phelans shorts
Full Member
Yes...before being reprimanded for poor performance and either they improve or get their contract terminated.
Literally not true in the slightest.
Yes...before being reprimanded for poor performance and either they improve or get their contract terminated.
I'm still finding it doubtful.Look at the quote. He said he never refused to play, Ralf said he refused to be in the squad. He's refused to travel because he wasn't going to start.
I agree, get in line or I will throw you to the wolves. Martial has been sacrificed and with the online lynch mob ready to pounce players will think twice before disrespecting him.This was a power play by Rangnick. He is telling the players that he may stay only 6 months here, but in that time span, if they don't do what they are told he can damage them more than they can imagine.
I think that this was a great move by Rangnick! Our players should learn to work, and then work a little more, and listen to the manager. The manager is their boss, not their buddy like Ole.
You answered your own question. Because he wants a move away, and he's trying to force the issue because the club want the loaning club to cover his wage, and he's not willing to take a paycut.I'm still finding it doubtful.
Martial has been benched by Mourinho and Ole and has never refused to be a part of the squad. Why would that change now ? He's looking for a move away, if he gets subbed on and scores a goal it could be the difference between him leaving and him staying.
Guy refuses to do something I ask that is part of his contract for no reasonable reason, I bring him in and talk amicably, then I ask again. If he still refuses I mark on his record, implement performance improvement procedures, ask again, he refuses I give him second warnings before finally moving to terminate his employment.Literally not true in the slightest.
Guy refuses to do something I ask that is part of his contract for no reasonable reason, I bring him in and talk amicably, then I ask again. If he still refuses I mark on his record, implement performance improvement procedures, ask again, he refuses I give him second warnings before finally moving to terminate his employment.
People are incredibly shortsighted and naive so it's easier for players who are basically multimillionaires to manipulate them just like Rashford was until it became too much last last week. It's ridiculous to turn on Ralf when the symptoms of the malaise that sank Ole and Mourinho are there for us to see game in, game out.There has to be more to it than meets the eye. There’s something rotten behind the scenes, it can’t be a coincidence that this is all going on with Martial and we’ve seen Rashfords head drop the way it has.
Something is going on behind the scenes, it might be needed to get to a clean edge for the next manager arriving in the summer but it feels incredibly painful at the moment.
The problem for Ralf is that it feels as though it’ll get worse before it gets better, and fan reaction will make life difficult for him, a lot of fans have already turned on him.
It's an opportunity to send a message to the squad and the fans though. An easy win for the club and Rangnick IMHO if they were to fine him.So you would rather believe a lazy player over the manager even if he is an interim? Why would Rangnick lie, he hasn't been here long enough to develop any antipathy towards Martial? I think Martial didn't expect Ralf to out him and now that he has been outed he is lying to protect his backside.
It depends, it's still just a couple of days after the fact. Looking at it, I find it pathetic that fans are taking a wantaway player's side and basically accusing the manager of lying. Would people be doing this if this was a manager who we had a connection to like Ole or Carrick?
The club and the fan base is strangely insular and hostile to anyone who does things differently from what we knew under Fergie especially if they are foreign. Eerily I think Martial and Rangnick are both victims of this, as was Van Gaal and Mourinho to an extent.
Guy refuses to do something I ask that is part of his contract for no reasonable reason, I bring him in and talk amicably, then I ask again. If he still refuses I mark on his record, implement performance improvement procedures, ask again, he refuses I give him second warnings before finally moving to terminate his employment.
He wants to leave. Sitting on the bench sulking won't help his case. Especially with the money he's on.You answered your own question. Because he wants a move away, and he's trying to force the issue because the club want the loaning club to cover his wage, and he's not willing to take a paycut.
It's an opportunity to send a message to the squad and the fans though. An easy win for the club and Rangnick IMHO if they were to fine him.
If they don't then either Martial did nothing wrong or he is above any punishment.
I side with Ralfy chops.
It really wouldn't, it's a matter of budget this time of year for most clubs, not panic singing a striker on loan because he happened to come off the bench and get a goal against Villa. Most clubs have to offload before they can sign someone else, which is why no one is willing to meet his wage demands. If any clubs genuinely believed in his ability, they wouldn't be waiting for him to score a goal or two this month before making a bid would they?He wants to leave. Sitting on the bench sulking won't help his case. Especially with the money he's on.
Coming on putting in some good performances would change that.
No mate. Wasn’t the “giving it their all” part I was really getting at...I originally replied to a guy who said as an employee, Martial shouldn’t be expected to turn down money as part of his contract. I said it’s not comparable to a normal contract as if it were, there would be mechanism to address a breach of contract - ie. poor performance or refusing to do something reasonably expected under the contract.So you think everyone is giving their all? Oh boy do I have some news for you
Not MartialMartial has denied saying that he did not want to travel. So who do we believe.?
Ralf worded it carefully. He said squad. Martial was most likely told he was not going to make the bench or play at all but should be part of the squad. Martial said no thanks. Odd one for Ralph to drop in it as it just causes more headlines imo.Martial has denied saying that he did not want to travel. So who do we believe.?
When?Will only believe this if he gets fined because that should be the next step when a player refuses to play. Horrible from Martial if true. He used to love the club so much I dont know how it’s come to this.
He did not, Ralf said he didn't travel because he refused to be in the SQUAD, Martial said he never refused to PLAY. He was obviously told he would be in the squad so he refused to travel to sit on the bench, however he would have travelled if he was told he was starting, or so it seems.Martial has denied saying that he did not want to travel. So who do we believe.?
Well that's tough for him. He has to be assured of playing before he travels. If this was the case with all players we would have an empty bench. Get rid quick as we can.He did not, Ralf said he didn't travel because he refused to be in the SQUAD, Martial said he never refused to PLAY. He was obviously told he would be in the squad so he refused to travel to sit on the bench, however he would have travelled if he was told he was starting, or so it seems.
Yeah I suppose the player has way of finding excuses . What a clusterfeck, just look what we are talking about. We are a circusIf a player says he can't play because his back is hurting, you cannot punish him.
Agreed. If he refused to be part of the squad then we really need him gone this window, it can't wait until the summer.Well that's tough for him. He has to be assured of playing before he travels. If this was the case with all players we would have an empty bench. Get rid quick as we can.
Way I see this.
Martial is told he isn't starting and will be on the bench.
Martial not happy and says he doesn't want to travel if he is just gonna sit on bench.
Ralf tells the media Martial didn't want to travel.
Martial says I never refused to play.
Therefore, Martial correctly didn't refuse to play, however, he did refuse to travel if it meant he would only be sitting on the bench.
I think that sums up the situation and both are correct, from a certain point of view.
Some takes on here are just embarrassing. Would you personally turn down money that is part of your contract at your job? Why would you expect any employee to do that?
- Martial is covering his own arse by trying to make out it was a misunderstanding so he does get docked wages
- Trying to get public opinion back on his side, like that's possible after declaring himself unfit and immediately requesting a transfer as soon as Ralf takes over without a single traing session
- Trying to show to potential buyers that he's not an entitled temperamental little so and so and won't destabilise their dressing room too
Martial has denied saying that he did not want to travel. So who do we believe.?
I honestly don't get why Ralf would lie. He's been here 5 mins and hasn't caused this mess.
Martial is a snake.