Marcus Rashford - Linked to PSG
- Thread starter saik
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran discuss a horrific month of December and a depressing FOUR defeats in a row - the latest coming against Wolves and Newcastle.
They discuss how much blame is on Ruben Amorim and rank our squad against other Premier League teams.
Do we have any chance of avoiding defeat at Anfield?
United value Rashford at 150!?! In what world. My goodness, ask PSGs for 90 and we could probably get 75 or 80 which is extraordinary for a club as awful at selling players as United
Keeping him when we can get 80M is going to be yet another Pogba + Lingard blunder. If we're going to throw this season away, Rashford isn't going to change much.
The way it was unfolded usually speaks volume. No journalist had a single clue and all in a sudden, they all release articles pretending they know every detail. It was an obvious massive leak and it's very likely it came from the Rashford clan. It's even possible they asked PSG a meeting just to use it as an argument.
I officially don't have a clue about football as I just do not, and never have, seen the player that those at the top of the game seem to when they watch Marcus Rashford.
Others have piled on your post here, I don't mean to add to that but wanted to respond seeing as you replied to me.
I am purely ralking about on pitch attitude, I don't care for rumours and I definitely pay no attention to the press. When things aren't going His way on the pitch, he becomes sullen, insular, his head drops, he starts trying to force things on the ball and he's not good enough to do that which makes it spiral.
I get your point re a lack of confidence, but I think it's more than that.
I think the attitude issue goes right through the academy as I said - add to Rashford the likes of Pogba, Lingard, Greenwood, go back as far as Ravel if you want. We are bringing young lads through who think they've already made it, and lack the mentality to make the most of their ability. In my view, while it's easy to blame individual players, it's getting to the stage where it seems like the club is failing these young men somehow.
some on here really do have agendas!
I suggest some step away from the keyboard and get some fresh air.
Conjuring up revisionist history out of nowhere.
Ok so what's the solution?
I hope ETH has got a measure of Rashford. Because with quotes like that I am now genuinely worried that he'd ok a massive contract for him. The stars may just be aligning for Rashford here to make himself incredibly wealthy.
With the speed the club works it’s best any contract renewal is put on the back burner until the window closes…
If PSG do make a bid then hallelujah. But we all know that’s not gonna happen, and this is just another story to bother Ten Hag with when he has a million other things to worry about.
If PSG do make a bid then hallelujah. But we all know that’s not gonna happen, and this is just another story to bother Ten Hag with when he has a million other things to worry about.
He's off form and had a shit season last year. But there aren't many players who are left winters who have the mix of attributes that he does, or have actually shown it like he did between 2019 and 2021. His pace, shooting, movement, dribbling that he can do (when confident), passing and crossing he is capable of... The guy needs/needed a psychologist, but clubs will be all over a player with his qualities if available because they would feel like they can get him performing to his abilities again. Just as Ten Hag will feel he can. You don't write off a player after a bad season when they are capable of being 100m players and were just that not a whole long time ago.
happy to do deal a swap deal. Verrati plus that Goat.
The difference is that Rashford is on a lot higher salary, last I saw it was 4 times what Dan James was on, so if PSG match Rashford's wages, he signs a 4 year deal and sees out the deal, then he is on an additional £40 million on top of the transfer fee, whereas for the same salary Dan James is only worth £10 million on top of the transfer fee.
I agree £25m would be cheap, but considering his form and salary, last year of his contract the chance to move him on, I think £40-50m in a fantastic offer and £60m is an unbelievable offer.
Yet we like to act shocked when players don't want to join anymore
Playing for us is a thankless proposition and at other clubs at least you've got a chance at trophies regardless of any abuse.
There's hardly been a player signed over the last 10 years who has left the club with a better reputation than they had prior.
That's just bollocks. Players here are adored when they do well, and supported for a lot longer than they would be at many other clubs.Yet we like to act shocked when players don't want to join anymore
Playing for us is a thankless proposition and at other clubs at least you've got a chance at trophies regardless of any abuse.
The reason players aren't interested in joining has nothing to do with Joe Blogs on RedCafe slagging off Rashford and Co. It's because we're a shambles of a club that has been steadily declining for years.
I suggest some step away from the keyboard and get some fresh air.
Conjuring up revisionist history out of nowhere.
I've always seen this word thrown around by you lot, but it always refers to something vague or implied. I've never seen an explanation as to what this "agenda" might possibly be that makes criticizing Rashford have a sinister motive as opposed to criticizing any other player and holding him to the same standard as everyone else.
He has a an option for a further year, so really it's 2 years left. That's a garbage offer. The only offer that makes sense for Rashford is one where you can replace him with someone who can offer what the staff believes Rashford can offer. And that's a 100m player.
