Rafael da Silva | 2010-14 Performances

Status
Not open for further replies.
How far behind the elite fullbacks in the world is he? He has fantastic attributes, he's a good tackler, excellent on the ball, has a decent cross, very quick, he's bulked up over the last season or two, his positioning and decision making has let him down occasionally, but as he's matured I think these attributes have improved.
Is he better then the Johnsons/Walkers of the premier league, if not why not?
 
I was trying to be subjective, of course he is, he's fantastic.
 
How far behind the elite fullbacks in the world is he? He has fantastic attributes, he's a good tackler, excellent on the ball, has a decent cross, very quick, he's bulked up over the last season or two, his positioning and decision making has let him down occasionally, but as he's matured I think these attributes have improved.
Is he better then the Johnsons/Walkers of the premier league, if not why not?

Only probably lahm and Dani alves on top form would I swap for Rafael at the present moment, and that days alot.

Seems to be a shortage of real top quality right backs but he is at the top at present. No doubt.
 
I would swap him for anyone. Absolute class.
 
Fergie says he should be back for Wigan on Tuesday, good news.
 
I read that he will be back for Wigan. If yes, than these are great news.
 
Great news. Smalling and Jones can do a job there but aren't a patch on Rafael. Both defensively and offensively IMO.
 
Only probably lahm and Dani alves on top form would I swap for Rafael at the present moment, and that days alot.

Seems to be a shortage of real top quality right backs but he is at the top at present. No doubt.

But Rafael is much younger. There is no doubt that they in top form are better than Rafael right now, but he is still young and can become as good or better than them. And he can give us at least a decade of service as a top player.
 
Rafael had Ribery in his pocket almost 3 years ago.

And that yellow card was bullshit.

His form this season is not suprising at all. His fitness and ability to finish games is though.
 
I was listening to a podcast earlier and one of the journos was talking about Rafael as if the player we have seen most of this season is the same as two years ago, this is by no means the first time either.

Is it that some in the trade only watch us infrequently and then read about his being subbed against Reading, and just assume that there has been no significant improvement?

Raf has been up there with some of our forwards as among the more reliable figures in the team.
 
I was listening to a podcast earlier and one of the journos was talking about Rafael as if the player we have seen most of this season is the same as two years ago, this is by no means the first time either.

Is it that some in the trade only watch us infrequently and then read about his being subbed against Reading, and just assume that there has been no significant improvement?

Raf has been up there with some of our forwards as among the more reliable figures in the team.

It's probably got something to do with the huge amount of goals we're shipping, it's difficult for defenders to get praise in circumstances like this. It's quite difficult to explain really, if you read RedCafe Evans is really good, Rafael is the best right back in the Premier League, Ferdinand's still got it and Evra's having his best season in years, it might be a little bit over the top but I struggle to disagree with any of that. I imagine it's very easy for someone who doesn't watch United every week to assume it's down to Rafael being a kamikaze maniac or down to some of the flaws he's more or less eliminated.
 
Good interview on the official site.

Rafael: I'm not a kid now

Rafael has arguably been the Reds' most consistent player this season. He sat down with Inside United recently to discuss the changes in his game and his ever-growing confidence...

Everybody’s talking about how much you’ve matured this season. What has changed to make that happen?
I'm getting old! [laughs] No, I think this is just a natural development – it's bound to happen when you play more games and have more experiences. My daughter has also helped me – it's settled me down a lot. When you're a dad you have to be mature. Also, I think splitting from Fabio – he's on loan at Queens Park Rangers this season – has been a good experience.

You used to get stick from people who said you went forward too much or threw yourself into too many tackles. Have you made a conscious effort to curb some of those instincts?
Yes and no. I'm a Brazilian and everybody knows how much we love to attack. Part of my game is going forward and I love to score goals – it's an incredible feeling. It's always been the case that I've had to think carefully about when to go forward and when to stay behind. I think the difference now is that I'm making more correct decisions and that's something that comes from playing regularly in the team. The same goes for my tackling. You can't always win the ball and sometimes the best thing to do is not to make a challenge. You learn when to tackle and when not to.

