sherrinford
Full Member
- Joined
- Jan 3, 2017
- Messages
- 1,257
Seriously?
Rashford till Jan, Fred, Cavani, AWB, Bruno, Shaw, Maguire all more consistent for me last season. They all, Cavani aside, played about 2000 more minutes than him too.
Hes a really good player but injuries and inconsistency are his enemy.
Shaw and Maguire were consistently good, but I find the idea that Fernandes or, particularly, Rashford were more consistent to be ridiculous. Wan Bissaka and Cavani are more stable in their performances but I don't particularly value Wan Bissaka's contributions and simply don't think Cavani was quite as good. Fred was fine but not as good as he was the season prior and certainly not as good as Pogba.
Of the players you mentioned, 3 are defenders (so not mids and attackers) and the rest don't have poor/mediocre performances slotted away in an "inconsistency" bucket the way Pogba does.
If every mistake or poor performance was proof of inconsistency, then last season Pogba was more consistent than the majority of our players.
As for Whoscored, I'd have a lot of players over Rashford and Bruno consistency-wise last season (and I'm sure you'd agree in the case of Rashford). Shaw, Fred, Pogba, Maguire, to name a few. So while I acknowledge their stats, I disagree with the conclusion.
In any case, all that has little to do with what I was saying. I'm not saying anything else beyond the bounds of his consistency compared to his teammates last season, and at the end of the day he was one of our most consistent players, yet inconsistency is still being talked about like he has a special problem with that. He doesn't, he's just as consistent as anyone else in the side.
This.
We didn't switch to a Herrera - Pogba double pivot by the end of this season. Fellaini was a third midfielder whenever Carrick wasn't present, which was what happened in the Ajax final.
There's no way Pogba was better than Cavani and Bruno last season either. He had a good season, but you are overrating it at this point.
Yes, as a No.10. Actually I would agree that it wasn't always a 4-2-3-1 (though it definitely was in the final) but Pogba certainly played as the second function midfielder as opposed to the third function midfielder.