Sell sell sell
Rashford - New contract or sell?
- Thread starter Frank Grimes
- Start date
- Status
He is a virus and a perfect example of what is wrong with this club…..
Sell at any cost!!!!!
Sell at any cost!!!!!
Sell for whatever we can get. If it's a bag of crisps so be it.
Why would PSG buy him? They don't always make the smartest decisions as far as team balance, but they don't buy scrubs either.
My apologiesI literally just mentioned PSG on the post you quoted. Did you not read the whole post?
I responded to the wrong post
Give him an extension till 2024 and sell him in 2023. Let's see how he does under the next manager but personally I don't expect him to be worth the wages and am worried well give him a proper new deal.
Absolutely. Your team is of too high a level to be looking at duds like Rashford. If we sell him it'll be a much worse team.
One of the issues with our team is a lack of football intelligence. Rashford is one of the busiest culprits in this regard.
Has a contract till 2024 so there is no rush to do either. Deserves another season to show what he can do and we decide next summer what there is to be done.
This, but I disagree that he deserves it. If the club moves him on, he only has himself to blame. But I do hope he stays another year and regains some kind of quality with a new manager and a new approach. I know this kind of hopeful, wishful thinking has left us disappointed in the past, but I don‘t seem to be able to shake it.
Cantona was bought from Leeds, Roy Keane from Nottingham, while Rashford and Lingard are "home bred". Please tell me how "growing up United fan" is important.
Being an academy product, all that means is that the club has saved money on getting you. Every club needs it to healthily manage finances but in reality it has very little to do with if you are gonna give your all. That is just a cold reality, sentimentalism aside
Thanks.
Well some will complain, some wont. Personally I think he should be given a chance under ETH. Although as it was said here his attitude is the biggest problem along with the form or after form. He thinks he's done it all and that oozes of him when you see him play. Dont know if that will change and will ETH succeed in changing it.
I hear you and its a dire situation but there is a whole window to sign replacements.
The club have to start planning for replacing Rashford as a starter
Circumstances mean for him he'll luckily get one more season. He might be able to salvage something
Yesterday there were only 87 votes for offering him a new contract, now its 101.
Who are these 14 knobjockeys ??
Who are these 14 knobjockeys ??
Newcastle will pay a premium for him to fulfill the English quota. Selling him abroad would come at a loss.
If any half decent offer comes in for him he should be gone. It sends completely the wrong message keeping someone like Rashford around playing the way he is.
I'm not even really interested in whether there's potential for an upturn in form next season now, he's too far gone.
I'm not even really interested in whether there's potential for an upturn in form next season now, he's too far gone.
I wouldn't even give him next season based on this one, but I doubt we'll find many suitors this summer.
Being out of form and lacking confidence is one thing, not being bothered something completely else.
I would be genuinely surprised if he returns to stardom.
Being out of form and lacking confidence is one thing, not being bothered something completely else.
I would be genuinely surprised if he returns to stardom.
Purely based on footballing reasons: Sell
His decision making on the pitch is awful, it seems every time he gets the ball at his feet he either:
His decision making on the pitch is awful, it seems every time he gets the ball at his feet he either:
- attempts to dribble at full speed with his head down and loses it or it ricochets off him back to the opposition
- has the 1st touch of a JCB digger and loses it
- actually gets it under control and attempts a pass/cross which is normally the wrong option
I agree, Rashford has been brilliant in the past, but he has to step up and reaffirm his desire not only to play but to play for United. Maybe, just maybe, ETH will be just what Rashford needs to come good again, but Id only give one more season and tell him so; he has the ability and perhaps without the influence of Pogba, Martial and Lingard he'll knuckle down and be the player we all know he can be, but it has to be "last chance saloon!"
Same problem as with Martial. If you're not "in" it and you don't want it, all the talent is for nothing. Hence both will not make it here for much longer if it continues
I don't think Rashford's development has been helped by having 4 managers (all with completely different philosophies) and numerous different strike partners.
This is another disingenuous narrative being built by some of the posters like you on here when Rashford PR antics and management while being consistently sub par and totally use less on field is far more manipulative and damaging than anything others can be accused of .
Milk Newcastle dry, they would buy him for a good amount. His off the pitch heroics are a welcome boost for the Saudis.
Maguire, Pogba etc have their faults, but Rashford is by far the most dislikeable twat amongst our entire squad.
Thick as shit, lazy, entitled with a serious attitude problem. What a combination.
Just get rid of the fecker
Thick as shit, lazy, entitled with a serious attitude problem. What a combination.
Just get rid of the fecker
Last edited:
Take the money and run
Rashford's PR representatives at caf.Yesterday there were only 87 votes for offering him a new contract, now its 101.
Who are these 14 knobjockeys ??
How Newcastle went about their transfer business in January Window doesn't give me any indication that would be slightly interested in Rashford even with his Off Field profile .
Its often seemed to me that Rashford was too easily influenced by the likes of Pogba, Martial and Lingard who all seemed to be using the Club for their own ends. With these bad eggs gone hopefully Rashford will apply himself again, stop sulking and concentrate on doing what he's paid to do, play football.
It feels like he needs a change of scenery. He seems to have all the troubles of the world on his shoulders. I want the old Marcus back but I don't think it will happen. He should probably move on and have a fresh start.
Yup, hopefully with the team clearout he'll clear out his mind also and get it back to football.
Let's face with Rashy and Mctom in this first team we are not going anywhere.
Sell or give away. Just get rid.
Sell or give away. Just get rid.
If we could get 50/55 million for him this summer I would sell, and bring a couple of players in.
can’t believe Ronaldo was telling him where to go and had to drop into his position to cover for him. Lack of effort was criminal, there’s no excuse I can think of, life long United supporter and just doesn’t put in the effort.
What has Marcus Rashford produced to deserve a new contract? He has only gotten worse. Give him his last chance until January to prove that he is an inportant asset. If he does not deliver? Sell. Who cares is he is homegrown or not. The main criterion is whether he is good enough to play for United under ETH.
No new contract, that would be utterly bonkers at the moment.
Let him have next season to sort himself out and see what Ten Hag can do with him and then decide based on that.
Let him have next season to sort himself out and see what Ten Hag can do with him and then decide based on that.
Sell, if it was just about a loss of form I could be a bit more patient, but he just does nothing right now. Absolute waste of a player, it is like playing with 10 men.
I don’t think he’s ever been as great as made out, he was very good and what was the ‘great’ thing about him was what he could be. Looks like he’s going the other way sadly.
Id give him another year but probably as a squad player.
Id give him another year but probably as a squad player.
Yep he was always going to be a peak Walcott/Sturridge. Don't think he will be more - we should cash in before he falls consistently to their lows too.
Rashford was never easy on the eye but at least those who defended him could point to a somewhat reasonable goals and assists record. Even though many of us pointed out it was easy to pick hole in that.
Now he's struggling on that front too, all you have are his rotten performances. His technical ability is worse than some players I have seen in the Championship.
It's a sell for whatever we can get for me. He'll be the next Iwobi
- Status