Moby
Dick
The aim of this poll is to decide the winner in this fantasy game contested between two sides assembled through the method of drafting. For the purpose of this game, all players would be considered as being at their respective peaks. I invite all posters to go through the formations, tactics and arguments that will follow in the thread and kindly leave their vote. Thanks.
Jayvin's Tactics
Overall:
The defence has a blend of brains, brawn and pace. The technically excellent Hierro with the perfect partner in the fast, athletic Thuram. Both easily in the top 10 defenders of the 90s. Evra is quick and skillful while Neville is intelligent and defensively robust.
In midfield there is again a nice balance, with plenty of options in both defence and attack. The unrivaled defensive presence of Deschamps, coupled with the box to box energy of Baraja, the tactical intelligence and discipline of Seedorf and the sublime technique and outrageous skill of Zvonimir Boban.
Up front is the fearsome attacking duo of Ibrahimovic and Shearer, both physically imposing, excellent finishers from any angle or distance, from either foot or head. They will compliment each other well with Ibra able to drop deeper and help to link the play, while Shearer will act as the focal point of the attack and arch-poacher in the box.
The team will be set up to play in a 4-3-3/4-4-2 diamond formation similar to Real Madrid's 1998 CL winning side. With Deschamps in the holding role, Seedorf playing his versatile LCM position, supporting the defensive and attacking phases when required. Ruben Baraja slots perfectly into Christian Karembeau's box to box role on the right, and depending on the opposition has the potential to strike up a great combination with Gary Neville when he bursts forward. Zvonimir Boban takes over Rauls #10 position and up front Predrag Mijatovic and Morientes are vastly improved upon with Ibrahimovic and Shearer.
Every player fits their position and role to a tee and the side strikes the perfect balance between defence and attack.
WHY I WILL WIN:
- Lack of workrate in TITOs front 3, putting enormous pressure on De Rossi and the fullback duo.
- Deco/Scholes v Boban/Seedorf: Scholes/Deco and Boban are all able to play further forward or drop deeper, though in the case of TITOs side I can see Scholes/Deco further forward would getting in the way of Totti/Suarez. Seedorf is a more versatile, robust player than Deco. Deco/Scholes will both want to be playmakers and as neither has the side built around them, they will be far less effective.
- Lack of defensive cover in TITOs side. If De Rossi tracks Boban, the forward runs of Baraja/Seedorf will need to be covered by his fullbacks, allowing my midfielders to release Evra/Neville on the overlap. Conversely, on my side Baraja and Seedorf are more than capable of pressuring Scholes and Deco, particularly Baraja who will give Scholes no time or space whatsoever.
- Savicevic and Suarez will both cut inside more often than not, meaning Hierro and Thuram can take care of them while Deschamps covers Totti, leaving my fullbacks to easily track the runs of Di Livio/Pessotto and effectively render TITOs attack impotent.
PLAYER PROFILES
Team Jayvin
Vs
Team Thisistheone
Starting formation, changed at a lead of 7-6
Vs
Team Thisistheone
Starting formation, changed at a lead of 7-6
Thisistheone's tactics
Formation & how the side will operate
Based on the 2007 Roma side which played a 433 - with el capitano Francesco Totti as the false 9 and creative fulcrum of the team.
The idea of the inside forwards making diagonal runs, whilst the fullbacks overlap on the outside is fantastic - impossible to defend against when executed correctly.
Totti will keep picking it up into feet, from neat and tidy distribution from Scholes, Deco, De Rossi, take one touch and spin, then sweep a pass out to one of the 4 runners – Suarez, Pessotto, Savicevic, Di Livio. (This is also not including any runs made from midfield. Scholes as everyone knows, scored goals.)
The whole side is built around Totti and is aimed at getting the most out of this extraordinary talent. Suarez is a perfect foil next to him. Cutting in from the left he offers pace, work rate and goals.
The team requires good work rate in order to accomadate the duo of Totti and Savicevic. This is provided by proven workaholics such as Suarez, Deco, De Rossi & Di Livio.
The foundations of the side are built on the tried and tested, highly successful Juventus back 5 of the mid 1990’s. Peruzzi, Pessotto, Montero, Ferrara and Di Livio won everything together. At one time forming the best defence in European football. During the mid 90’s Juventus reached 3 consecutive Champions League finals. An incredible achievement.
With the chemistry and proven ability to win , this team will be extremely difficult to score against.
Paul Scholes in midfield brings control to the side, as well as a big goal threat. Our Paul was quite simply a fabulous footballer. And the current Utd side miss him terribly.
Deco brings industry, tackling, and technical ability. A hard working, tenacious all-rounder in his prime, he suits Scholes very well. Offering endless energy and coverage of the pitch.
De Rossi brings the Roma connection to the side with Totti. But also that fight, drive and spirit. An excellent passer in his own right, he will neatly link defence and midfield.
Of course with either Di Livio or Pessotto getting forward at different times, De Rossi has the tactical nous to drop in and cover, holding off the threat of the counter-attack, keeping the shape at the back. Ferrara was capable of playing right back, Montero also was capable at left back. De Rossi has played such a role before with Roma and Italy.
The whole side is bursting with winners. Experienced and seasoned pro’s who have the “know how” required to win. One thing is certain, there will not be a lack of fight in this side.
Breaking down the in-game battles:
· Dejan Savicevic was incredibly quick and a superb dribbler. He will cause Evra all sorts of problems, whether running directly at him or cutting inside between him and Hierro.
· Suarez like-wise will cause Neville a lot of headaches. Poor Gary got turned inside out at times when up against quick dribblers. McManaman always seemed to rip him apart. So I fully expect Suarez to get some joy here. When Luis cuts inside, Thuram will be there to cover, leaving space in the middle for Totti, or a late Scholes run.
· With Totti playing a false 9 he has a licence to drop deep and connect midfield with attack.
· There is a lack of width in Jayvin’s side. Shearer and Zlatan are similar forwards in the sense that neither will pull out wide but rather stay central and expect delivery from wide areas. This isn’t going to happen here and actually plays into my hands quite well with Pessotto and Di Livio going forward themselves to attack.
· There is a lack of pace in his side, in general. I believe with exceptional passers like Totti and Scholes, the pacey forwards can get in behind their back line.
· Deco, De Rossi and Scholes are all excellent on the ball. With Totti helping, there should be a solid control of possession and the tempo of the game.
PLAYER PROFILES
Last edited: