I'll check it out.
Played it for myself on the PS3 all day so far, and I personally thought it was brilliant. A few small issues, but nothing that really takes anything substantial from the game. The game play is superb, a fantastic improvement on last years style. The shooting is the same as usual, except those incredible shots from so far out, aren't as frequent. The passing is excellent, a touch more realistic as not all through balls magically find their target, you have to aim properly this time. The speed of the game is perfect, it's not too fast that it's unrealistic, and it's not too slow to bore you either, it runs smooth and nice.
Overall, I think the new Pro is excellent so far. A sharper menu system, easier save modes, the save highlight system. The only slight problems are the slow-ups on replay scenes, a thin Edit Mode and the obvious licensing issue. But none of those things are really anything to take away from the actual game. A few dress-up flaws sure, but the core of the game, the actual football, is beautiful.