Ole Gunnar Solskjaer | W15 D2 L4

Is Ole a good appointment?


  • Total voters
    2,659
You know what I mean. You're expected to beat the lower teams regardless, but tactics play much more of a role in the games against the better sides, and can be a real difference maker

But we did not beat lower teams regardless, often we lost the most points against the worst teams as we had no clue to unlock defenses. I don't think changing tactics makes much of a difference in big games, if anything tactics mean very little in big games. We beat top teams before, hell we beat Juventus this season under Mourinho, and he was shit, with no tactics but having eleven men behind the ball, and lumping it up front in the big games. It means nothing if we win a few big games, if we cannot regularly beat the teams weaker than us. Post SAF, it is our failure to beat the bottom teams consistently that has hurt us, rather than the big games, which can vary easily.
 
But we did not beat lower teams regardless, often we lost the most points against the worst teams as we had no clue to unlock defenses. I don't think changing tactics makes much of a difference in big games, if anything tactics mean very little in big games. We beat top teams before, hell we beat Juventus this season under Mourinho, and he was shit, with no tactics but having eleven men behind the ball, and lumping it up front in the big games. It means nothing if we win a few big games, if we cannot regularly beat the teams weaker than us. Post SAF, it is our failure to beat the bottom teams consistently that has hurt us, rather than the big games, which can vary easily.

I think you're getting hung up on Mourinho's shortcomings here rather than the point I've made.

We've not played in a game under Solskjaer that has properly tested us, or him, tactically. Spurs on the weekend will be that first test. Until that game has been played, there's not a great deal to analyse about our performances from a tactical perspective.
 
I think you're getting hung up on Mourinho's shortcomings here rather than the point I've made.

We've not played in a game under Solskjaer that has properly tested us, or him, tactically. Spurs on the weekend will be that first test. Until that game has been played, there's not a great deal to analyse about our performances from a tactical perspective.
Disagree slightly. The way we set up against Cardiff or Huddersfield was very different from how we set up against Newcastle. Suspect we'll see another Newcastle-esque performance against Spurs with counter attacking being the main outlet.
 
One huge test for this new Ole-led team is going to be how we respond to being down by a goal.

Can we bounce back. Does the team push on and step up, while being clinical with the chances given to them? Personally, i think the attitude is there. OGS has shown that he has managed to bring back the desire to win and the never say die attitude. But what really sets good teams apart from the great ones (and United should only ever aspire to be a great team), is the ability to snatch a goal from half a chance when the game has otherwise been going against you.

God knows that with our defence currently, when put up against a top side, we are going to concede. So if we are behind, then how do the players respond
 
It is such a wonderful dream scenario for Solskjaer to become permanent manager and win things at United that, that is the reason I think it won't happen. Such dreams rarely come true :(
 
One huge test for this new Ole-led team is going to be how we respond to being down by a goal.

Can we bounce back. Does the team push on and step up, while being clinical with the chances given to them? Personally, i think the attitude is there. OGS has shown that he has managed to bring back the desire to win and the never say die attitude. But what really sets good teams apart from the great ones (and United should only ever aspire to be a great team), is the ability to snatch a goal from half a chance when the game has otherwise been going against you.

God knows that with our defence currently, when put up against a top side, we are going to concede. So if we are behind, then how do the players respond

It's the test for the players now that the Jose obstacle is gone. Specially the ones who like to attack but can be lethargic tracking back.

We are not winning this without putting all the energy in as a team.
 
I think you're getting hung up on Mourinho's shortcomings here rather than the point I've made.

We've not played in a game under Solskjaer that has properly tested us, or him, tactically. Spurs on the weekend will be that first test. Until that game has been played, there's not a great deal to analyse about our performances from a tactical perspective.

Not really, this idea that tactics play more of a part in big games is non sense. Tactics play a part in every game in setting up a team, for any manager. This narrative that the other games were not important and that you cannot analyse those games is non sense. Too much importance is given to the Spurs game as if that will reveal something that has not been revealed before. The assumption that ones ability as a manger will only be measured in big games but the things he does in the smaller games is ignored, because it is expected, yet many fail to do that consistently. The big games are not some big test, at least no more than any other game is.
 

Good read from Ducker.
Wonderful read, Ole just gets United through and through

The article was not kind at all to his predecessor, so glad we've moved forward in a progressive direction instead of waddling in toxicity
 
Well Mourinho was underperforming so badly that he was sacked before Christmas. Ole managing not to be a disaster and getting one of the most expensively assembled squads to beat a few lower teams should be recognised but not seen as some extraordinary tactical achievement just because his predecessor set the bar so low.
Agree. The real stuff starts now. The honeymoon period has gone as well as anyone could have expected, let's see how he fares.
 
