He is different. Provides a aerial threat, intelligent movement, linkup play and workrate which is superior to any forward we have.
Well he’s not identical, but a broadly similar ‘type’ of player. Like Martial, his game is predominantly about hold up play, link up play. He plays with his back to goal, takes the ball into feet. ‘Different’ would be someone who plays on the shoulder of the last defender, on the turn, threatening the space in behind the back line, running the channels - someone who’s first thought would be to make a penetrative run off the ball. Or a fox in the box. Or both would be perfect. I think Haaland would have been very suitable. His now ex-teammate Hwang would maybe fit.
Even so, I would be a bit keener on Jimenez if Rashford didn’t think he was Hazard.
I understand but I don't see it. Origi and Shaqiri at Liverpool, Jesus and Mahrez at City, they have similar back-up options to attack who come into the team and are expected to play similarly.
You don’t see it? Man City perhaps, yes - Guardiola is pretty set on what he wants his striker and wingers to do and how he likes them positioned. Though I do think he initially favoured Jesus because the Brazilian followed instruction more and relented merely because Aguero is quite simply a better player. Guardiola’s adjustments happen deeper, with the best example of a player Man City use to change the dynamic of the team being Gundogan when replacing one of the two attacking no.8’s to provide a deeper option and more control.
Origi and Shaqiri offer something different. When they played together against Everton in the last league game the setup was quite different, with Origi up top and Shaqiri on the right the ‘function’ of the players in those positions were reversed. Origi is a bit of a like-for-like change with Mane, but gets chucked about all over the place and is often brought on to change the formation when things aren’t working. When Shaqiri first came in Klopp seemed to experiment with a 4-2-3-1 with Salah up top, Firmino in the hole and him on the right, probably in an attempt to establish a good alternative shape. After his injury, I feel like Shaqiri has just not been near the first team much at all really.
Our best and most impactful sub this season has been Greenwood, offering something very different off the right either in a straight swap for James or in a change to a front four. Many talk about James being a potentially great impact sub. The idea of a ‘plan B’ forward is obviously well established, and a great example of that was seen with Tottenham having Lucas and Llorente as potential forward options last season. Traore is establishing himself as a consistent starter for Wolves in a system which suits him now but was a bit of a wildcard option as a wing back prior to the change of shape. He had a notable impact against us off the bench. Sissoko was previously used as an impact sub by Spurs and I can recall him having a similar impact in a past game against us too. There are myriad examples.