I fail to see how he can be an elite player in that he plays in the PL and earns ridiculous amounts of money. He has no attributes that suggests that he should be playing for us.
His physical attributes are below average. He is slow, he is weak and he doesn't seem to have much of an engine to run up and down the flank either.
His technical attributes are decent, but he can't do much with the ball in tight corners.
His defending is weak and is the easiest defender in our squad to get past one on one. I'm not convinced about his positioning either, and having played cb previously in his career, his aerial ability is shocking.
His attacking is atrocious, not just below average. He doesn't find space in attack, and he has no chance of running into space, and if he by some miracle manages to do that because both winger and fullback did a Stevie G and slipped, then his crossing is woeful.
I'm actually convinced we could take any fullback from any team in the PL and they would perform better. I used to think that he is decent as a squad option as he can play all positions in the defence, but now I'm not so sure.