Music RedCafe's Favourite Albums Of All Time Contest (Round 5)

Dirty Schwein

Has a 'Best of Britney Spears' album
Joined
Feb 6, 2012
Messages
36,083
Location
Miracle World
Supports
Luton Town
Round 4 is complete and Backstreet Boys didn't make it :(

The 5 albums progressing are:

Nevermind
OK Computer
In Utero
Illmatic
Loveless

The below 2 albums are going to the Resurrection Round:

What's the Story, Morning Glory (was tied with Loveless but lost on tie-breaker)
The Bends

Note: Please vote within the timing guidelines. Every time you don't do that, it causes me an unnecessary headache.

Full results below:

Nevermind (Nirvana)
98​
OK Computer (Radiohead)
70​
In Utero (Nirvana)
52​
Illmatic (Nas)
38​
Loveless (My Bloody Valentine)
34​
What's the Story, Morning Glory (Oasis)
34​
The Bends (Radiohead)
26​
Dookie (Green Day)
24​
The Chronic (Dr. Dre)
24​
Endtroducing (DJ Shadow)
22​
Rage Against th Machine (Rage Against the Machine)
22​
Automatic for the People (REM)
20​
Definitely Maybe (Oasis)
20​
Homework (Daft Punk)
20​
Ten (Pearl Jam)
20​
In the Aeroplane Over the Sea (Neutral Milk Hotel)
18​
Aquemini (Outkast)
16​
Enema of the State (Blink 182)
16​
Siamese Dream (The Smashing Pumpkins)
16​
2001 (Dr. Dre)
14​
August & Everythign After (Counting Crows)
14​
Moon Safari (Air)
14​
Songs of Faith & Devotion (Depeche Mode)
14​
The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill (Lauryn Hill)
14​
Violator (Depeche Mode)
14​
Achtung Baby (U2)
12​
Adventures Beyond the Ultraworld (The Orb)
12​
Aenima (Tool)
12​
Grace (Jeff Buckley)
12​
Moon Pix (Cat Power)
12​
The Fat of the Land (The Prodigy)
12​
24 Hour Revenge Therapy (Jawbreaker)
10​
Doggystyle (Snoop Dogg)
10​
Dude Ranch (Blink 182)
10​
Ecliptica (Sonata Arctica)
10​
Either/Or (Elliott Smith)
10​
F♯A♯∞ (Godspeed You! Black Emperor)
10​
From Yorkshire 2 New York (Mc Devvo & Shady Piez)
10​
If You're Feeling Sinister (Belle & Sebastian)
10​
Metallica (Metallica)
10​
Millennium (Backstreet Boys)
10​
Out of Time (REM)
10​
Parklife (Blur)
10​
Reasonable Doubt (Jay Z)
10​
Souvlaki (Slowdive)
10​
Sublime (Sublime)
10​
The Downward Spiral (Nine Inch Nails)
10​
The Fragile (Nine Inch Nails)
10​
The Predator (Ice Cube)
10​
The Soft Bulletin (The Flaming Lips)
10​
Thunder Perfect Mind (Current 93)
10​
Low End Theory (Tribe Called Quest)
10​
Mustt Mustt (Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan)
10​
Agaetis Byrjun (Sigur Ros)
8​
Apple Venus Volume 1 (XTC)
8​
Blood Sugar Sex Magik (Red Hot Chilli Peppers)
8​
Different Class (Pulp)
8​
Experience (Prodigy)
8​
Fitzxarraldo (The Frames)
8​
Imaginations from the Other Side (Blind Guardian)
8​
Jagged Little Pill (Alanis Morisette)
8​
Laid (James)
8​
Perfect From Now On (Built to Spill)
8​
Selected Ambient Works 85-92 (Aphex Twin)
8​
Spiderland (Slint)
8​
Static Prevails (Jimmy Eat World)
8​
Superunknown (Soundgarden)
8​
The Holy Bible (Manic Street Preachers)
8​
Trompe Le Monde (Pixies)
8​
Homogenic (Bjork)
8​
808 Skate (Ex:el)
6​
A Different Class (Pulp)
6​
ATLiens (Outkast)
6​
Is This Desire? (PJ Harvey)
6​
Keep The Faith (Bon Jovi)
6​
Leftism (Leftfield)
6​
Middle Class Revolt (The Fall)
6​
Portishead (Portishead)
6​
Ready to Die (Notorious B.I.G)
6​
Soul Cages (Sting)
6​
Still Life (Opeth)
6​
The Score (The Fugees)
6​
Urban Hymms (The Verve)
6​
Vauxhall & I (Morrissey)
6​
Weezer Blue Album (Weezer)
6​
Where I Wanna Be (Donnell Jones)
6​
Californication (Red Hot Chilli Peppers)
6​
A Meeting by the River (Ry Cooder & VM Bhatt)
6​
1 Outside (David Bowie)
4​
Adrenaline Rush (Twista)
4​
Black Sails in the Sunset (AFI)
4​
Dah Shinin' (Smif'N'Wessun)
4​
Dig Your Own Hole (Chemical Brothers)
4​
Dummy (Portishead)
4​
God Fodder (Ned's Atomic Dustbin)
4​
I Could Live in Hope (Low)
4​
Life After Death (Notorious B.I.G)
4​
Mescal Head (Swervedriver)
4​
Pinkerton (Weezer)
4​
Seal (Seal)
4​
The Dark Saga (Iced Earth)
4​
The Slim Shady LP (Eminem)
4​
White Room (KLF)
4​
All Eyez On Me (2Pac)
2​
Black Sunday (Cypress Hill)
2​
Blue Lines (Massive Attack)
2​
Dirth (Alice in Chains)
2​
Don't Sweat the Technique (Erik B & Rakim)
2​
Enter the Wu: 36: Chambers (Wu Tang Clan)
2​
Henry's Dream (Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds)
2​
It Was Written (Nas)
2​
Les Colocs (Les Colocs)
2​
Midnight Marauders (A Tribe Called Quest)
2​
Operation Doomsday (MF Doom)
2​
Pod (The Breeders)
2​
Significant Other (Limp Bizkit)
2​
The Afghan Whigs (Black Love)
2​
The Lonesome Crowded West (Modest Mouse)
2​
Themple of the Dog (Temple of the Dog)
2​
They Might Be Giants (Flood)
2​
This is My Truth, Tell Me Yours (Manic Street Preachers)
2​
Through Silver in Blood (Neurosis)
2​
Uptown Saturday Night (Camp Lo)
2​
Lewis Taylor (Lewis Taylor)
2​