You seem more confident than ever. Would you agree?
I feel good, definitely. I'm getting older. I don't feel young anymore. I think everybody still thinks of me as this teenage boy who's only just arrived at the club. But I'm 22 now, I'm a father. I'm not a kid anymore. Now I feel like a man and maybe that shows on the outside. I'm obviously still learning about football and I'll keep learning, but I feel ready for anything now. I'm ready to make a big impact.

You seemed to have struck up a really good understanding with Antonio Valencia down the right wing. How enjoyable is it to play with Antonio?
It's amazing. He's a terrific player and he's so strong. When I go out on the pitch and Antonio is in front of me it fills me with confidence. We have a very good relationship off the pitch as well – perhaps that helps during games.

Do you know much about David Beckham and Gary Neville's partnership down the right in the 90s?
Of course, and I hope me and Antonio can have the same success at United. To play together for almost 10 years here would be incredible and I'm sure we could have a lot of success. It would be a dream to develop a partnership as good as that one. I like the fact that Neville and Beckham were good friends as well.

Sir Alex said recently that whenever you go back to Brazil you end up playing football every day in the street. Is that true?
Yes, it is! I love it. We always spend time with our friends when we go back and part of that is playing against other teams from the neighbourhood in our city. It's not a big city and it's just for fun so it's really enjoyable. We also play a lot of beach soccer and volleyball but with the feet and head. It's obviously very different to playing at Old Trafford – there's not as much pressure and we don't have to run quite as much!

But the boss says you "train like a beast"!
I read that [laughs]! I think it's because when I play football I just forget about everything else in my life and I commit to football 100 per cent. It doesn't matter if it's a cup final or a training session - I always give my all and I always want to win. I think it's important to train to the same level as you would play a match. It's the best way to prepare.

Part two will be published on Tuesday 1 January.

http://www.manutd.com/en/News-And-F...clusive-Inside-United-interview-part-one.aspx
 
It's probably got something to do with the huge amount of goals we're shipping, it's difficult for defenders to get praise in circumstances like this. It's quite difficult to explain really, if you read RedCafe Evans is really good, Rafael is the best right back in the Premier League, Ferdinand's still got it and Evra's having his best season in years, it might be a little bit over the top but I struggle to disagree with any of that. I imagine it's very easy for someone who doesn't watch United every week to assume it's down to Rafael being a kamikaze maniac or down to some of the flaws he's more or less eliminated.

It's a strange situation. I don't think any of our defenders have been bad this season, really. Rafael's obviously been excellent, and Evans has stood out for me too. Rio's had the odd game where his lack of pace has cost him, and Evra's had a few of his standard lazy ones. But as individuals they haven't been nearly as bad as our goals conceded numbers would suggest. Very strange.

That said, with Vidic against West Brom it was like a different outfit. He's so crucial to the entire defensive unit.
 
Maybe this is nostalgia on my part but these days i do have to wonder how much time in training is committed to defensive drills whether this be the whole XI or back five alone, particularly when compared to Quiroz's time at the club. Additionally the midfield shield has been thinner than it used to be, nor has it Park and Fletch of a few years ago buzzing around all over the place pressing opposition players higher up the pitch.
 
Was great to see him back against Wigan. Was solid at the back and provided plenty of drive going forward. Having him back really gives us that attacking threat from RB again that we lost while he was gone and Smalling was filling in.
 
I somehow knew he was going to backheel the ball just before we scored the 4th goal, and the Wigan defence would feck it up and it would lead to a chance for us. Really like the flair he adds on that right hand side going forward, has the potential to be as influential as Evra was/is down the flank, but with better end product.

Got a better cross and eye for goal than Evra too (although Evra has scored a few goals this season!)
 
I did have to laugh when that back heel managed to actually work due to the Wigan players totally messing it up.
 
I somehow knew he was going to backheel the ball just before we scored the 4th goal, and the Wigan defence would feck it up and it would lead to a chance for us. Really like the flair he adds on that right hand side going forward, has the potential to be as influential as Evra was/is down the flank, but with better end product.

