I would buy him from Ajax for a cheap price and let them have old Huntelaar. We should then loan him out to a PL club and see how he does. I personally think he is a great talent and wouldnt mind him here with Lukaku.
think the start of this season shows that he shouldn't take a step up yet. he needs to be able to perform even when the team isn't running smoothly or when things aren't going his way like in the EL final. Also depends what you mean by 'cheap'; Ajax reportedly turned down a €50m offer from Monaco in the last week of the window.
Also quickly to add slightly more to my last comment; I said 'no football-technical flaws', but I should actually say that I find him a bit too one-footed. I can't imagine he isn't very capable with his left foot too, but he does everything with his right, which can get him into trouble sometimes when he predictably turns open to the right because that.
Also as youtube compilations can be seen as a bit misleading, here's his personal highlights of his best match in our shirt, at home vs Celta last season. Was probably the best first half performance I've seen in my whole life as an Ajax supporter, from any player
Off topic, i cant watch many Ajax games here in my country, some of you could tell me how is David Neres doing there?
You happen to mention my second favourite player in our squad. Since he joined us in January he's got a lot of flack from the press, our fans, and rival fans, because he's a very expensive young Brazilian who wasn't playing much. From day one I've seen something special in him and have been pushing for him and raving about his potential on other websites(probably annoyingly so).
Up until this match against Feyenoord he had a record of scoring in every league match he had started in (6 in a row). Now our manager has finally given in to his natural talent and started him 3 matches in a row, resulting in 2 decisive goals vs Heerenveen, an assist and great goal vs Sparta, and then a hattrick of assists for our first three goals against Feyenoord on sunday. So opinion on him has predictably shifted very quickly, but this also means he will be likely to start a lot more from now on.
The great thing about following him, if you wanted to, is that Brazilians seem to love following their young players overseas, so for every match of his you can find a youtube highlights all his touches the next day. His best matches have probably been last season vs Go Ahead Eagles, once he found some confidence about 30 minutes in:... never mind, as I type this I've found out that that one video has been taken down so don't have a video of his best performance.
at 0:59 here you can see his nice assist anyway
and here's his performance against Sparta last week
as you can see his play is far from perfect. he messes up simple passes and takes poor decisions, but he's actually so incredibly good at finishing 1 on 1 that I've made a case for playing him up front in a free role as a centre forward, with Dolberg at the tip of a midfield diamond behind him. He's got a great close dribble; really dribbles purely on technique the way Martial does, for example, compared to the more Bale/Ronaldo ish style of 'anticipatory' dribbling (which Kluivert leans more towards). What I really like about Neres is that he always immediately moves as he passes, really looking for the combination, and keeping awareness. He is prone to dribbling into trouble too much and losing control as he gets further into his run. But I'm personally really really excited about him.
sorry that my comments are all getting so long