ICC Cricket World Cup 2011

Sachin's been on redcafe, clearly responding to my criticism :D
 
Sachin gone... Tait the joker gets a wicket...

no excuses for rest of the batting not to finish the job here. Excellent platform has been set.
 
Well played Sachin. Good knock.

Great platform to milk the bowling now,
 
What a great platform we have to beat Australia. A soft ball, lots of gaps, if we play smart cricket this game is there to be won.
 
Dravid was class. Laxman was never meant for ODI cricket. But dravid should have been played more than he was.

Not really. Dravid never scored that quickly and lost his form after a point in one day cricket and the youngsters have proven their worth.
 
Despite my shock, it would probably be the sensible thing to do.

The guy is 38 now and test cricket is so much the better format anyway.

Only problem is he's showing no signs of slowing down.
 
Not really. He was much better technically than some of the players around and scored at a decent enough run rate for me to retain his place.

You can't ignore a drop in form. He had a drastic drop in form. And there's a point where you have to move on and give young talents who are playing better in that format a go. We did.
 
Sachin gone!!

his replacement looks like the Indian version of Gibson (with a beard)
 
You can't ignore a drop in form. He had a drastic drop in form. And there's a point where you have to move on and give young talents who are playing better in that format a go. We did.

Put it this way, Sachin has endured some drastic drops in form due to whatever reason, but persistence with him has paid off. Would have been the same with Dravid, his fitness levels were never in question, he's a good fielder as well. I'd rather have Dravid than Raina in today's team. But maybe thats just me, I prefer strokeplay than explosive batting
 
Put it this way, Sachin has endured some drastic drops in form due to whatever reason, but persistence with him has paid off. Would have been the same with Dravid, his fitness levels were never in question, he's a good fielder as well. I'd rather have Dravid than Raina in today's team. But maybe thats just me, I prefer strokeplay than explosive batting

So you'd rather have Dravid coming in instead of Raina at 6 or 7? That makes sense.

Also there is no comparison between Sachin and Dravid. Sachin dominates games so even when he's out of touch (which basically barely happens) he's still trying to score quickly. Dravid when he's out of touch eats up a lot of deliveries and then gets out. As I said he had totally lost his touch and it was the right decision. It's worked out well for us so I don't see why we would regret it.
 
India need to step up the run rate.

I think it's important to keep wickets in hand though. So many gaps in the pitch and with 50 or 60 to get in the last 10 with 6 wickets in hand it should be pretty simple. So I'd reckon the aim has to be to stay there and just move along at 5 an over. There will be poor deliveries to get the odd boundary from.
 
With Dravid it's not just his scoring rate which would be a problem for the team and his fellow batsmen - his fielding would also weaken the team.
 
So you'd rather have Dravid coming in instead of Raina at 6 or 7? That makes sense.

Also there is no comparison between Sachin and Dravid. Sachin dominates games so even when he's out of touch (which basically barely happens) he's still trying to score quickly. Dravid when he's out of touch eats up a lot of deliveries and then gets out. As I said he had totally lost his touch and it was the right decision. It's worked out well for us so I don't see why we would regret it.

Where do I say what position I want to play him in ? In place, not in his position. He would obviously be slotted up the order.

You really need to wind up the clock a bit and watch Sachin. As much as I admire him, he was completely out of sorts for considerable spells after the '03 WC. He did not dominate anything, whatever the reason, chappell, injuries etc. I never said India as team regrets it, the batting being the best in the world ATM proves it, but thats just my personal choice, I dont like players like Pathan or Raina, hit/miss with their suspect techniques. I'd rather have a Dravid like player instead of them.