Actually he is just about to enter his prime IMO. Great buy for most teams. Reminds me a little of Carvalho.
Raphael Varane | Signed for United!
- Thread starter davidmichael
- Start date
- Status
Needs to be paired with the right player. He would be amazing next to Maguire IMO.
He’s a top player and would instantly improve us tenfold. I think we have enough youngsters coming through. It’s time to buy at the top end of the market if we want to get to the next level. If we want to win the PL next season we really need to show some intent in the market.
Personally I think his prime was 2016-2019. Still want him though. He should have another 2-3 good years at the highest level, and I'd rather we sign quality rather than another will he/won't he like Bailly and Lindelof.
Playing two midfielders is on Ole and he can't be responsible for it. Even if you give VVD to Ole he would still play 2 box to box.
He is positionally good , composed and reasonable on tackle as well. Yes, not the best CB we can get but he is much better than what people think here. If you are willing to give credit to our defense this season, Lindelof was part of it. Take that however way you want !
We've had enough "needs the right partner", "needs to play in a different position", "needs legs around him" merchants over the last few years thank you.
but if we’ve already got the right partner in place as @Makelele says, then that’s pretty irrelevant?
whether that’s the case or not… I don’t know.
And then Real Madrid turns around and spend that money on Kounde? Feels like a mistake. With Ferguson, we used to be on the selling side of those deals.
In theory he should be the perfect partner for Maguire.
Just like Bailly is..
Just like Bailly is..
Kounde isn't costing £40m.
News is obviously going to come out today because the need for a CB was displayed last night. I don’t believe it all personally.
Always happens after a poor result. Whether that's United doing or the press just see this as a opportunity for easy clicks is another thing.
Kounde would probably be cheaper too, if you factor in the wages that Varane is wanting.
I don't disagree, however the problem is if we're looking to keep pace with City we need proven talent to come in straight away.
We can't afford Kounde coming in and needling time to acclimate to the PL and a higher level of opposition with a higher level of accountability that being at a top club brings.
From what I've heard about Kounde, he seems the better option. But I haven't seen La Liga enough for these two players of late.
Kounde I know is quite functional and can operate at right back and DM too, so I like the flexibility and he always looks quite comfortable driving through into midfield. Varane is obviously a very good player too, but I'm just unsure whether he's a better option.
Kounde I know is quite functional and can operate at right back and DM too, so I like the flexibility and he always looks quite comfortable driving through into midfield. Varane is obviously a very good player too, but I'm just unsure whether he's a better option.
Can't see Madrid playing Kounde and Alaba at CB
And the number of years we could depreciate that transfer fee over...
Real Madrid will likely do just that.
But I'm not saying I'm against the signing of Varane but my preference would've been to go after a younger CB.
Varane would be a great signing/partner for Maguire, but the exact same issues would arise if Maguire got injured IMO. I still wouldn't totally trust a Varane/Lindelof partnership.
But at 40M it's good business, and hopefully would still allow two other signings. *If* it is true.
But at 40M it's good business, and hopefully would still allow two other signings. *If* it is true.
Not seem enough of Kounde but can see he's only 178 cm. That could be an issue.
40m is a no brainer. If he wants to come.
Straight swap for Donny!
Smells like a typical post-loss brief to me, especially considering scummy Luckhurst is involved.
Have to say I had my heart set on a no nonsense bruiser who can win a fecking header for once. Not so keen on basically a slightly better Lindelof, and I’ve always thought Varane was a bit overrated anyway. Chelsea gave him a hard time the other week.
Yes please. Him and Maguire would make me rock solid in my opinion.
Whenever I see Varane against English sides his weaknesses are quite apparent.
I don't think it'll happen, and I can't say I'm 100% convinced he'd be a success either. He's a great player, I think him with Maguire would be brilliant. But do I think he'd turn Lindelof or Bailly into better defenders if Harry was out again? Really unsure.
I said it awhile back, this one sets off alarm bells for me. Could come in and be brilliant though and make me look like a total fool.
I said it awhile back, this one sets off alarm bells for me. Could come in and be brilliant though and make me look like a total fool.
Last edited:
This is an issue I have. We could put Baresi back there, but without the right coaching he’ll end up looking like a muppet as well.
What are they? On paper he’s strong in the air, fast and good on the ball. I haven’t seen him much the last few years though.
This is the case with Lindelof & Bailly too.
Honestly I find him to be alittle awkward on the ball, which seems like a left-field opinion on him as various people suggest that this is actually his strongest attribute.
I do find him lacking in aggression too, which I think is a major issue with the Maguire and Lindelof partnership. Someone like Baily has the aggression but not the nous.
We need a CB like Vidic/Terry/Stam/Puyol. Someone who really enjoys the dirtier side of the game.
I think with Varane you'd be getting a upgrade on Lindelof with similar attributes but not necessarily the type of CB we need, if that makes sense.
I would prefer Kounde. I see alot of similarities in his game with Puyol. Who was a somewhat underrated CB.
Why we signing an injury prone defender? I know he’s fantastic but there’s no point splashing the cash to find Maguire back with lindelof/Bailly after a month.
Good signing for 40 million I think. I still remember his great performances against us in 2012.
Just hope he can stay fit.
Just hope he can stay fit.
It's obvious he's a step up from Lindelof, everyone has seen how many goals he's cost us, another plus is he's friends with Pogba, would be a good signing if its true.
If it isn't Lindelof still needs to be replaced.
If it isn't Lindelof still needs to be replaced.
Can’t see us getting better CB’s between £40-50m.
Varane give us 2-3 years to bring in a young talented CB who can get smooth matching and gradually step into our XI. It also gives Tuanzebe more time to develop, and he also has the potential to be our regular CB (XI), but he needs more time.
Varane give us 2-3 years to bring in a young talented CB who can get smooth matching and gradually step into our XI. It also gives Tuanzebe more time to develop, and he also has the potential to be our regular CB (XI), but he needs more time.
Or will this just be another Ramos situation
- Status