Pogba's contract offer

Because people think that France depend on Pogba. They won last cup because of Mbappe and Griezmann. Pogba was passenger. I don't understand how so called "experts" don't see that he is average player. At best.

Carragher is right in lot of things there.

Nah, they didn't have anybody else to play Mbappe in behind other than Pogba. They don't really have a ton of creative CMs in France at the moment and less in 2018. Tolisso would have had to have produced the best month of his career.

But. yeah, City should steer clear.
 
If he went to Madrid I'd understand, but if it's PSG, he'll be down there with Neymar as quality players that could not handle the pressure of a big club and went to easy street for a big pay check.
Honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if he doesn't have much choice. After how things have gone the last two years I don't think Real, Barca or Atletico will offer him a contract, nor will Bayern or any of the English clubs. That only leaves the Italian league (which will come with a significant wage decrease and less chance in Europe) or PSG.
 
He doesn't half talk sense Carragher. Mad how people still bang on about Pogbas 'Undeniable Quality'. What does potential matter at his age?

Have to agree - not sure why City would go for him they are past doing things to antagonise us. It did not work out at United for whatever reason, the club being in constant crisis did not help nor did his frequent injuries but he never seemed to player to grab the opportunity by the scruff of the neck. It would appear now his options are limited and likely will include a substantial pay cut, although will likely be offset by a fat signing on fee. While I bear him no ill will, I hope he does not remain at United, we need a clear break from the recent past and another bumper pay day to an underperforming player does not send the correct signal. Frankly we have all expended enough energy on him and I wish him well (unless he goes to City), but off!
 
Redknapp especially is an absolute gobshite and always has been. How the feck he's been on TV so long when his only qualification is "looks good in a suit" is completely beyond me.

Played for a big team, and the ladies love him.

Puts him streets ahead of Jenas!
 
Exactly. Man I hope he goes there and wastes away losing in the C league quarters yearly.
I just read an article claiming Pogba wants to talk about his future with ETH......obviously this is because no other club is prepared to pay him what we do.....I hope to God this report is wrong, Pogbas had his chances, and plenty of them, under 3 different managers and has failed to perform; ETH should tell him to sling his hook. In the name of The Holy Trinity (Law, Best & Charlton) just leave, Pogba....just GO!
 
No club is going to offer him a silly contract given his age and injury record and I think this is just dawning on him. I reckon he would be quite keen on staying and it will have to be the club that tells him to feck off.
 
If he were to stay the problem is whether he'd be a disruptive influence on dressing room. Even if United some how paid him less and he was a squad player he could still affect the mentality of the team.

Many of United's spice boy generation need to go.
 
If he were to stay the problem is whether he'd be a disruptive influence on dressing room. Even if United some how paid him less and he was a squad player he could still affect the mentality of the team.

Many of United's spice boy generation need to go.

Why would he be a disruptive influence in the dressing room?
 
Hopefully he really really ends up regretting not signing the absurd contract we offered him last summer.

Could have been lumbered with him for another 4 years on 350k a week.
Reliable reports have said we've not offered him an increase? If there is it's probably just bonuses based on achievements/appearances/etc.
 
France is always bought up by the likes of Redknapp, (who I think is a terrible pundit) but it's only a few games he plays needs to play well in, he just isn't capable of doing it over a long hard 38 game prem season.
It didn't work out and I wish him all the best but its time for club and player to move on
 
Last edited:
I hope we don't offer him a contract. The money is better spent on a young and hungry player
 
Why would he be a disruptive influence in the dressing room?

Maybe not on the dressing room per se, but certainly the culture of the club if we're going to refresh the squad and have committed players working hard. He's also undermined one manager directly on quite a few occasions and he had his agent talking shite on the eve of major matches (which is 100% on the player in my view).

That aside, I'd be amazed if we're still open to tie him down to a huge contract when we've just upgraded Bruno needlessly and are looking to sign de Jong plus a DM.
 
Pogba is a poison the club need to get rid off. He's been one of the worst performers at the club the last few years and then you get the....... he does this for France nonsense. He isn't great for France, watch the World Cup final, an average performance covered over by a goal. Christ he has Kante to do all his work. Lad is the person I hate most at Utd, honestly hope he feck off. Absolute waster that fella. Poison
 
I hope we don't offer him a contract. The money is better spent on a young and hungry player

Without any doubt.
We have to move back to a model where these sort of wages only go on players who are the best in the league and perform every week..
 
Reliable reports have said we've not offered him an increase? If there is it's probably just bonuses based on achievements/appearances/etc.
If any new contract is performance linked then Pogba will owe us money. We should not even be considering resigning him; hes been at United nearly 6 years and played under 3 managers, and seen them all off, and has under performed every year and for every manager; why do people keep thinking that he might suddenly come good? There is more chance of Martians landing in Downing Street!
 
I wonder how the meeting with Juve went today. I bet they will low ball him with loads of add ons.
 