Got a better cross and eye for goal than Evra too (although Evra has scored a few goals this season!)

He would have scored if not for a very good save from Al Habsy which fortunately Chicharito managed to score from.Evra has improved his attacking game this season, more goals, assists and more importantly much better crosses
 
Led the team yesterday in touches, tackles, and interceptions.

Just another day at the office.
 
Love the interview and as I said on another thread, he's my favourite United player. Commitment, passion and quality in abundance.
 
Is it common for a RB to consistently lead the team in touches?

I would think a Central Defender or Deep Lying Midfielder would.
 
Rafael had Ribery in his pocket almost 3 years ago.

And that yellow card was bullshit.

His form this season is not suprising at all. His fitness and ability to finish games is though.

He did I agree but the red card was stupidity on his part (Ribery did what he usually does and rolled around). I was at the game and remember a few folk at half time saying they hope Fergie takes him off as he was a time bomb ticking after getting booked for kicking Van Bommel who had done him earlier if I remember. Bloody memory of this tie was Evra in the away leg costing us in the last minute and Carrick not being strong enough just before half time. Can't believe we didn't go through this tie we mauled them.
 
He did I agree but the red card was stupidity on his part (Ribery did what he usually does and rolled around). I was at the game and remember a few folk at half time saying they hope Fergie takes him off as he was a time bomb ticking after getting booked for kicking Van Bommel who had done him earlier if I remember. Bloody memory of this tie was Evra in the away leg costing us in the last minute and Carrick not being strong enough just before half time. Can't believe we didn't go through this tie we mauled them.

My memory is foggy so I could be wrong but from what I remember his first yellow was quite harsh as well. He had dragged down Badstuber after not getting a freekick for a clear foul on him by Badstuber.

What annoyed me most about that game was both Badstuber and Van Bommel should have been sent off as well, they were far worse than Rafael. Van Bommel especially is a massive cnut and how he has not been sent off more often in his is anyone's guess
 
He did I agree but the red card was stupidity on his part (Ribery did what he usually does and rolled around). I was at the game and remember a few folk at half time saying they hope Fergie takes him off as he was a time bomb ticking after getting booked for kicking Van Bommel who had done him earlier if I remember. Bloody memory of this tie was Evra in the away leg costing us in the last minute and Carrick not being strong enough just before half time. Can't believe we didn't go through this tie we mauled them.

Still hurts thinking back to that game. We we're absolutely battering them, I remember texting my mate at 3-0 saying something like 'I feel another Roma 7-1 coming on here'.

feck knows how we lost it. Would have had a great chance of winning it that year as well :(
 
It's a strange situation. I don't think any of our defenders have been bad this season, really. Rafael's obviously been excellent, and Evans has stood out for me too. Rio's had the odd game where his lack of pace has cost him, and Evra's had a few of his standard lazy ones. But as individuals they haven't been nearly as bad as our goals conceded numbers would suggest. Very strange.

That said, with Vidic against West Brom it was like a different outfit. He's so crucial to the entire defensive unit.

Agreed! Individually the defenders have played well. I think Rio has been good; you can't blame him for being outpaced by Bale - other than that, he has kept up with most players well. Of CBs, I can only think of a younger Rio and Thiago Silva who could keep up with Bale anyhow (maybe Smalling?).

Evra has had a very good season - it is unfair to him to blame every goal that comes from his side. Rafael has been terrific and Evans has been good too, although he does cost us the odd goal here and there due to some weird moments that are hard to explain.

I agree that Vidic did seem to inject something that was missing; in my opinion that was his presence in the box, and his ability to clear the ball the hell out of there. Rio seems to get his head to most balls, but they are mostly just headed out for another attack.
 
The goals have mostly come from Rio not taking enough authority, so Evans tries to deal with every ball coming towards the box and sometimes making mistakes. If thats Vidic instead of Evans we'd probably have conceeded less. Alternatively Rio could do more than just standing in a good position
 
Status
Not open for further replies.