Alrighty, this might get a little lengthy but I generally find the discussion here quite interesting, even if not everyone is interested in the more detailed analysis of the Dortmund squad. I am only replying to this now because I only had my phone over the weekend and was honestly a bit gutted about that display against Bremen.
Before I get into the details I want to acknowledge that
@do.ob essentially made most counterpoints I had and that I would basically sign off on everything he has said.
@DSG I don't mean to attack you in any way, I am really happy that you seem to be quite interested in our team and their performance, it is just curious to me how you can have watched as many of their matches as you say and then come to some conclusions that are extremely different to mine. Anyways, here goes.
Given you are a Dortmund supporter, and all of the needs Dortmund has, will Pulisic’s transfer fee be enough to cover their aspirations in the transfer market? If they buy 3-4 players, do they have the cash to spend, say, 40m in addition to the 60m+ they raised by selling Pulisic? Or will they need to sell other players?
I’ve seen a lot of Burki errors over the last 3 years. He is a good shot stopper IMHO, but is there a recency bias here?
I cannot believe that Alcacer will be the first choice striker for a club like Dortmund. His track record suggests his red hot form earlier this season was a blip rather than the norm.
I won’t comment on the Sancho transfer as it is clear that several members are reading the rumors differently than I am, which is fine. Maybe I am wrong, and he won’t move this summer or next winter. It might be better for us if Dortmund stays firm, doesn’t sell and we can use out transfer kitty to upgrade the squad in other areas, hopefully get CL football next season and table an offer for Sancho in summer 2020.
Short answer: Yes, they should have enough cash to do that. So far they have signed Alcacer for €23m and they signed Balerdi in Winter for €15m while selling Pulisic for €64m. While the german TV-deal does not pay nearly as much as it does in the PL there is still decent money to be made and they did play CL this season. While Dortmund is by no means as rich as some clubs in the PL they are not dependent on player sales. They can't afford losing their best players on a free, but as long as the players have running contracts they are not forced to sell to buy anyone. Additionally there will of course be players leaving the club in the summer. Weigl is quite likely, Dahoud might leave since he doesn't seem to make it here, Isak seems to be willing to join another club, Guerreiro might be on his way out as well. All of these players will bring in some cash and I am afraid the club will be able to function without selling Sancho this summer.
I am not sure about Alcacer yet either. I expect Dortmund to go into next season with him as first choice striker and to get someone to build up behind him. His numbers in his first season for us are decent though.
So, conclusions from today’s match.
Burki is suspect. Exhibit A, slow undeflected nutmeg on a shot outside the box, letting in a goal.
Pulisic is the best player on the field with a goal and setting up the Alcacer free kick. He absolutely abused Friedl. After that performance, I can honestly say that Favre didn’t rate Pulisic. Of course, Favre doesn’t want to play the high press, so maybe that’s it because Pulisic is absolutely made for the high press.
Guerreiro may want to play CM, but he never will because he is completely one-footed. Anyone playing him there is either desperate or stupid because he cannot switch field with a right footed pass. His future is as a LB or winger.
Akanji made an awful mistake for the second goal, and Weigl played the Bremen forward onside which almost resulted in a goal. He’s frequently in no man’s land getting passed around.
Anyway you look at it, Dortmund need to make major moves to solidify defense and GK if they want to challenge for the title. I don’t think the 65m fee for Pulisic is going to be enough to do that. That was a must win against a mediocre team and the entire defense just shit the bed.
Back to Sancho, he didn’t really do much the first 60min, started to come alive later on.
I guess we see things differently. I like Akanji, and Diallo, Zagadou as well. My opinion is that Guerreiro could be great as a LB... but he shouldn’t be moving central.
The data does not confirm the premise that Burki is a great goalkeeper.
They have a right mess on their hands with all of the tinkering the Favre has done with the squad. Bruun-Larsen is the sub that you bring on to score the winner? Ridiculous.
Weigl was brilliant in the Tuchel years as a deep lying playmaker, why has he been shuttled to the bench? Or filling in at CB???
Honestly, if Dortmund wants to seriously challenge they have work to do. Tons of talent in the squad, but very poor management of the talent.
Makes me think that Sancho should move. Because he won’t be winning trophies under this regime...
Nope. I’ve watched 25 matches at least.