Have to agree - not sure why City would go for him they are past doing things to antagonise us. It did not work out at United for whatever reason, the club being in constant crisis did not help nor did his frequent injuries but he never seemed to player to grab the opportunity by the scruff of the neck. It would appear now his options are limited and likely will include a substantial pay cut, although will likely be offset by a fat signing on fee. While I bear him no ill will, I hope he does not remain at United, we need a clear break from the recent past and another bumper pay day to an underperforming player does not send the correct signal. Frankly we have all expended enough energy on him and I wish him well (unless he goes to City), but off!
Couldn’t care less if he goes to City, he simply weakens the team because of his work rate, yes he’s great sometimes in possession but he doesn’t read the game that we’ll and won’t buy into Pep’s 3 second rule of wining the ball back, so he’ll be subbed a lot at city, he will only be used as the 6 at city, they play so high up with Centre backs high and only really Walker used as a last sweep up line so city will lose more points playing Pogba rather than Rhodri in the CDM role and be open to being exposed down their left side, it’s why Salah always does well against them he’s so high on the right he’s the obvious out ball, Jared Bowen for West Ham at the weekend exactly the same left footer wide on the right with pace , City weakness Even united exposed this when our strikers were playing well in the previous two seasons, POGBA makes them significantly weaker against good sides and marginally better against average and weak sides so jog on Paul, no one cares anymore !
 
Couldn’t care less if he goes to City, he simply weakens the team because of his work rate, yes he’s great sometimes in possession but he doesn’t read the game that we’ll and won’t buy into Pep’s 3 second rule of wining the ball back, so he’ll be subbed a lot at city, he will only be used as the 6 at city, they play so high up with Centre backs high and only really Walker used as a last sweep up line so city will lose more points playing Pogba rather than Rhodri in the CDM role and be open to being exposed down their left side, it’s why Salah always does well against them he’s so high on the right he’s the obvious out ball, Jared Bowen for West Ham at the weekend exactly the same left footer wide on the right with pace , City weakness Even united exposed this when our strikers were playing well in the previous two seasons, POGBA makes them significantly weaker against good sides and marginally better against average and weak sides so jog on Paul, no one cares anymore !
I'm not even sure I believe the City link story... just doesn't feel like a Pep sort of player to me
 
Can't wait for him to leave, although I'm sure he will start talking bad about the club once he steps out of the door.
 
I 100% want him gone, but would accept him staying if a) He accepts a new contract under reduced terms AND b) Ten Hag specifically wants him.
 
I'm sure he'll come back and sign what we've offered once he's completed his European whore tour and realises no-one else is stupid enough to offer him what we have

Sigh
 
The only words Ten Hag should say are "Go, and dont let the door hit you in the arse on your way out!"
This was a perfect opportunity for you to quote Gloria Gaynor and you didn't. Disappointed.
 
I have a feeling he will sign a new contract here
I'm sure he'll come back and sign what we've offered once he's completed his European whore tour and realises no-one else is stupid enough to offer him what we have

Sigh

Get the same feeling.

New deal. Some quotes about how it's a new start and he's ready to commit the rest of his career to United. And how Ten Hag is the first manager with a clear plan for him.

First bump in the road, he'll get 'injured' and then be speaking to French media about how lovely Turin and Madrid are this time of year.
 
I'm not even sure I believe the City link story... just doesn't feel like a Pep sort of player to me
Yep have to agree with that but for a free probably thinks they could sell him
Next year for £50M
 
Get the same feeling.

New deal. Some quotes about how it's a new start and he's ready to commit the rest of his career to United. And how Ten Hag is the first manager with a clear plan for him.

First bump in the road, he'll get 'injured' and then be speaking to French media about how lovely Turin and Madrid are this time of year.

No way right? Can't fricken happen can it? That is terrifying.
 
There is no way we would give him a new deal. He’s too injury prone for big contract.
 
Why are we even resigning and offering him a contract. If no one signs him, let him rot as a free agent (although I’m sure he’ll get an offer from Juve or PSG but it’ll be an offer lesser than ours)
 
At this point I'm hoping PSG do us a favour. Tell the Arabs Mbappe is leaving and that they'd need a new poster boy.

If we extend his contract, I'm not so sure much has changed in the club's thinking, despite all the changes that have been made.
 
Don't underestimate how many stupid football clubs there are out there. Jose Mourinho is notorious for coaxing teams into sacking him after the three season mark, and yet clubs keep employing him.

But saying that....

I doubt any club is stupid enough to match Paul Pogba's current wage (£300k pw), never mind almost doubling it to £500k pw. Not many teams could afford it.

The latest news is that Juventus have offered Pogba a 3 year contact, but they haven't met his wage demands. Which goes to prove, once and for all, that he's nothing but a money grabbing mercenary. He loves Juventus, but not enough to take a wage drop.

I doubt PSG would touch him. Manchester City won't go near him. Who does that leave?

I can see Pogba being to Newcastle what Robinho was to Manchester City... their first ever marquee signing.

If we are offering a contract worth £500k pw, it should be retracted as soon as possible.