Through so far:

Round 1:
Abbey Road (The Beatles)
Pet Sounds (The Beach Boys)
The Velvet Underground & Nico (The Velvet Underground & Nico)
The Doors (The Doors)
Revolver (The Beatles)

Round 2:
The Dark Side of the Moon (Pink Floyd)
Rumours (Fleetwood Mac)
Unknown Pleasure (Joy Division)
Never Mind The Bullocks (Sex Pistols)
Wish You Were Here (Pink Floyd)

Round 3:
The Queen is Dead (The Smiths)
Disintegration (The Cure)
Thriller (Michael Jackson)
Doolittle (The Pixies)
Apetite for Destruction (Guns n' Roses)

Round 4:
Nevermind (Nirvana)
OK Computer (Radiohead)
In Utero (Nirvana)
Illmatic (Nas)
Loveless (My Bloody Valentine)

Resurrection Round:
Let It Bleed (The Rolling Stones)
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band (The Beatles)
Led Zeppelin IV (Led Zeppelin)
London Calling (The Clash)
The Joshua Tree (U2)
Closer (Joy Division)
What's the Story, Morning Glory (Oasis)
The Bends (Radiohead)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Onto the next round!

Each Monday, I will set up a new round for the contest.
Each round will represent a different decade of albums (I can't check the dates for each album so please make sure yourself).