Pulisic has not been good in every match. I’ve said that he has been inconsistent. Still, with his talent and Favre’s underwhelming choices (besides Pulisic) for LM, it is easy to draw the conclusion that Favre doesn’t rate Pulisic. You put the blame on Pulisic’s form, I put the blame on Favre for not showing a bit more patience given the kid’s track record.
Your analysis:
Burki is great! Definite Bundesliga-winning GK!
Guerreiro can be a great CM (as long as he is passing to the left!)
The defense is solid! Good enough to win the Bundesliga!
Yeah, I stand by my statement that Guerreiro should not play CM. Yes, the other managers were stupid to play him there. And, given the number of boneheaded errors that I have seen Burki make over the last 3 years, they do need an upgrade there. Just because he’s had 3 good months doesn’t make me forget all the costly errors he’s made in the past and the error he made today is a classic example.
Oh, and by the way, the error by Akanji wasn’t because he was playing RB. CB’s need to make that play 2-3 times a game. That’s what makes it more unbelievable.
Look, this is a Manchester United board. We are waaaayyyy off topic. You probably don’t want Sancho to leave Dortmund this season and he may not. But neither one of us knows the situation there, and the team’s performance, while on the surface looks impressive (especially the early run of form) actually raises a lot of question marks.
I will try to adress this all together.
Bürki did kind of undercut his performances this season with that blunder on Saturday. That does not change the fact, that he is playing a very strong season and I see no reason whatsoever to replace him right now. One of the aspects of his game that you might not be taking into consideration is the fact that he is quite a decent footballer. For teams that want to control games and hold the ball this has become more and more of a necessity and Bürki is very strong in this respect. Sure, a lot of goalies it bottom table clubs can shine with great reflexes on the line and you think: "Wow, he would be so much better for Dortmund" but in reality these situations do not come up as often for a top the table club (or at least they shouldn't
). In addition to that Bürki has actually proven to be a great shotstopper as well this season. So the question is: Can Dortmund easily find a keeper that is better than Bürki, who is good with the ball, a good shotstopper and makes mistakes from time to time? Honestly I would not know who they could buy that would be a significant improvement overall.
Guerreiro is not defensively sound enough to be a LB, he is strong if there is space and less strong when the opposition does not leave a lot of space. He is a decent winger, not more, not less. I wouldn't be too fussed if he left.
Weigl was brilliant under Tuchel in a team that strived for total domination of ball and opposition. Basically a Guardiola approach to football, just not with the billion Euro squad at his disposal. That is probably on of the reasons he ultimately failed in Dortmund. I think Weigls talents would shine most in one of those extremely talented and oppressive teams where he has the time to implement his passing game and isn't held too much with ball winning. That is why a move to PSG would make a lot of sense for him. I think he could once again be brilliant there. So while I don't want Weigl to leave because he is a great dude and a good player I think for his sake he should because in a differently set up team he could once again shine. Unfortunately there are only a handful of teams where that would be the case. We will see, how this develops.
I think we just have to accept that we rate Pulisic's performances this season very differently. To me he was often the most frustrating player on the pitch, endlessly losing the ball because he took on three or four defenders at once. I really like his style and I hope he will do great things for Chelsea because I want him to succeed but this season he has mostly been absolute trash and I don't think you can fault Favre for benching him as much as he did. Bruun-Larsen may not have had a great offensive contribution in the second half of the season but he was definitely less of a defensive risk.
The defense in general was and is a bit of a problem but I generally really like all of Akanji, Diallo, Zagadou and Weigl. Balerdi I haven't seen yet, quite interested to see, how he does. I think Toprak might well be let go this summer. I will give all involved the benefit of the doubt that the injury crisis paired with the fact it was their first full season together led to some of the present issues. I still expect them to be good enough next season.
And as a final note: you complain about players not being good enough to compete for titles. That may well be but in the position Dortmund are in you can't plan on winning titles. No one really expects them to win any titles, Bayern will be winning the league for the seventh time in a row. The goal is to put together the best possible team and then see, how much that will take them. Trying to plan a title winning team would probably be too much ambition and hurt the club in the long run. That does not mean, that they don't want to challenge. But after a season like this one I am mostly happy with how things turned out. Of course I am gutted that they won't be winning and the cnuts that are Bayern will be celebrating for an afternoon. But then I look at the bigger picture and see how well they have rebounded from that awful last season and that things seem to generally be moving in the right direction. So I think you might be projecting your expectations and maybe hopes for Dortmund and complain if they can't deliver that. Overall they have actually simply done well this season, not great but well.