Our Defence - Has it actually been fixed?

Defence isn't a big issue for me. The Spurs result was a bit of a freak result scoreline wise.

Chelsea and Arsenal games again highlighted we find it hard to break teams down when they sit in. Midfield and Forward line didn't play well at all yesterday. Midfield didn't look balanced, despite functioning extremely well in the Champions League, and the forwards didn't get any service. Cavani hardly touched the ball when he came on.
 
A-man said:
11 goals scored and 3 conceded (of which 2 own goals and 1 penalty)
Click to expand...

We struggled to create much in two of the last five matches, in which we didn't score and dropped five points, while late goals made the Newcastle and Leipzig scores look better than the performances were.

The issue is there. We need to find a balance between protecting the backline and giving our attack the most options. Longer term, we need to improve the backline so it doesn't need as much protection.
 
There is a clearly a balance issue still there. We want to play fairly high up the pitch but have two slow CBs. So we end up playing a double pivot to stop counters, which means our midfield has less creativity. We play without natural wingers, but our full backs don't provide width. I like AWB and Maguire but we've spent £130m on two defenders with fairly big flaws for their positions.
 
Amir said:
We struggled to create much in two of the last five matches, in which we didn't score and dropped five points, while late goals made the Newcastle and Leipzig scores look better than the performances were.

The issue is there. We need to find a balance between protecting the backline and giving our attack the most options. Longer term, we need to improve the backline so it doesn't need as much protection.
Click to expand...
It is hard to say if our struggle comes from too defensive set-up or poor performance from attacking players. Against Arsenal we had periods where we had a high line and played around Arsenal who dropped back, but we hardly created anything. It's too easy to blame everything on the defence, that they need more protection than what is normal. It's not that simple. I don't know many successful backlines that can manage without any protection from the midfield. We saw how we scored 5 goals on the Bundesliga leaders, and one reason was because of their poor protection from the midfield. When it comes to the defensive midfielders, they are very limited in finding ways through the midfield. That is probably why Matic came on. It might be that we need one better DM, instead of 2 average, or two who are better footballers.
 
A-man said:
It is hard to say if our struggle comes from too defensive set-up or poor performance from attacking players. Against Arsenal we had periods where we had a high line and played around Arsenal who dropped back, but we hardly created anything. It's too easy to blame everything on the defence, that they need more protection than what is normal. It's not that simple. I don't know many successful backlines that can manage without any protection from the midfield. We saw how we scored 5 goals on the Bundesliga leaders, and one reason was because of their poor protection from the midfield. When it comes to the defensive midfielders, they are very limited in finding ways through the midfield. That is probably why Matic came on. It might be that we need one better DM, instead of 2 average, or two who are better footballers.
Click to expand...

Against Arsenal, Pogba and Fernandes were marked - and that was that, we didn't have anything else to offer. We weren't going to get any creativity or a game-changing move from our midfield players.

Football is simple. You have a better chance when your players have more to their game. If you've got midfielders who can both shield the backline and be creative and contribute to the attack, you're in a good position. We don't have that and while previously we took more chances with our selection - as I think Pogba is suspect when he plays a more defensive role - in recent games we prefer our more defensive oriented midfielders. Sure, every defence needs shielding, but if you use two players to do that, it comes with a cost.
 
Amir said:
Against Arsenal, Pogba and Fernandes were marked - and that was that, we didn't have anything else to offer. We weren't going to get any creativity or a game-changing move from our midfield players.

Football is simple. You have a better chance when your players have more to their game. If you've got midfielders who can both shield the backline and be creative and contribute to the attack, you're in a good position. We don't have that and while previously we took more chances with our selection - as I think Pogba is suspect when he plays a more defensive role - in recent games we prefer our more defensive oriented midfielders. Sure, every defence needs shielding, but if you use two players to do that, it comes with a cost.
Click to expand...
It’s a bit more complicated than that. Agaisnt Arsenal the tactics was totally off, doesn’t mean the whole concept with some protection is wrong. It was the key to winning against PSG imo. One way is to use more offensive FB but still keeping a balanced midfield with both offensive and defensive capacity.
 
A-man said:
It’s a bit more complicated than that. Agaisnt Arsenal the tactics was totally off, doesn’t mean the whole concept with some protection is wrong. It was the key to winning against PSG imo. One way is to use more offensive FB but still keeping a balanced midfield with both offensive and defensive capacity.
Click to expand...

It was indeed. We were away to a top European team (though they are off colour right now) that wasn't going to sit back, which meant our attack had the space in needs even with a less creative midfield.

If you play that way against teams that are going to be far more cagey, you need more than that in order to open them up.
 
