Player of the Season vote

Well...

  • Total voters
    405
  • Poll closed .
1. Dalot
2. Bruno
3. Garnacho

Honorable shoutouts to Mainoo, Maguire and Evans in breakout, redemption and better than expected seasons.

The rest have been absolutely dreadful.
 
afrocentricity said:
Looking at the thread it's going to be Dalot isn't it? That says a lot to me that he's ahead of Bruno, Nacho, Mainoo....

Bruno for me and it's not even close, way higher heights, and he's objectively carried us on his back at points this season. Gets absolutely no love from redcafe
Click to expand...

I could not disgaree more. This is what happens when some fans are swayed by a good individual performance.

Bruno bottled the game against Arsenal at the weekend, don't tell me he miraculously recovered for this (Newcastle) game, which in fact, meant little at all. Even Rooney called it out. That tells you everything about Bruno and the season he has had. He has been much better in recent weeks, (because he responded to much criticism) but for significant majority of the camapign, he was everything that does not reflect a Manchester United Captain: uncommitted, uninspiring, selfish, and inconsistent. He epitomised the problems the team were having. Bruno has had a very poor season, considering a player of his ability. Of course, he wasn't responsible for the players around him, but his role, as Captain, was to inspire, to elevate, to lead. And Bruno Fernandes did not do that this season. No way.

How can you say that he has had a better season than say, Garnacho? That's unbelievable...
 
My vote is more with my heart than my head, as I really respect Maguire for coming out the other side after all the abuse he took (& for sure he wasn’t playing well at all)… his confidence was at rock bottom 12 months ago, so fair play to him for not giving up and for putting in some really solid performances this season.
 
Maguire for his character and performance. Our best defender for sure.

Dalot the most improved player.

Garnacho the best efforts. Giving his all every game. Keep running up and down the flank all day.

Mainoo most consistent.

Amad best new comer.
 
Mainoo for me. He didn't play the full season but he's played enough for me to qualify for the honor.
 
Dalot for me, most improved player and he's also our best cheerleader and high fiver as well.
Honourable mentions to Garnacho, Mainoo and Bruno
 
afrocentricity said:
Looking at the thread it's going to be Dalot isn't it? That says a lot to me that he's ahead of Bruno, Nacho, Mainoo....

Bruno for me and it's not even close, way higher heights, and he's objectively carried us on his back at points this season. Gets absolutely no love from redcafe
Click to expand...
Bruno's only been good the last month or so, no way can he be POTS.
 
Dalot with an honourable mention to Maguire for helping to stabilise us for a while everybody was catching the injury bug. For all Maguires flaws, he stays fit and I think he's improved areas of his game where he was lacking.
 
Dalot. Honourable mention - Mainoo.

Rest are all varying degrees of shit.
 
3 contenders: Mainoo, Dalot and Bruno. Has to be one of them
 
Rashford - Can’t think of any player whos worked harder. Sancho with an honourable mention as well. Anthony with his amazing goals and assists. Scott with his 4,000,000 back passes and side way passes. On a serious note Dalot or Bruno for me.
 
Jeffthered said:
I could not disgaree more. This is what happens when some fans are swayed by a good individual performance.

Bruno bottled the game against Arsenal at the weekend, don't tell me he miraculously recovered for this (Newcastle) game, which in fact, meant little at all. Even Rooney called it out. That tells you everything about Bruno and the season he has had. He has been much better in recent weeks, (because he responded to much criticism) but for significant majority of the camapign, he was everything that does not reflect a Manchester United Captain: uncommitted, uninspiring, selfish, and inconsistent. He epitomised the problems the team were having. Bruno has had a very poor season, considering a player of his ability. Of course, he wasn't responsible for the players around him, but his role, as Captain, was to inspire, to elevate, to lead. And Bruno Fernandes did not do that this season. No way.

How can you say that he has had a better season than say, Garnacho? That's unbelievable...
Click to expand...
He missed only the second game of his entire career due to injury, and he's 'bottled it'. Jesus wept. Get a grip. He plays nearly every minute of every game, and while others have dropped like flies, Bruno is always there. It's absolutely insane to blame him for finally missing a game.
 
Garnacho has been amazing. He's a bit off only in the last few weeks.
 
Finally, we come to this prestigous award. Think even the one who gets it feels a bit shit.

Mainoo for me though.
 
Most consistently good player over the whole season is Dalot for me. Maguire close second.
Bruno has been excellent the last few months but a really bad early season.
 
Bruno for me, easily. This team would be in a relegation battle without him.
 
Maguire.
He comes out on top of the individual ratings I have given on here to each player, on a match by match basis.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.