The decades are below (BOLDED IS THE CURRENT ROUND FOR THIS THREAD):

Round 1 - Up to 1969
Round 2 - 1970-1979
Round 3 - 1980-1989
Round 4 - 1990-1999
Round 5 - 2000-2009
Round 6 - 2010-2019
Round 7 - 2020-Present Day (mini round)
Round 8 - Resurrection Round
Round 9 - The Finals

For each round, please list your top 5 music albums from the decade in list view (album name first, followed by artist).
Please do this by Friday 11:59pm BST (no votes beyond this will be counted).
5th = 2 pts, 4th = 4 pts, 3rd = 6 pts, 2nd = 8 pts, 1st = 10 pts.
The top 5 albums from rounds 1-6 (and top 3 from round 7) will go through to the finals.
The 6th and 7th album from each round (4th and 5th from Round 7) will enter the resurrection round, where 7 albums will go through to the final.
In the event of a tie, I will refer to their AllMusic scores (and then the amount of scores if still a tie).
If you have voted, then changed your vote, please don't edit your vote... instead, reply to it and let me know by tagging me, otherwise I may miss your vote by accident.
I will try to start each new round on the Monday after a vote round has finished.
At the opening post of each round, I will put in the results from the previous round and start the voting of the current round.
Once rounds 1-8 are complete, we head into the final round with 40 albums on the shortlist.
Then once that voting is done, I will post the top 40 in order from last to first and crown the overall winner.

Remember, I have 2 kids and a full time job so there may be times where I miss deadlines or post later than anticipated. Apologies in advance.

I hope this is fun and you guys enjoy it.
 
Last edited:
1. Hybrid Theory (Linkin Park)
2. Born To Do It (Craig David)
3. Marshall Mathers LP (Eminem)
4. Discovery (Daft Punk)
5. 8701 (Usher)

This was the hardest one so far. Had to leave out:

Meteora (Linkin Park)
Songs About Jane (Maroon5)
Justified (Justin Timberlake)
Fallen (Evanescence)
Park Bench Theories (Jamie Scott & The Band)
Big City (Billy Crawford)
What's A Man To Do (Frankie J)

:(

Edit: Think of a way to include Daft Punk - Discovery
 
Last edited:
1. Rock Action (Mogwai)
2. Horses in the Sky (A Silver Mt. Zion)
3. Vampire Weekend (Vampire Weekend)
4. The Crying Light (Antony & The Johnsons)
5. Is This It? (The Strokes)

Honorable mention:

I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning (Bright Eyes)
Is a Woman (Lambchop)
Antidotes (Foals)
The Fountain (Clint Mansell)
Ghost Tropic (Songs: Ohia)
 
1. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens
2. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys
3. Discovery - Daft Punk
4. For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
5. Is This It - The Strokes


This was tough. I debated 4th and 5th positions for a bit and thought about In Rainbows or Kid A but I think enough Radiohead will make it through overall. Madvillainy was in 5th for ages but I went for what I actually listen to more in Is This It.

Honourable mentions then:

Madvillainy - Madvillain
Stankonia - Outkast
Kid A - Radiohead
In Rainbows - Radiohead
Funeral - Arcade Fire
Veckatimest - Grizzly Bear
() - Sigur Ros
Takk... - Sigur Ros
 
Enter Shikari - Take to the Skies
Daft Punk - Discovery
Kanye West - Graduation
Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
 
Think Marshall Matehrs LP might need to get dropped. It's in there because of the amount I listened to it at the time but it has no replay value anymore.
 
Enter Shikari - Take to the Skies
Daft Punk - Discovery
Kanye West - Graduation
Bloc Party - Silent Alarm
Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not
Take to the Skies. Didn't expect to see that. Definitely on my honourable mentions.
 