Amir said:
It was indeed. We were away to a top European team (though they are off colour right now) that wasn't going to sit back, which meant our attack had the space in needs even with a less creative midfield.

If you play that way against teams that are going to be far more cagey, you need more than that in order to open them up.
Click to expand...
I agree. We can play defence and counter with teams who want to attack but it’s different with teams that sit back. However I would still want protection from the midfield and rather release the fullbacks. And my point, actually: I don’t think two defensive midfielders necessarily means no creativity. It is McT and Fred who means no creativity and they are also poor at transporting the ball imo. But good defensively. I think we’ll be fine with Maguire/Lindelof/ Axel/Shaw/ AWB but would benefit from a defensive midfielder who could also play some football. (Would also prefer more offensive fb but doesn’t seem to happen. And there is no one to head the ball in the box anyway)
 
A-man said:
And my point, actually: I don’t think two defensive midfielders necessarily means no creativity. It is McT and Fred who means no creativity and they are also poor at transporting the ball imo.
Click to expand...

I'm certainly not arguing your point. You are correct. Unfortunately we lack the midfielders who can contribute both defensively and offensively. Which means that with the current squad, we have to choose what's right for each match.

It's just that since Spurs (which, to be fair, came after other bad defensive performances), we always starting these two. With two matches a week, there's probably also the affect of fatigue.
 
Playing two defensive midfielders to cover for the lack of speed of our CB's, is far from fixed. If we played Axel and Maguire or Lindelof that would loosen up midfield. It has a knock on effect in how we setup. Keeping Axel fit is another issue, another question of many for Ole at the moment.
 
Amir said:
I'm certainly not arguing your point. You are correct. Unfortunately we lack the midfielders who can contribute both defensively and offensively. Which means that with the current squad, we have to choose what's right for each match.

It's just that since Spurs (which, to be fair, came after other bad defensive performances), we always starting these two. With two matches a week, there's probably also the affect of fatigue.
Click to expand...
That’s true and that leaves my reasoning to something hypothetical, I guess :cool: I definitely think those two have a place and they’ve done a good job. To play them both was kind of an emergency break and it worked. I don’t necessarily want them to be super creative but they must be more available for a pass and to be able to transport the ball. Instead they give away the ball at dangerous situations, especially Fred who can pass the ball to the feet of the opposition 6-7 times per match.
 
Our defence is in it's worst state since Moyes. Maguire-Lindelöf combo is the worst CB pairing at United in the last 30 years. Championship level defensive coaching doesn't help either.
 
I was told our defence was fixed and how it's better than it was with Smalling, Rojo, Jones etc. but can't see anything that indicates on the pitch. I'm sure there will be some stats that prove it's great though so everything is OK I suppose.
 
As bad as I've ever seen it. Think they had 4 shots on target tonight and 3 goals. Playing 5 at the back and still it looks like no one is marking anyone. It's the reason we play with such negative tactics imo, Ole knows its shite too and doesn't trust them. Need to drop de gea indefinately to start with. To blame for so many goals
 
Will never be fixed with DDG as the keeper. Silent, scared and glued to the goal line. Always legs first when diving for the ball... I would like to see how many goals we conceded from "GK space" in last 2 years.
 
Can we get some better coaching first. I was thinking that VVD made that kind of impact on Liverpool because they were ready for him so to speak. You drop VVD on to this mish-mash of a team and I'm not sure he'd look as good.
 
Same issues tonight as in so many other games. Can't defend simple crosses. Easily exposed in transition. Could even Diego Simeone sort this s-t out?
 
3 crosses that any defender worth his salt could defend in his sleep. 3 goals.

This game was obviously worse than normal, but it's criminal that 3 mistakes like that can happen in 1 single game.
 
Cutch said:
As bad as I've ever seen it. Think they had 4 shots on target tonight and 3 goals. Playing 5 at the back and still it looks like no one is marking anyone. It's the reason we play with such negative tactics imo, Ole knows its shite too and doesn't trust them. Need to drop de gea indefinately to start with. To blame for so many goals
Click to expand...
He bought 3 of those. So I guess we only need to get rid of Lindelof and Shaw and all will be great. Can't wait til we sign the next batch of amazing defenders.
 
They all have pretty awful awareness. Always on the back foot.

AWB doesnt know how to position himself. Its actually pretty disturbing to look at as its something that is fairly easy to work on in training, and he has shown zero progress.
He is also often too lazy in the pressure in regards to blocking crosses.

Lindelof is way too indecisive. Leads to dangerous situations all the time. Feels like he doesnt have the confidence to play his game unless we are 2-0 up.

Maguire is just very slow. Not just his running. His allround movement is so slow-motion. Should not be captain.

