SportingCP96
My horse comment seems to have gotten to you, that wasn't my intention. But - even though it's pointless since you quite obviously won't listen - I will reiterate what I meant:
A 23 year old G-Leaguer or a Horse WOULDN'T play. That, to me, is a net +- of exactly 0.
Nobody ever questioned Anthony's ability to score, and yes, in that regard he is one of the all time greats and still much better than a lot of current players, even starters. That, however, was not the point of anyone in this thread.
The point is that now that he's old and washed, his scoring isnt't nearly good enough anymore to balance out all his shortcomings. He is by now not only an all time great scorer, but also an all time shit defender. And while his scoring got worse, his inability to defend just keeps on getting more pronounced. He won't be a + player at this point, so as far as I am concerned he is worthless to any team that doesn't want to tank. So yes, I'd rather have a 23 year old G-Leaguer that gets 2minutes and in those two minutes misses one shot but deflects one pass on the defensive end than a 35 year old that chucks balls and won't defend. And yes, I'd also rather have a horse that doesn't play at all. That's the point: Having Anthony on the court hurts your chances to win more than not having him on the court.
Add to that the drama he (and especially the media around him) will inevitable create and there's just no way I'd want him on my team.
Is he skilled enough to
play in the NBA? Offensively yeah, he still got it.
Does he have the mind- and skillset to actually be
useful in the NBA? Nope, not anymore.
Imagine having a football player that will score 0,5 goals a game. That's a great rate. But then you look closer and realize that while he does score in every 2nd game, he will have 3 major defensive blunders week in and week out that put your own team at risk. He also registers 0,01 assists per game. Would you want that guy to play for your team?