If you compare our defensive record last season to this season, you can see we have in general improved across the baord
2018/19 Premier League - 38 Games | 2019/20 Premier League - 27 Games | |
Goals Conceded - 54 (11th). 1.42 GA per game | Goals Conceded - 29 (Joint 4th). 1.07 GA per game | 2019/20: 0.35 Better |
XGA - 48.3 (9th). 1.27 GA per game | XGA - 26.4 (5th). 0.98 GA per game | 2019/20: 0.29 Better |
Clean Sheets - 7 (15th) CS%: 18.4 | Clean Sheets - 7 (Joint 7th) CS%: 25.9 | 2019/20: 7.5% Better |
Shots Against - 169 (12th) 4.4 SA per game | Shots Against - 92 (4th) 3.4 SA per game | 2019/20: 1.0 Better |
Saves - 124 (15th Low to High) 0.680 Shots to saves | Saves - 64 (Joint 4th) 0.685 Shots to Saves | 2019/20: 0.005 Better |
Penalties Conceded - 6 (Joint 4th Highest) | Penalties Conceded - 1 (Joint 14th) | |
Free Kicks Goals Conceded - 2 | Free Kicks Goals Conceded - 1 | |
Corner Kicks Goals Conceded - 7 | Corner Kicks Goals Conceded - 7 | 2019/20: On course for 2/3 worse |
Own Goals - 3 | Own Goals - 1 | |
So on paper, there's plenty of statistics hat suggest we've improved in almost every aspect, ever the goals from corners isn't too far off what it was last season, which is disappointing given the purchase of Maguire and the more settled nature of our back four selection as opposed to the previous season where we didn't seem to have that to the same extent. We are however conceding fewer shots & have a lower XGA, which I feel can seen seen as potentially more accurate stats than simply goals conceded + Clean Sheets. Watching the games, I am one that is surprised at the improvements across the board generally as we seem to have a spell of a panic and desperate defending each game.
From the stats I'd summaries, we are yet to have a world class, solid defence that we'd consider fixed there have however been a nice improvement compared to last season.
The additions of Maguire, AWB, McTominay establishing himself in front, Willaims/Shaw coming into 1st 11 more as opposed to Young seems to have had a positve effect
A key talking point as to whether the defence has actually improved is to see if we have sacrificed the attacking part of our game. We all know that a team that sits deep and doesn't take risks when attacking are less exposed than expansive sides so we may have just become a team set up to concede less rather than any real defensive improvements. A few of the attacking stat comparisons, last season to this.
2018/19 Premier League - 38 Games | 2019/20 Premier League - 27 Games | |
Goals For - 65 (5th) 1.71 Goals per game | Goals For - 41 (Ranked 6th) 1.52 Goals per game | 2019/20: 0.19 Worse |
XGF - 59.6 (3rd) 1.56 Goals per game | XGF - 41.7 (Ranked 5rd) 1.54 Goals per game | 2019/20: 0.02 Worse |
Shots - 518 (5th) OT - 212 (2nd) %OT - 40.9% (1st) | Shots - 391 (4th) OT - 142 (4th) %OT - 36.3% (5th) | 2019/20: Shots on Target % - 5.6% Worse |
Shots per game 13.63 (5th) 0.11 Goals per shot (Joint 6th) | Shots per game 14.48 (4th) 0.09 Goals per shot (Joint 5th) | 2019/20: 0.85 More shots/ 0.02 Lower GPS |
Goals per SOT - 0.26 (16th) | Goals per SOT (0.24) (18th) | 2019/20: 0.02 Worse (Both Terrible) |
Shots From Free Kicks - 28 (2nd) 5.4% Total Shots | Shots From Free Kicks 25 (1st) 6.4% Total Shots | 2019/20 1% Higher |
Pens - Scored 9 of 12 (75%) 16.7% of Total Goals | Pens - Scored 6 of 10 (60%) 14.6% of Total Goals | 2019/20: Worse Conversion, Lower TG % |
Expected Goals Non-Pens - 50.4 (6th ranked) 1.33 per game | Expected Goals Non-Pens - 34.1 (7th ranked) 1.26 per game | 2019/20: 0.07 Worse |
The key Interesting thing here to me is that a lot of the stats are similar, with a consistent small drop across the board. Our Total Shots and Expected Goals are all very similar to last season however we seemed to perform well above our expected goals and had a significantly higher shots on target %, suggesting that it isn't a change to a more defensive style that has caused fewer goals scored and a better defensive record but rather a defence which has genuinely improved with an attack which is now performing more to par rather than an over performance we saw last season
In my personal opinion, and all season like a lot of fellow United supporters, I've watched as we seem panicky in defence as well as unable to create chances so to suggest that defence is better, attack is actually the same in reality seems odd, especially given our far worse points total as opposed to last season but with Bruno arriving, Pogba hopefully fit soon for the remainder of the season. We may Finish this Premier League season saying
Yes our defence has clearly improved and Yes our Attack has improved too.