Nope. He's as average a defender as you'll get in the PL.
Uses his physical capabilities to make up for a lack of skill or footballing brain.
When I read that sentence, I immediately thought of Zat Knight. Now he was a defender who overly relied on his physical qualities. However, I've kept track of Jones since his Blackburn days, and since the beginning, he never really looked like someone who overly relied on recoveries in his defending. He was always quick on his feet and very good at reading the opposing ball holder. Positionally, and in terms of reading the game, he wasn't as refined as J.M. Gimenez is at a similar age, but he showed very good anticipation. Combined with his aggressive defending style, I immediately starting making comparisons with John Terry at his best, and I'm somewhat surprised that I'm not the only one who sees that.
He is a brave John Terry throw your head infront of a bus type, who while it looks great and brave is actually a bad way of defending.
It's not bad if you do it at a calculated approach. Under Mourinho in the past, yes, he may have been given a platform to defend like that, but he wasn't as gung-ho and loose as he, Cahill, and Kompany are now. Even Vidic was quite aggressive in his defending, but he was very calculated. Certainly, in the past few matches, and even in many moments this season, we've seen Jones show a better reading of the game that allows him to defend with controlled aggression. Compare that to his first season here when he was quite reckless but great at recovering himself. van Gaal has certainly done a great job at controlling Jones, and I do believe that he'll start to show the promise he initially showed at Blackburn. His reading of the game has massively improved, and whilst he still has some recklessness in him, I'm sure that will be coached out of him as there's already progress being made in that department. Look at how often he's filled in excellently for Blind. He's been a great supporting defender for Blind on that left side, and I sometimes wonder if we'd have fared as well on that side if Rojo was there instead of Jones.
Of the young central defenders playing in La Liga the one who's impressed me most this season has been Jose Gimenez who reminds me of Vidic. Anyway my original post wasnt to compare these players but more to point out that even the highest rated young defenders make mistakes but these get ignored while Jones often gets vilified on here for things which arent even his fault such as the Valencia back pass.
Definitely. Young defenders do make mistakes quite often, but they're often brushed under the carpet unless you actually pay attention to their defending. Certainly, people have been very watchful of Jones, and I doubt most would have kept a close eye on other young defenders like Varane, Laporte, Sule, etc.
However, J.M. Gimenez has been a very refined defender for someone of his age. I'm sure that he'll be the best defender in the world when he develops and refines his game even more.