Great move if this comes in. He makes defending seem quite effortless. There are obviously more priorities in the squad but with Maguire leaving we’ll be short on centre backs and with Varanes injury record it would be silly to go into the season with three cb’s one of which being him.
Kim Min-jae | signed for Bayern
- Thread starter MyOnlySolskjaer
- Start date
- Status
Martinez, Varane, Kim and Lindelof would suddenly make for as strong a CB group as we've had in a very long time with the expected departures of Jones, Tuanzebe and Maguire.
Hope the rumors are true, he looks the perfect profile for the Premier League
Hope the rumors are true, he looks the perfect profile for the Premier League
Well they are gems, arent they?
Regarding Kim, I hope we won't get fleeced for him cause we need funds for other positions which are imo a priority.
Last edited:
Adam has proven nothing so far at United. Garnacho is a great pickup, very young too. Both of them are too young to starting consistently
Never heard mattino before so not sure if it’s reliable.
Yeah but those are gems, talented players, you unearth them, buy them and sometimes they proved to be a star, sometimes they fade.
any chance he can convince Son to come join him at United?
Would we want him now though
i most certainly would...i think he would ideal for United still
Where would he fit best
Supposedly a €56m release clause, which isn't too bad for a highly rated player these days tbh
This would be a very smart signing, I think we'd integrate him into the team patiently and he'll ultimately displace Varane within a season.
Would be great squad planning to have that quartet as our options along with Shaw in our inevitable yearly CB crisis.
Yeah hopefully that's what happens
No concrete contact = we shook hands on a grass surface
It's so on!
It's so on!
easily could play on the wing for us....his pace on the counter with Rashford would be terribly difficult for teams to defend
Think he’ll play mainly with martinez. Rotate with Varane quite a bit as Varane can’t stay fit for full season. Unless ETH wants to play 3 at the back in some games… that could work.
I'm now thinking this is quite unlikely. Apparently a striker and midfielder is our priority with the latter even dependent on sales. So given this deal has to be sealed within 15 days and we most likely won't make any big sales by then, I don't think we'd take the risk of spending 40m on a defender which could hinder our chances of getting ETH's top two priorities. Only way I see this happening is if we get Rabiot on a free as the midfield signing
Amad nor Garnacho aren't gonna be players on which next season will depend on, I'd be highly surprised about it.
The type of player I'm talking about is Saliba at Arsenal, in a fantasy scenario, if they're to sell him tomorrow, his fee would be great because he's perform wel beyond expectation and turned himself quickly into an invaluable player
Don't think I've ever seen this guy play... is he only a CB or is he a bit more versatile? Can in play in a back three if required?
Can see Arsenal joining the race for him after their obvious drop in form since losing Saliba against Sporting.
Theres a review on Youtube of him if youre interested, although obviously its one guys opinions. Compares him with Vidic. Very good and pro-active tackler and very intelligent positionally. Statistically he's very efficient in possession but not at Licha's quality on the ball, obviously.
It’s exciting that we are already being reported doing deals and speaking to player entourages. Whether it’s true, false or somewhere in between it’s light years ahead of last summer and those before it where we consider planning to weigh up and ponder possibly making an offer for a player. Let’s go!!!
It’s exciting that we are already being reported doing deals and speaking to player entourages. Whether it’s true, false or somewhere in between it’s light years ahead of last summer and those before it where we consider planning to weigh up and ponder possibly making an offer for a player. Let’s go!!!
True but also not good when you hear reliable journos say nothing can be agreed until ownership is finally sorted out
He’s speaking with PSG apparently.
I doubt we will sign him or even a CB. There is no reliable journalist links us with him or even a CB. I wouldn’t be surprised if we sell Maguire, we will stick with Varane, Martinez, and Lindelof while Shaw and Casemiro can also cover this CB position. I actually like this idea, this might help us to sign 2 new midfielders to upgrade McFred.
This is becoming too much from Il Mattino. There's no one reliable advancing any of this news, and here they are talking about a house being arranged! Watch this fall off once the summer transfer windows is underway.
This would be suicidal. You can't go into the season with 3 recognised centre backs when Varane is very injury prone. Shaw is only cover for the left side which is Martinez' position, and we need Shaw at LB.
Reportedly in talks with PSG at the moment. I’d imagine this is far from done. We’re still owned by the Glazers.
We can because we will have 5 options to play in CB position if you include Casemiro and Shaw. The defenders we have currently already been solid to secure us 17 clean sheets. Imo, there are at least 5 positions to cover/upgrade before CB. Ideally after those positions, we can start talking about CB. I think that could be the reasons why we haven’t been linked with any CB by reliable journalists in comparison to midfield, keeper, striker, and right back.
I doubt we're even in talks with anyone, we won't be signing anyone until the club is sold IMO.
C'mon get him before anyone else does.
Why would we count Casemiro considering he's not a centre back. He's someone you'd play there in a unprecedented injury crisis, every team technically players who could play out of position in a horrendous injury crisis, that doesn't count as depth. And if he ends up at CB it means you've lost something in midfield, the same way if Shaw is forced to CB we've lost something at left back.
If you're doubling up on players covering a 2nd position then you're losing overall depth.
If Dalot could play CB would you consider going into the season with AWB, Dalot, Varane, Martinez, Shaw and Malacia? That would still leave us 2 RB options, 4 CB options, and 2 LB options, but only 6 defenders in total compared to the 8 we have now so it wouldn't make sense. It's never a good idea to cut the amount of options you have just because a player can cover multiple positions if needed, particularly when you have injury prone players. 2 first team players per position is standard at this level, I see no reason for us to voluntarily go from 8 defenders to 7 defenders when we're trying to improve. If we don't have the money to replace Maguire we need to bring in someone cheap, not just forget about it and hope for the best.
No, we won’t lose something midfield. If Casemiro playing CB when needed, we still have 2 new midfielders to cover hence why I mentioned 2 new midfielders.
It’s about quality not quantity!!
Maguire only starting for us 7 league games, 3 in EL, and 2 in league cups. Is it necessary to spend 45m and 150k pw on a CB just to play 7 league games and 3 UCL games in a season when we can use the money on other areas because we are more desperate for 2 new midfielders, keeper, striker, and may be even right back. My answer is NO.
Our squad depth quality is worse if we don’t have cover for Casemiro and Eriksen than Varane. McFred cannot do what Casemiro and Eriksen are asked to do. And it’s shown this season. Hence why signing cover for Casemiro and Eriksen first.
Last edited:
Haven't seen us strongly linked to many midfielders so far,however would agree with you on the other positions
We have been linked with Rabiot and Kone by more reliable journalist than with KMJ or centre back so far.
Are those two similar kind of players?
- Status