midnightmare
Full Member
“He can still do a job” is a phrase that keeps getting peddled about Lingard, and it makes me ask “what job?”
He’s not creative, he doesn’t offer a goal threat, he can really only play one position. Running? Is that what we consider doing a job now?
Scott McT is an example of a player who can do a job. He has limitations but brings attributes and a versatility that means he can be useful even in the biggest games. Jesse Lingard is not a player who can do a job, at least not for a club looking to actually compete at a high level.
Clearly memories are short. Jesse used to be able to “do a job” and for a while he was quite effervescent. People seem to forget the “Messe Lingard” phase and his Cup performances and goals. I still held even then that he should not be a first team starter for us but clearly he was a capable squad member. But that new contract was the turning point. It wasn’t his fault he was given it but the fan reactions were positively toxic. Across social media (which I’m sure he doesn’t avoid), it was absolutely poisonous. It’s bound to have had an impact on him. This coincided with our team being shit, Jose being Jose and of course his form dipping. But more than anyone, Lingard was absolutely crucified. Did himself no favors online but Twitter and the Internet overall are cruel.
I’ve wanted him sold for ages now. But I’ll repeat it. It’s as much for his good as the club’s. In happier circumstances, we’d have signed high quality starters for #10 and RW years ago and we’d not have forced him into this position. If we hadn’t, we’d not have this furore and while some would still have baited and trolled, a majority would likely have seen the sense in having a player like him filling out the squad. That’s no longer possible so I’m quite sure he’ll be sold.
PS: Say what anyone may, 3 managers - LvG, Jose and Ole - have rated Jesse good enough (in ability) to be a member of the squad. For all their flaws, no player could be devoid of talent and con all these for so long.Fergie too saw the talent. It’s ended badly and he must be sold but let’s not use this version of Jesse to pronounce judgement. We can easily accept his talent and also hold that firstly, that’s not enough for us and secondly, circumstances dictate that we must part ways for the good of all parties.