Think more details might come out in the embargoed comments. But I have noted that, today two journalists have tweeted that it's a clue that Solskjaer thinks the quality of football he is able to produce till May will prove a more crucial factor in him getting the job than any eventual top four success.
Makes me think the club have prioritised style above everything else in the search for a new managAper. I would be very happy with that.
 
Last edited:

Good read from Ducker.


Very good read. Thanks for sharing.

Wonderful read, Ole just gets United through and through

The article was not kind at all to his predecessor, so glad we've moved forward in a progressive direction instead of waddling in toxicity
:( Yes, very good read, first 10 lines, then I have to register, wonderful. Can someone sum it up in few words. Thanks. Don't say: very good read
 
:( Yes, very good read, first 10 lines, then I have to register, wonderful. Can someone sum it up in few words. Thanks. Don't say: very good read

If you register you can read one premium article a week, which you can use on Ducker's Ole piece.
 
Lots of positive stuff in that Telegraph article but I can’t help but wonder who is leaking the stories from the dressing room and training ground.

Maybe it’s just a puff piece from official club sources but I had the impression that they were keen to distance themselves from bigging up Ole too much while they search for a permanent manager, hence their constant insistence on the use of the word “caretaker” on twitter etc.
 
:( Yes, very good read, first 10 lines, then I have to register, wonderful. Can someone sum it up in few words. Thanks. Don't say: very good read

One of the things mentioned is how an Academy staff/coach remarked that he spoke more with Ole in one morning than he did with Mourinho his whole time here.

Don't know how legit that is, because when Mourinho was in the club's good books, people were talking about how his public and private demeanors are total opposites but there you go.
 


It is surely this run of games that will test solskjaer to the limit . In two months time we will learn a lot about him and this team
 


It is surely this run of games that will test solskjaer to the limit . In two months time we will learn a lot about him and this team


I think we will be somewhere in the middle. What I mean is we'll have mixed performances and results and we'll end up with a debate about keeping Ole. That's what I predict. Won't be a clear yes or no with Ole.
 
13th Jan: Tottenham (A) win
26th Jan: Arsenal (A) win
12th Feb: PSG (H) win
24th Feb: Liverpool (H) win
6th Mar: PSG (A) draw
9th Mar: Arsenal (A) win
16th Mar: Man City (H) win

easy
too much?
 
13th Jan: Tottenham (A) win
26th Jan: Arsenal (A) win
12th Feb: PSG (H) win
24th Feb: Liverpool (H) win
6th Mar: PSG (A) draw
9th Mar: Arsenal (A) win
16th Mar: Man City (H) win

easy
too much?
PSG away might be a loss. But we'll have beaten them 5-0 at home so who cares:devil:
 
Some of you guys take it as a joke but I have feeling that we will win some of those games.
 
PSG away might be a loss. But we'll have beaten them 5-0 at home so who cares:devil:
Was thinking about keeping the unbeaten momentum, so went for a draw.

Looks fine
Thanks, glad I'm not the only one who thinks that.
Would you like correct results?
Some of you guys take it as a joke but I have feeling that we will win some of those games.
1. not joking, just optimistic
2. some of these games? You know Jose left the building Carrington, right. We might not be best team ever, but we are very capable of winning anyone!
 
It is such a wonderful dream scenario for Solskjaer to become permanent manager and win things at United that, that is the reason I think it won't happen. Such dreams rarely come true :(

Anything is possible. I was a huge fan of Zidane as a player, and when he became coach of Madrid I was worried because, first it's a huge club (like United is), and another thing is he didn't strike me as the vocal, managerial type. Most of the brilliant players don't make very good coaches usually because they had a gift that's hard to transmit to others.

Three years later, he's both a player and managerial legend at the club. I don't see why the same isn't possible for OGS. It would make a hell of a story, and so far (very early, granted) he's already done some major transformation on the team in a positive manner. I would love to see him succeed here and become a permanent manager. There's no proof that getting someone else to come in at the end of the year would yield better results and at least this is a servant of the club that knows what the culture is about.
 


It is surely this run of games that will test solskjaer to the limit . In two months time we will learn a lot about him and this team

That's leaving out half the games during that timespan anyway. Between those games there is Brighton (h), Burnley (h), Leicester (a), Fulham (a), palace (a), Southampton (h). Obviously we're also going to have tough games in the next 13. Most pivotal 10 days is March 6-16 though. PSG away, arsenal away, City at home between those days.