Ballon D'or: Messi 7 > Ronaldo 5
Golden Shoe: Messi 6 > Ronaldo 4
Pichichi: Messi 5 > Ronaldo 3
IFFHS Best Playmakes: Messi 4> Ronaldo 0
International Tournament MVP: Messi 5 > Ronaldo 0
IFFHS Playmaker of the Decade: Messi
La Liga Best Player Award: Messi 6 > Ronaldo 1
All this difference while Messi is a playmaker first (one of the greatest ever) and one of the top 3 dribblers ever. The only area Ronaldo can compete is the goal scoring and even in that area Messi has an edge with more Pichichis and Golden Shoes.. In terms of style, elegance, technique, creativity Ronaldo does not come close to Messi, Maradona, Cruyff type of players and that's also a big deal for most football fans (an unfortunate reality for Ronaldo fans)..
Most people would refuse to call a player GOAT who has limited creativity, technique or any playmaking skills that's why the majority of the football world goes with Messi, even some of Ronaldo's former teammates. I do not even think most fans who saw Maradona would think Ronaldo is better than Maradona, too much of a talent/elegance gap..
Ronaldo proving in other leagues does not mean anything when Messi is a GOAT level playmaker+dribbler+goal scorer whereas Ronaldo is just a GOAT level goal scorer. His Juve and this United experiments are all considered mistakes. But, yeah, he had a great game today after 10+ poor games, and the whole perception changes here as usual
Ronaldo being "always" the man for the big occasion is sorry but a big BS, he frequently ghosted in the CL finals only to be bailed out by heroics of Ramos, Bale and even Karius. The guy did not even play in the EC final for more than 20 minutes in the EC final yet gets all the credit.