He will win the West Ham fans over. Playing in a deeper back line with lower expectations will make him look good again
Maguire | he stays!
- Thread starter Zoo
- Start date
Nice! lets convert it into euros to make it look bigger...that's what we do with any United transfer right?
€40.5 million euros is a fantastic price for Maguire. Congrats to the club.
€40.5 million euros is a fantastic price for Maguire. Congrats to the club.
Two seasons of absolute shite and wanting him out on that basis is fickle?
Are we supposed to let him stink up the place for a decade before considering selling him?
Happy days
He really needed this.. He is much better than he has been for us over the last 2 season.. the fans got on his back and he never fully recovered..
A step back will be great for him.. He really is a good defender.. just not best suited to our setup and all the attention clearly got to him.
A step back will be great for him.. He really is a good defender.. just not best suited to our setup and all the attention clearly got to him.
If he doesn’t hit the ground running at WH, it looks like he has the exact same scenario ahead of him, and unlike us, they give their undesirables both barrels. Hope it works out for him otherwise it’ll be waking up from a nightmare inside another nightmare.
Glad his misery will soon be over.
Thne ignore the conversion? 40.5m for Maguire, great recovery deal.
Fair, he was 31 and cost 33m. Which leaves Maguire second.
It is a great deal for us, and I think that at least for a couple of years, it is gonna be a good deal for West Ham. In the final one-two years of his contract, a 34-35 years old Magure is definitely gonna be a massive liability though.
On the BBC Sport page Simon Stone said deal has been agreed! So glad to be shot of this donkey and that is an insult to an actual donkey!
I share this opinion. He hasn't been good enough for us, and the pressure of captaincy crumbled him. No one rejects that opportunity of being a captain at United. Should he have stepped down on his own accord? He'd have been called a coward who can't handle pressure.
He's a good player, just mentally not strong enough for a club as big as United. The damage has been done, and he'll never win over the, some, cruel haters among the fanbase.
I'm glad he's leaving as it means I don't need to see him shivering at the back for us again, but also for the good of his career.
It's no good for a man's mental health to having to put on a brave face and be a meme on British soil as well as abroad when applying his trade.
He'll do well there.
People can stop pretending he wasn’t poor long before Greece now.
I feel bad rejoicing this like we won our first trophy for the season
I agree, he’s a human being, he lost his form and couldn’t regain his confidence. I hope he does well at West Ham and shows his best form for them. Having said that I’m glad he’s gone and hope we get a decent young replacement.
I get the feeling Moyes is going to protect him and play him in a role that he's extremely comfortable with. He'll come out and say he's not been fit at United, he's been used wrong, he's a good defender in the right set up etc.
Shouldn't the title of this thread be updated to accepted?
after reading this thread, he’s determined to stay and fight for his place.
Probably because they've seen him play at some point over the last two years.
Not last season, but their last 5 league finishes were:
22/23 - 14th
21/22 - 7th
20/21 - 6th
19/20 - 16th
18/19 - 10th
It's going to be an interesting season for them. I imagine he'll do a good, solid job for them in all honesty. But, I imagine they'll be under the pressure in many games and may struggle with goalscoring/creativity, which then puts further pressure on their defence to keep the score lines down. Tempted to say it's going to be a similar season to last year rather than the one before.
He was brilliant before Greece, still have no idea what he was thinking going there in the first place. He's not bright.
If Moyes gets this and McTominay over the line, he's going to be having a redemption arc rivalling Anakin Skywalker..
Good luck to Maguire though, honestly, it's not worked but no reason really to hate on the guy. Hopefully he gets some decent seasons now (except playing against us).
Good luck to Maguire though, honestly, it's not worked but no reason really to hate on the guy. Hopefully he gets some decent seasons now (except playing against us).
I bet he’s gonna be super salty about us for years. Fabulous.
Honestly it's a positive deal for everyone. I hope he works out well for them.
Last edited:
I know they've done pretty well in the league over the course of Moyes' tenure and before but I can't remember watching them and thinking they were good to watch. I think they'll probably have a better season this season if Moyes gets completely his own way with these transfers.
He'll remember again how to hit the target from corners in WHU which will make him an instant success for them.
19/20 he was average I'd say.
20/21 started horribly but recovered and by the end was having a very good season. Easily the best he had at Utd.
21/22 An absolute disaster, one of the worst individual seasons I can ever remember a Utd player having
22/23 Dropped to the bench for most of the season, when he did play he wasn't very good.
All in all , he's been a shocking transfer. To get 30m for him is brilliant.
20/21 started horribly but recovered and by the end was having a very good season. Easily the best he had at Utd.
21/22 An absolute disaster, one of the worst individual seasons I can ever remember a Utd player having
22/23 Dropped to the bench for most of the season, when he did play he wasn't very good.
All in all , he's been a shocking transfer. To get 30m for him is brilliant.
You think he might give us loads a shit in his club interview for West Ham? I thought he might but I think he think's he's too professional for that.
Varane was no.5 at Madrid wasn't he? Hopefully he can take Maguire's number now.
Looks like a fee has been agreed. Good. He needed out of the club. He is decent but was never a £80m player, spending that much on him was a big mistake.
Yes, exactly. Please change the thread title and spread the joy. We have made a sale!!
Good news for all concerned.
That fee looks even worse when we had previously agreed £50m and then cancelled the deal last minute because Mourinho had a tantrum.
Absolutely. At the time of signing him, I was never convinced he was the right move for United. In all honesty, I felt he was a downgrade on Smalling, and to this day I still feel he was/is. He may be slightly better with the ball, but the difference isn't as stark as the other attributes. They may be similar in the air, but I think Smalling pips him there, but in terms of speed, agility, one on one defending etc, Smalling is leagues above. Strange voice though...
Didn’t he go on holiday with his family?
Imagine him leaving here to get away from our booing fans to only get booed by their fans as well
Pretty much. Even his best season was not consistently great. He failed to improve on the player he replaced - the opposite in fact.
I'm struggling to remember what their football was like in the season before last, to be honest. The exact quality, I mean. 6th and 7th place finishes are really good for them, however. Even if the football isn't exactly free-flowing, their fans would be delighted with a finish close to that after their last season.
From Maguire's point of view, it's a very good move for him. Even if he has 2 good seasons there before tailing off, that'll be good for him. He'll be fine and the pressure won't be the same.
I hope he does but I think you’re right - he thinks he’s too professional rather than actually being so.
Good enough deal, 30 million for a 30 year old CB who is 4th or 5th choice CB, more importantly liability whenever he steps on the pitch is a very good deal.
Hopefully he recovers and regain his form, he used to score lot of goals too for Leicester and England but missed easy chances for us. Now maybe he can go back to scoring 4-5 goals a season for West Ham and become one of the leaders there.
Hopefully he recovers and regain his form, he used to score lot of goals too for Leicester and England but missed easy chances for us. Now maybe he can go back to scoring 4-5 goals a season for West Ham and become one of the leaders there.