USREDEVIL
Full Member
Preparing to potentially create a possible bid!
I'd hoped that would have changed with the new CEO.
He's really poor on the ball but AWB is a good defender. Just not for a club like United. Palace was right for him.Let me clarify: Me describing AWB as a ‘monkey’ has NOTHING to do with with the fecking colour of his skin. Jesus christ, are we past this already?
No, the way he moves his flexible body about the pitch always reminds me about a monkey moving through the jungle. It’s actually a compliment, because it’s quite gracefully. The only unfortunate thing is that the comparison is also correct in that both the monkey and AWB can’t handle a football for shit.
There's also implicit trust in playing him at RB, even if temporarily as Timber knows absolutely everything expected of him in the role, so it becomes one less thing to worry about this pre-season, at least. Ajax's full-backs have complicated roles in and out of possession so Timber there really cuts coaching and stressing down by taking a position out of that equation.It's also a case of seeing what we have, and what he is, and what is available. Is Timber part of Ten Hag's future plans as a CB? Sure. Timber is only 20 though. New league and drastically more difficult one. He can play at RB and Ten Hag has used him there in the past, but obviously they had an excellent RB in Mazraoui so he was the main guy. With that in mind... He'll look at our squad and see Varane, Maguire and Lindelof as CB options, with only Dalot as a RB option. It's common sense. What is a bigger upgrade, Timber over Maguire or Lindelof while using Dalot, or Timber over Dalot while using Maguire?
He might move him centrally eventually or use him to rotate there while mainly being a RB, and eventually buying a right back. Those who say "buy a RB then".... Well, who? Easy to say buy a RB, but maybe Ten Hag and the recruitment team feel Timber would do a better job at RB than anyone we could buy at RB, while also being part of the long term plan anyway, while at the same time being a stop gap until we find a long term RB.
Pau Torres is left footedDue to our CBs being all around the same age, it makes sense for us to target a younger CB. Whilst I love the idea of Timber coming onboard, I'm surprised we haven't targeted a left footed CB. There are some younger left footed CBs out there with awesome potential that would be a great fit for the squad. Unless Timber is going to split his time at RB and CB, then this deal doesn't make sense. Hopefully we target a left footed CB next year.
Pau Torres is left footed
Club doesnt know Gvardiol.Not sold on him to be honest. I'd much prefer Gvardiol over him
Hmm showing your true self now; what was your original ID which presumably is was banned?Funniest Caf post since Fontaine's Rivaldo meltdown
Club doesnt know Gvardiol.
Not sold on him to be honest. I'd much prefer Gvardiol over him
Let me clarify: Me describing AWB as a ‘monkey’ has NOTHING to do with with the fecking colour of his skin. Jesus christ, are we past this already?
No, the way he moves his flexible body about the pitch always reminds me about a monkey moving through the jungle. It’s actually a compliment, because it’s quite gracefully. The only unfortunate thing is that the comparison is also correct in that both the monkey and AWB can’t handle a football for shit.
Based on the players seriously linked, I can’t help thinking that we’re moving to 3 centre backs with Timber and Pau Torres each side of Varane or Maguire. This helps Maguire as both are quick (despite appearances, Torres is actually lightning quick and clocks insane top speeds). It also benefits Dalot, Telles and maybe even Laird who might stick around the first team. If we sign Sosa, he operates best at LWB too.
It takes away the need for a DM that shields the defence. De Jong and Fred could work with 3 defenders behind them but wouldn’t be robust enough in big games with 2 centre backs behind them.
We haven’t really been linked with wingers so I’d expect we’ll get another ST. Sancho slightly loses out in this system but surely can adapt to either the AM role or a second striker free role.
He’s a CB. I don’t understand why so many are convinced we’d sign him to be our RB. Could be do a job there? Sure, if needed I guess. But if we want a RB we’d sign a RB.
Our wing back options would need an overhaul to play that system all season, we don't have good enough quality on either side.
Yeah agreed. I mentioned Sosa who operates best at LWB and is the best crosser in the Bundesliga bar Kostic who is like 7 years older. Laird put in sensational performances at RWB for Swansea in the season just gone but struggled at Bournemouth with injuries and playing in a more conventional RB role.
We could upgrade at RWB. The benefit of a 352 is that we’d only really need a ST in attack as opposed to a ST and a RW if we played 433 (and buying an extra CD is typically cheaper than buying an attacker). Antony is the only real RW we’ve been linked with but reports are tenuous at best. ETH pretty much shut down that notion himself while also basically confirming interest in Timber.
The most heavily circulated and seemingly legit rumours do seem to hint at a 352 -
GK: De Gea
RCD: Timber
LCD: Pau Torres
CD: Varane/Maguire
RWB: NEW/Dalot/Laird
LWB: Sosa/Malacia/Shaw
Playmaker CM: De Jong/NEW
Ball Winner CM: Fred;
AM: Fernandes/VDB
Free Role Attacker: Sancho
ST: Ronaldo/Nunez/NEW
Based on the players seriously linked, I can’t help thinking that we’re moving to 3 centre backs with Timber and Pau Torres each side of Varane or Maguire. This helps Maguire as both are quick (despite appearances, Torres is actually lightning quick and clocks insane top speeds). It also benefits Dalot, Telles and maybe even Laird who might stick around the first team. If we sign Sosa, he operates best at LWB too.