Arctic Monkeys - Whatever People Say I Am, Thats What I'm Not
The Strokes - Is This It?
The Killers - Hot Fuss
The Libertines - Up The Bracket
System of a Down - Toxicity
 
1. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens
2. Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys
3. Discovery - Daft Punk
4. For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
5. Is This It - The Strokes


This was tough. I debated 4th and 5th positions for a bit and thought about In Rainbows or Kid A but I think enough Radiohead will make it through overall. Madvillainy was in 5th for ages but I went for what I actually listen to more in Is This It.

Honourable mentions then:

Madvillainy - Madvillain
Stankonia - Outkast
Kid A - Radiohead
In Rainbows - Radiohead
Funeral - Arcade Fire
Veckatimest - Grizzly Bear
() - Sigur Ros
Takk... - Sigur Ros
Your 2000s choices are your best yet. Illinois(e) very much in my top 5
 
Ah time for me to start fleet foxing this thread. I’ve waited long enough
 
Your 2000s choices are your best yet. Illinois(e) very much in my top 5
Finally getting the alto approval I crave.

But yes, amazing album. Going to listen to it right now actually.
 
1. Sound of Silver (LCD Soundsystem)
2. The Body, The Blood, The Machine (The Thermals)
3. Illinois(e) (Sufjan Stevens)
4. In Rainbows (Radiohead)
5. The Black Parade (My Chemical Romance)

Honorable mentions:
Talkie Walkie
A Grand Don't Come for Free
Original Pirate Material
Stankonia
Amnesiac
Franz Ferdinand
Kala
Vampire Weekend
Madvillainy
Silent Alarm
The Campfire Headphase
Take to the Skies
Lateralus

Very tough after 1.
 
Last edited:
Will have to edit this when I think of 5.

This is where I really start to struggle - in this decade was when I pretty much stopped listening to new music for a very long time and went backwards instead.

1. Blink 182 - (Untitled)
2. Blink182 - Take off your Pants and Jacket
3. Eminem - The Marshall Mathers LP
4. RHCP - Stadium Arcadium
5. Green Day - American Idiot
 
Last edited:
1. Boxer - The National
2. Hospice - The Antlers
3. Sound of Silver - LCD Soundsystem
4. Funeral - Arcade Fire
5. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens


maybe include later:

For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys
Fleet Foxes


Seems like a lot of potential albums were actually recorded in 2010, nearly enough great albums to make a top 5 from that year alone.
 
Last edited:
1. Hybrid Theory - Linkin Park
2. Marshall Mathers LP - Eminem
3. Toxicity - System of a Down
4. American Idiot - Green Day
5. Origin of Symmetry - Muse
 
Last edited:
1. Boxer - The National
2. Hospice - The Antlers
3. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens
4. Sound of Silver - LCD Soundsystem
5. Funeral - Arcade Fire


maybe include later:

For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys


Seems like a lot of potential albums were actually recorded in 2010, nearly enough great albums to make a top 5 from that year alone.
Somehow forgot about this too. fecking love LCD Soundsystem.

Hospice is a beautiful piece of work as well.
 
1. Hybrid Theory (Linkin Park)
2. Born To Do It (Craig David)
3. 8701 (Usher)
4. Marshall Mathers LP (Eminem)
5. Justified (Justin Timberlake)

This was the hardest one so far. Had to leave out:

Meteora (Linkin Park)
Songs About Jane (Maroon5)
Fallen (Evanescence)
Park Bench Theories (Jamie Scott & The Band)
Big City (Billy Crawford)
What's A Man To Do (Frankie J)

:(

Edit: Think of a way to include Daft Punk - Discovery
I checked my notes for tracking my progress through the "1001 albums you must hear..." list, where I rate the album and add a comment, and I saw this for Hybrid Theory:

Linkin Park: Hybrid Theory - 4/10 - Maybe I wasn't in the mood, but I found it intolerable at times. Turned off quite early
 
I checked my notes for tracking my progress through the "1001 albums you must hear..." list, where I rate the album and add a comment, and I saw this for Hybrid Theory:
You used to be cool :(

 
Somehow forgot about this too. fecking love LCD Soundsystem.

