Skåre Willoch
Full Member
- Joined
- Sep 10, 2014
- Messages
- 4,304
While your list isn't wrong, it would be fair to ask whether some of those players were bound to improve due to them being young or settling in England. Also, Pogba, Rashford and Martial were always capable of a lot. It's about getting them to do it consistantly that's been the problem, and still is.
For the money spent on them - and fees do count, as we have to spend wisely - I'd say AWB and Maguire would probably need to be great and solve problems long term. They are not, and they are also creating problems. So that's definitely an issue.
All fair points, and I totally understand that many fans feel this way.
I'd add that while most of the players were/are young and/or settling in England, they still need an environment they can thrive in, and trust from the manager. Many of the players mentioned had either a lack of trust / being used as a scapegoat or had simply fallen out with the manager (Fred, Pogba, Shaw). McTominay was a laughing stock "lacking of United quality" according to many (I was probably in this camp as well). I don't think their progress or comebacks were automatic and foretold at all, really. Not all Ole, but not not Ole either.
The jury's out on AWB and Maguire it seems. While I think AWB is still quite lacking in some aspects, he's great in other. Instant upgrade on the RB (Valencia and... Young?), and I think he'll only get better with time, giving him maturity and confidence. I also think Maguire is a very solid signing, and that he can be our starting CB for years to come.
Last edited: