Perhaps he meant the anime, which definitely deserves to be up there?
I'm sorry Pogue but it IS genuinely a brilliant film - and I'm not being pretentious!
I happened to get a video copy of it at the local car-boot sale and I dreaded watching it: I mean, sat in front of a tv watching two-&-half-hours of a silent film was daunting, to say the least! But it wasn't. The story was engrossing, the visuals were sumptuous and the metallic/robotic woman both frighting and alluring.
Along with Nosferatu and King Kong, its one of the greatest films ever made.
Word up, El Grande!
You're right about In the Mood for Love. But it did take me two viewings to appreciate its brilliance.