It takes away the need for a DM that shields the defence. De Jong and Fred could work with 3 defenders behind them but wouldn’t be robust enough in big games with 2 centre backs behind them.
We haven’t really been linked with wingers so I’d expect we’ll get another ST. Sancho slightly loses out in this system but surely can adapt to either the AM role or a second striker free role.
Sounds like that’s the plan, which I like.That's what I initially thought. However the more I think about it, the more I am warming to the idea of him being signed as a RB
A- AWB is on sale and we're not being linked to a RB.
B- Ajax love their kids to play multiple roles. Rijkaard, Blind and the De Boers all played in multiple roles.
C- ETH already play with a converted LB ie in Blind
D- United's defence is a mess. Varane, Jones, Tuanzebe, Shaw and Bailly are either shit or/and injury prone, Maguire is unsuited for ETH's game and Dalot & Telles aren't good enough. In reality we need at least 2 defenders and someone like Timber whose young, who can play multiple roles and whose on the cheap will be a nice addition to the team. Think of an upgrade on OShea
E- While Pau Torres + Timber would swallow much of our budget (around 80m), this would change if Villareal are truly interested in Bailly and we're able to sell AWB. If the pair can be sold off to a combined fee of 30m-40m then we could get the pair for just 40m.
Due to our CBs being all around the same age, it makes sense for us to target a younger CB. Whilst I love the idea of Timber coming onboard, I'm surprised we haven't targeted a left footed CB. There are some younger left footed CBs out there with awesome potential that would be a great fit for the squad. Unless Timber is going to split his time at RB and CB, then this deal doesn't make sense. Hopefully we target a left footed CB next year.
That's what I initially thought. However the more I think about it, the more I am warming to the idea of him being signed as a RB
A- AWB is on sale and we're not being linked to a RB.
B- Ajax love their kids to play multiple roles. Rijkaard, Blind and the De Boers all played in multiple roles.
C- ETH already play with a converted LB ie in Blind
D- United's defence is a mess. Varane, Jones, Tuanzebe, Shaw and Bailly are either shit or/and injury prone, Maguire is unsuited for ETH's game and Dalot & Telles aren't good enough. In reality we need at least 2 defenders and someone like Timber whose young, who can play multiple roles and whose on the cheap will be a nice addition to the team. Think of an upgrade on OShea
E- While Pau Torres + Timber would swallow much of our budget (around 80m), this would change if Villareal are truly interested in Bailly and we're able to sell AWB. If the pair can be sold off to a combined fee of 30m-40m then we could get the pair for just 40m.
Oh calm down the transfer window isn't even open yet.This fits with one of the recent articles about our season. Lots of discussions and nothing done.
I reckon we won't have problems shifting Bailly but finding a buyer for AWB would be difficult.
Who wrote the article, Warwick Davis?Just read an article in The Sun on him and he is described as “towering”
How have you just seen this? There are 36 pages of nonstop complaining about it.Just seen this guy is 5ft 10". Thiago Silva probably the only CB I can think of under 6ft that has been a success in the PL.
He wouldn't be my choice.
Club doesnt know Gvardiol.
No one saw Konate or Upamecano coming right.Just read that Chelsea have him as one of their targets and not a peep on any interest from us, so you're probably right. Goes to show that we still haven't learnt. He'll be a beast at Chelsea and the CAF will weep, just as it did for Konate.
I cant think of many 20 year olds that have been successful CB's. That and his height makes him a gamble and a project. Is that really what we need to be doing? I can only trust that Ten Haag knows best. But there is no way he comes in as first choice and dislodges Maguire, Varane or even Lindelof. He will be 4th choice, one for the future signing. Or if he starts then he is a one in a generation talentJust seen this guy is 5ft 10". Thiago Silva probably the only CB I can think of under 6ft that has been a success in the PL.
He wouldn't be my choice.
I cant think of many 20 year olds that have been successful CB's. That and his height makes him a gamble and a project. Is that really what we need to be doing? I can only trust that Ten Haag knows best. But there is no way he comes in as first choice and dislodges Maguire, Varane or even Lindelof. He will be 4th choice, one for the future signing. Or if he starts then he is a one in a generation talent
He is believe meOr if he starts then he is a one in a generation talent
I cant think of many 20 year olds that have been successful CB's. That and his height makes him a gamble and a project. Is that really what we need to be doing? I can only trust that Ten Haag knows best. But there is no way he comes in as first choice and dislodges Maguire, Varane or even Lindelof. He will be 4th choice, one for the future signing. Or if he starts then he is a one in a generation talent