Hospice is a beautiful piece of work as well.
Same. I probably just about prefer This is Happening but that was 2010 so just about misses out this time.

Hospice is indeed beautiful. It's one of those albums that I forget about and then maybe once a year I remember and listen to it on near repeat for a few weeks.
 
Just a friendly note that if Hybrid Theory doesn't make it, I will cancel the contest :)
 
  1. Blueprint - Jay Z
  2. College Dropout - Kanye West
  3. Welcome to Jamrock - Damian Marley
  4. Discovery - Daft Punk
  5. My Name is Joe - Joe
 
1. Boxer - The National
2. Hospice - The Antlers
3. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens
4. Sound of Silver - LCD Soundsystem
5. Funeral - Arcade Fire


maybe include later:

For Emma, Forever Ago - Bon Iver
Whatever People Say I Am, That's What I'm Not - Arctic Monkeys


Seems like a lot of potential albums were actually recorded in 2010, nearly enough great albums to make a top 5 from that year alone.
2 of the same top 5 as me. Just seen yours as been editing my for last ten minutes try to work out an order. SoS number 1 for me though, by a decent margin.
 
  1. Blueprint - Jay Z
  2. College Dropout - Kanye West
  3. Welcome to Jamrock - Damian Marley
  4. Discovery - Daft Punk
  5. My Name is Joe - Joe
denzel-training-day.gif
 
Same. I probably just about prefer This is Happening but that was 2010 so just about misses out this time.

Hospice is indeed beautiful. It's one of those albums that I forget about and then maybe once a year I remember and listen to it on near repeat for a few weeks.
Yep. I’ll go years without listening and then I’ll remember it and Kettering just hits me for six.
 
Same. I probably just about prefer This is Happening but that was 2010 so just about misses out this time.

Hospice is indeed beautiful. It's one of those albums that I forget about and then maybe once a year I remember and listen to it on near repeat for a few weeks.
This is Happening could well be number 1 for 2010s for me also. Incredible two album run. American Dream was pretty good too.
 
This is Happening could well be number 1 for 2010s for me also. Incredible two album run. American Dream was pretty good too.
I think Home might be one of my favourite songs ever.
 
2 of the same top 5 as me. Just seen yours as been editing my for last ten minutes try to work out an order. SoS number 1 for me though, by a decent margin.
This is Happening could well be number 1 for 2010s for me also. Incredible two album run. American Dream was pretty good too.
I think Home might be one of my favourite songs ever.
We're like the same people. Reaching across borders, bringing communities together.
 
1. Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
2. Have one on me - Joanna Newsom
3. Ys - Joanna Newsom
4. For Emma, Forever - Bon Iver
5. All that you can’t leave behind - U2

I wanted to put Stadium Arcadium in there but I think it may have had too much bloat.

I really should listen to Illinois as I love Sufjan’s later work
 
1. Is This It - The Strokes
2. Funeral - Arcade Fire
3. White Blood Cells - The White Stripes
4. Illinois - Sufjan Stevens
5. The Life Pursuit - Belle & Sebastian

Probably the decade I could name the most albums I love from, but the top 10-ish were obvious enough that they've mostly all already been mentioned multiple times above.
 
1. Fleet Foxes - Fleet Foxes
2. Have one on me - Joanna Newsom
3. Ys - Joanna Newsom
4. For Emma, Forever - Bon Iver
5. All that you can’t leave behind - U2

I wanted to put Stadium Arcadium in there but I think it may have had too much bloat.

I really should listen to Illinois as I love Sufjan’s later work
Oh damn, forgot Fleet Foxes.
 
1. ( ) - Sigur Ros
2. Alligator - The National
3. Funeral - Arcade Fire
4. Takk... - Sigur Ros
5. The Music - The Music

Hon. mentions:
Before the Dawn Heals Us - M83
The Lost Riots - Hope of the States
Silent Alarm - Bloc Party
Up the Bracket - The Libertines
I'm Wide Awake, It's Morning - Bright Eyes
Rock Action - Mogwai
 
Last edited: