Player of the Season vote

Well...

  • Total voters
    405
  • Poll closed .
I'd say Evans, Maguire and Dalot have been relatively consistent throughout the season but my choice would be Mainoo purely on the basis that he's the one player who has produced some real, genuine class moments and looks set to establish himself as one of Europe's major prospects.
The excitement around him has brightened a otherwise bleak campaign.
 
Dalot or Mainoo. Only two that have been more good than bad this season.
 
TrebleChamp99 said:
There should be more shouts for Garnacho to be honest he was the difference maker early in the season and he's the only reason why we're only in eighth otherwise we'd be lower.
Click to expand...
How’s he the “only” reason? It’s not like he’s scored or assisted or even contributed consistently.

Anyone picking him over Dalot has a forward bias IMO
 
Dalot has been the most consistent. Although this does remind me of the season Shaw won it and people mocked the highlights reel :lol: :(
 
Voted for Bruno, special mention to Garnacho though. Appreciate Dalot for a consistent season but he hasnb't won a single month award. If that award Mourinho created for McT still exists, he would deserve it for being most improved.
 
Mainoo is probably your "feel good" PotY but seemed to understandably wear down near end of season.
Bruno undoubtedly your best player but still doubts remain about his stomach for the fight in some games.
Probably give it to Dalot myself for consistency and great improvement.
 
Schmeichels pinky said:
How’s he the “only” reason? It’s not like he’s scored or assisted or even contributed consistently.

Anyone picking him over Dalot has a forward bias IMO
Click to expand...
I have bias towards players who deserve to stay at the club and are part of the future.
 
Dalot for me, but even he has gone off the boil recently with switching from right to left every other game.

Maguire, Bruno, garnacho and mainoo others to mention
 
Dalot
Bruno in with a shout. Maguire and McTominay deserve a lot of credit but a bit behind them two for me.
 
The fecking app bugged out on me when it opened and I didn't even get to choose.

Screenshot-20240515-154019-com-mu-muclubapp.jpg


feck off.
 
this has to be the worst POTS winner i can think of in a long time, regardless of who wins.
 
Grande said:
For me it has to be between Onana, Maguire, Dalot, Bruno or Garnacho.

The most exciting for me has been Mainoo, without a doubt. Then Garnacho, and watching some of the best glimpses of Amad and Kambwala. But those five mentioned first have been more instrumental in our best play in total, in my opinion. None perfect, none having a great season, but it is what it is. The players can’t chose the conditions they work under. Dalot and Garnacho are having their personal best seasons IMO.

I think my ranking would be
1. Fernandes, 2. Onana, 3. Garnacho

Garnacho young player of the year.

Goal of the year is actually a quite good category this season. From a shady memory:

1. Garnacho vs Everton
2. Mainoo vs Liverpool
3. Amad vs Liverpool
Click to expand...
How in the world are you going to consider Onana as player of the season?!
 
The one which gives his yearly salary to the charity, so at least we fans can see who is ashamed of himself this year.
 
Should be Bruno easily but there are people on here who just cannot see how valuable the player is for our team. Even though he has been below par earlier this season he still wins it hands down.
2nd place: Dalot who has been consistent throughout the season and in my mind our most improved player.
3rd place: Garnacho great development. Sky's the limit for him!
 
Plant0x84 said:
How in the world are you going to consider Onana as player of the season?!
Click to expand...
Did a great job of destroying our CL campaign and had more clangers overall than even last season's DDG did. What's there not to like.
 
Kobbie Mainoo, lands in the midst of a shambolic "system", pathetic player displays from so called internationals, and produces moments of pure class, a youngster who has so much more maturity and professionalism than that of most of the team. Exception being Harry Maguire....dealt with all the flak with dignity and distinction.
 
It’s Dalot for me by a significant margin. He’s been the only player to consistently play and consistently retain his good form. Mainoo will probably win it, but realistically he didn’t play for half a season, and exciting as he is as a talent on merits he’s not our best player. The only other player who deserves a mention is Bruno but his form early season wasn’t great. Dalot is clear.
 
KiD MoYeS said:
Yep, Bruno has by far been our best player.

Dalot getting a lot of shouts, he's been decent to good - but has still made some terrible defensive errors and probably isn't in the top five or six right-backs in the league.
Click to expand...
Name 5/6 better right backs? Dalot is hugely underrated by a portion of our fans.
 
It shouldn't be awarded this year, no body deserves it. One of Mainoo, Garnacho or Dalot is we do have to give it
 
Would've said Garnacho until recently but the way the team has played since Bruno went down leaves no doubt in my mind it has to be him
 
It’s Dalot or nobody. Bruno had his worst season here. Mainoo/Maguire played half of a season. Onana mixed brilliant with insanity. Garnacho is so hot and cold and it would 100% go to his head and ruin his development.

Also should be said, Dalot is massively underrated (not to say he’s incredible). Head down, plays football, left or right, stays fit, has improved.

It’s upsetting that he’s the only viable answer, but he’s all we’ve got.
 
KiD MoYeS said:
Yep, Bruno has by far been our best player.

Dalot getting a lot of shouts, he's been decent to good - but has still made some terrible defensive errors and probably isn't in the top five or six right-backs in the league.
Click to expand...
Has he? He's largely been anonymous until the most recent 10 game or so. Dalot has performed consistently throughout the season.
 
Plant0x84 said:
Erm, yeah… still not seeing how he has been the best player?
Click to expand...
Seeing as you started a thread now titled ‘Onana has not worked out etc’, that’s hardly surprising, is it?

For my money, after a bad start, a shabby second quarter of the season, he has been our standout best performer since new year. He’s made lots of good saves, lots of important ones, quite a few brilliant ones, had a decent command of the box in spite of the chaos of a revolving door defence with no midfield. He has one of the best saves statistics in the league, particularily on the most relevant stat, postExG-saves, and that coincides with my eye-test, having seen us concede and alarming rate of unpressurized shots in and close around the box. And this is only his defensive part of the game. The improvement in his on the ball work has been very good, while severly handicapped by a back four not daring to go high and wide to leave space for him to play in, and wasted mostly by a back four unable to progress the build up that he starts in exemplary fashion time and again.

So for me, best player in 2024 slightly ahead of Bruno, and one very good half, one medium minus and one pretty bad quarter of the season is enough this season to get in the discussion. IMO.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.