right time and finishing the easy chances. Something we've sorely lacked the last few seasons.
 
This post doesn't make sense at all mate
It does? Do you remember how many times we put in a half decent cross from the wing? Or how many times our striker had time and space to run into? We will need to transform the team and get other players to get the best of Lukaku. Martial cant cross to dave his life and Pogba is our only player who speeds up the play with through and long balls.
 
Only Rooney, Ronaldo, Owen and Fowler scored as many EPL goals by the age of 23

Only Andy Cole, Shearer, Fowler, Kevin Phillips, Henry, Ronaldo, Drogba, Rooney, van Persie, Suarez, Aguero, Kane have ever scored more than him in a season.
Only Cole, Fowler, Ronaldo, Phillips have scored more in a season at a younger age.

How is this a risky move?

Use your eyes. This guy isn't in the same class as half of them and it's pretty apparent when you watch him play. I'm not against the signing as there isn't many options this summer but I don't see a world class player.
 
I'd be very happy to see him hear, but are we claiming £75m is a bargain now?:smirk:
Not at all but all of the whispers were £100m. Everton have spent roughly that. I just wonder whether they shat themselves because they spent it and suddenly Chelsea didn't cough up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.