We will not become a top team in Europe again with this defence. Its okay, but thats it.
 
Machine Elements said:
I was told our defence was fixed and how it's better than it was with Smalling, Rojo, Jones etc. but can't see anything that indicates on the pitch. I'm sure there will be some stats that prove it's great though so everything is OK I suppose.
Click to expand...
Its better than those three, but its still no where near good enough.

I want to see a centre back pairing of Axel and TFM. Just to be sure that we don't have something that needs to be unearthed.
 
Manny said:
Its better than those three, but its still no where near good enough.

I want to see a centre back pairing of Axel and TFM. Just to be sure that we don't have something that needs to be unearthed.
Click to expand...
No and No. The only we thing we have not unearthed is more shite hiding under the mediocrity of the current back four. Both of them combined can't last 3 matches. Besides, Ole is already in love with Lindelof + Maguire. Long will it last until death do them part. Of course if you are going to get thrashed by City next, imaybe its best to start with a an excuse such as we are in the midst of uncovering the next CB pairing for next 10 years.

Besides, the problem extends to both full backs. They are all fully guilty for all 3 goals, complicit. And not to mention DDG, how do they train to setup to work so well to allow the opponents to walk in and score 3 goals and miss another 3-4 howlers and get 1 chalked off by luck.

Our defence is so fixed, its fixed to fail at the wrong times.
1. Guaranteed concession first.
2. Bruno will drag us back in. He almost always does.
3. No help whatsoever to the attack.
4. We will use the slowest possible DM (Matic) to cover our slowest possible CB (Captain America)
5. No one is aware where the opponents are.
6. Everybody start singing Everything is awesome from Lego the movie.
7. OleAtTheWheel
 
Amir said:
Problem is I feel a big part of it is due to the midfield duo we play. It means we have seven defensive minded players on the pitch and there's a price to pay for it in attack.
Click to expand...

if the score line was 0-0 or 1-0 by 1st half, then yes we were weak in attack. It wasn't the problem. Problem was that when you play 7 defensive players, you meant to park the bus, so where was the bus after 2 min?
 
cyril C said:
if the score line was 0-0 or 1-0 by 1st half, then yes we were weak in attack. It wasn't the problem. Problem was that when you play 7 defensive players, you meant to park the bus, so where was the bus after 2 min?
Click to expand...

I don't know, I wrote it about a month and a half ago, it wasn't about tonight's match...
 
Gerrardian Slip said:
They all have pretty awful awareness. Always on the back foot.

AWB doesnt know how to position himself. Its actually pretty disturbing to look at as its something that is fairly easy to work on in training, and he has shown zero progress.
He is also often too lazy in the pressure in regards to blocking crosses.

Lindelof is way too indecisive. Leads to dangerous situations all the time. Feels like he doesnt have the confidence to play his game unless we are 2-0 up.

Maguire is just very slow. Not just his running. His allround movement is so slow-motion. Should not be captain.

We will not become a top team in Europe again with this defence. Its okay, but thats it.
Click to expand...
I said at most this defence is top 4. You will not mount a title challenge unless you score 100 goals. It was also always get undone in Europe. We got undone vs Seville and now again the same year. Cannot deal with crosses across the box
 
Getting very sick and tired of Maguire peddling out that line that we weren't at it from the start
 
Manny said:
Its better than those three, but its still no where near good enough.

I want to see a centre back pairing of Axel and TFM. Just to be sure that we don't have something that needs to be unearthed.
Click to expand...
Individually maybe, but as a backline no.

People need to realise how protected our current backline is when we keep playing 2 from Matic/Scott/Fred just to help shield them.
 
I don't see any difference from the Smalling years. Still as inconsistent and mistake prone as hell. Smalling also used to put on a great match followed by a disaster. The current defense isn't different.
 
I get that COVID has played it's part in this season but our defensive performances have absolutely fell off a cliff this season and quite honestly show no signs of the drastic improvement that we need
 
You guys need to trust in the process, back Ole to finish rebuild
Not enough yet, 3 more seasons needed, to be extended to +5 seasons.

18/19
- Fellaini
+ Jones

19/20
- Herrera, Smalling, Darmian, Rojo, Young, Valencia
+ Maguire, AWB, Axel, Williams, TFM, Matic, Bruno

20/21
- Romero, Dalot
+ Telles, Henderson
 
Currently our defence is worst than ever.

I blame it all on Pogba.
 
Where the feck are all our defenders?! Shaw the only one on the bench tonight.
 
I hope Telles can lift his game defensively as so far he has been found pretty shaky from what I have seen.
 
The sticking plaster on the defence is a bit better than the plasters on the midfield and forward line.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.