Let's just say I hope Ten Hag is telling a white lie regards to Rashford's importance.
We also boo our own on the pitch quite often to go with the incessant abuse online. It's naive to think that players in the game don't talk to each other and paint pictures of how they're treated.
Add that on to the fact that we're irrelevant on the pitch in regards to top honors and it's no shock why we never get the up and coming stars anymore. Hardly worth the hassle or extra wages they might earn here when there's much more attractive propositions at other clubs without the toxicity.
Our pull with the elite has become all but non-existent without Fergie
Does someone really believes that Rashford is worth a 100M player?
Dele Alli was worth £150 million on transfermarket only 3 or 4 years ago. Then he lost his form gradually, and his stock plummeted then Spurs couldn't sell him until Everton got him on a free with certain requirements to pay, but still way, way off his once valuation. Alli's only 26, there's a chance that Rashford goes the same way as Alli based on his football since the Euros. This is a rare chance to sell a seemingly out of form United player when his stock is still high enough to justify a £60m offer. Who else at the club is worthy of a £60m offer?
He is capable of being a 100m player. He was basically playing like a 100m player for 2 years before last season.
Ok who do you replace him with? Gakpo for 45m who has shown far less, is slower, heavier, less agile, not as good of a dribbler or passer as Rashford? Antony who scored a massive 12 goals in all competitions in the Dutch league as his best season for 80m?
Goalscoring wingers with pace are fecking expensive. 60m doesn't get you anyone good. It gets you an unproven punt who isn't even seen as an elite talent. Rashford is somebody who had 1 horrible season, in a season where everyone else played garbage and he was not an exception. Its very different to Dele Alli. If he has another shit season, then sure. As of now, he had 1 bad year and as a club we should all expect him to get back to the prior season form at the very least.
I hope so and I like Rashford and am willing to give him a chance, but it's such a rare opportunity to sell an underperforming player for big money. This would make him the third biggest sale in the history of the club. Also Alli was arguably better than Rashford before his fall, he was twice Young Player of the Year, England starter and key player.
We need Pilib de Brun translator. Pretty sure we have one on the Caf.
maybe they feel sorry for us! or don't want him to ever score a late penalty against them again...
my first through is the move would be best for both parties... do they have anyone we could ask for in a swap deal?
After one bad season in a completely dysfunctional side under Ole (where he may have played through injury), people here want to dump him when we have no depth up front and with no indication the club has any clue in how to replace him. In the previous season (20-21), even with a run of bad form late in the year, he managed 19 goals, 9 assists in 43 starts between the EPL, ECL and EL.
Looked good in preseason and it would be criminal not to at least give him a chance in ETH's system. If his drop in form continues, we sell next summer when we have the entire window to find a replacement.
Looked good in preseason and it would be criminal not to at least give him a chance in ETH's system. If his drop in form continues, we sell next summer when we have the entire window to find a replacement.
PSG did their due diligence and made an inquiry. This fecking chancer Rashford who’s played like shit for 2 years thinks he could leverage that!? FFS the lack of self awareness with this squad. Shut up and play better then maybe you’ll get paid.
am I right that he got just four league goals last season? sorry, but that's nowhere near good enough. that's not a "dip" in form... it's bloody horrendous
Would he survive outside of Manchester if he was to go to PSG, I think he'd just lose all heart if it happened.
maybe he needs a fresh start...
You think he'd lose heart getting treated like royalty by the Qataris and being a wealthy young millionaire in fecking Paris??
You can be given all the glory on the planet and still get fecking home sick.
With Alli though, maybe just me, but I always wondered what he was so great at. Never really liked him. Physically he didn't have any good attributes. Technically he was always average in pretty much every department. He was playing well as a second striker, in a Muller type role where he was just making good decisions and showing good movement which goes a hell of a long way. Just fell off the earth though. Rashford has always had far more talent and raw attributes with his pace and strength and agility, where the right system and just get his desire/happiness back and he'll be fine.
Yep, 4 leagues goals is well below his average of 8 league goals a season, over 7 seasons in the first team.
.
You have to question what is the “commercial value”, in a clearly poor footballer being one of the worst players in a badly performing team?
.
.
You have to live in an alternate reality to value Rashford at 120 million. Which unfortunately seems to be the case with Manchester United. He's worth like one tenth of that.
Transfermarkt value him at 60M. But for declining players on huge wages from overpaying big club, the transfermarkt value is always too high
I value him at 40M only because he is still young.
And PSG may have overpaid in the past. But they spent 100M+ only on top player. Not on the likes of Rashford