Red Indian Chief Torn Rubber
Thus says Kemo
Ronaldinho, Okocha, Maradona, Denilson Best and Ronaldo Da Lima are the best I ever saw
Yes there are plenty of players who do well in one league but struggle in another, but this is Messi we are talking about he is in the top most elite bracket with the likes of Silva, Iniesta, Neymar, Ronaldo etc, these guys don't struggle so why is it a given that Messi will? I'm a huge fan of Messi and I watch Barcelona matches whenever I can and he gets the same physical treatment the likes of Hazard, De Bruyne, Sanchez get in the PL. La Liga is not that soft as the English media would have you believe.That's not a given. Veron was a world beater in Italy but failed in England. Messi's standards drop when he plays for Argentina so it's not unreasonable to say that his system has helped him massively.
He has been winning it just for that actually, he right now is a glorified goal poacher(still better than the rest mind you) when compared to MessiHe didn't win 5 Ballon D' Or for just putting the ball into the net.
Messi is the best for me.
Also, not mentioned in the thread yet, the best Portuguese dribbler ever:
1. Lionel Messi
2. Diego Maradona
3. Garrincha
4. Pele
5. Ronaldo Nazario
6. Zico
7. Johan Cruyff
8. Ronaldinho
9. George Best
10. Andres Iniesta
I did, he was the next big thing out of Derry at that time. Got a really bad injury that made him retire but made a comeback and was still brilliant, though less mobile. The Derry letissier. Imho had a real shot at making it but for that injury.GB did you follow much of Liam Coyle's career? Still a freaky talent as far as I'm concerned. Irish league wasn't that bad back then, he was playing for a shite team, his knee was strapped up to feck and seemed like it would fall off after one tackle, and there was still matches that he bossed whilst barely moving from the centre circle.
Okocha: spectacular player but do you really think he was a great dribbler?![]()
Messi by a mile really. He raised the bar in terms of consistency with dribbling and during the years he won the Ballon D'or 4 times in a row he reached consistency levels with dribbling along with end product never seen before. Might be 30 years before we see his like again.
To go away from the usual I'd like to put honorable mentions for the following
Waddle
Kinkladze
Le Tissier
I don't get your point he is a spectacular player partly because he is a great dribbler, of all the players you chose to single out arguably the most skilful of them all.
Nice to read your thoughts, however wrong some might be.This is such a generic question. What kind of dribbling is it because different parts of the pitch require different types of movement.
Also, comparing dribblers from different eras directly is disingenuous. Different rules, different pitches, different ways of defending.
As for the different types of dribbling I narrow it down to 3 types. Obviously players will cross over all 3 but I'm being very general here:
Type 1: Press resistant players that are superb with dribbling when face with back to goal. They usually operate in the midfield and use feints and positioning to escape man marking and are strategic with their dribbling due to operating in a more dangerous area (for their team).
Type 2: players that once they face opposition goal they use their technique and ball control, more so than their athleticism to evade markers and are exceptional in tight spaces.
Type 3: usually explosive players that require the use of mainly their athleticism to evade a marker and usually are more effective with space in front of them
As I said players usually are a mix of all types but I am breaking it down to illustrate the players that use more of the others.
The best I have seen in each category are:
Type 1 Xavi, Modric, Iniesta, Maradona (later career), Gundogan, Osvaldo Ardiles, Johan Cruijff (later career), Didi, Rivelino.
Honorable mentions. Messi (last few seasons), Bergkamp (later career)
Laudrup was weak in this area and Zidane was effective but not as good as the players mentioned. He tried to use his body more than technique and when he couldn't escape he dived or got dispossessed similar to Busquets. Pirlo was good in this area but not excellent which is why he was relatively easy to man mark out of games compared to the top players in this category.
Players today have to be more press resistant than at any point in football history due to the improved vertical and horizontal compactness.
My top 3: Xavi, Modric and Iniesta.
Type 2: These are the types that are seen as classically great dribblers and mostly over represented in discussions.
Messi, Maradona, Johan Cruijff, Zidane, Zico, George Best, Ronaldo (inter), Ronaldinho, Pele, Ribery, Del Piero (pre injury), Bobby Charlton, Figo, Okocha, Dejan Savicevic, Denilson, Romario, Zola, George Weah, Laudrup, Jesper Olsen (Messi before Messi), Hazard, Rui Costa, Bergkamp, Gianni Rivera, Gascoigne, Omar Sivori, Platini, Roberto Baggio.
The mentioned players usually had the acceleration to go past in addition to their excellent ball control. They don't necessarily have the top speed to cover space so might be caught up but they keep the ball superbly when facing the opposition goal. Honorable mention goes to Iniesta and Modric who are more strategic with this but don't have the physical capacity to extend this over distances. van Basten was not on the level of the mentioned but he had excellent technique before his ankle injury when he played for us.
Top 3: Maradona, Sivori and Messi
TYPE 3 Cristiano Ronaldo, Gareth Bale, Preben Elkjaer, Gaarincha, Gento, Kubala, Pele (earlier career), Johan Cruijff ( earlier career), Ronaldo (PSV & Barcelona), Piet Keizer, Kaka, Michael Owen, Ryan Giggs,
Top 3: Cristiano Ronaldo, Gaarincha, Ronaldo de Lima.
Also when comparing players, most change their style of dribbling as they get older. The players that are slow are usually type 2 from the start throughout and then you have players that are type 1 mostly thay start to be type 2 as their physical faculties decline. For example, Johan Cruijff started out as mostly type 3 because he was one of the fastest forwards of his era but as got injured he became a type 2 and 3 because he dropped deeper and could no longer just rely on his speed. The transition requires the player to already have exceptional technical ability so dropping deeper means your technique and ball control have to be excellent.
These different types of dribbling are effective in different areas but if I was to pick an overall player that is complete in all 3 at any point in their career it would have to be Diego Armando Maradona
You forgot Robben, Bad Dutch person!This is such a generic question. What kind of dribbling is it because different parts of the pitch require different types of movement.
Also, comparing dribblers from different eras directly is disingenuous. Different rules, different pitches, different ways of defending.
As for the different types of dribbling I narrow it down to 3 types. Obviously players will cross over all 3 but I'm being very general here:
Type 1: Press resistant players that are superb with dribbling when face with back to goal. They usually operate in the midfield and use feints and positioning to escape man marking and are strategic with their dribbling due to operating in a more dangerous area (for their team).
Type 2: players that once they face opposition goal they use their technique and ball control, more so than their athleticism to evade markers and are exceptional in tight spaces.
Type 3: usually explosive players that require the use of mainly their athleticism to evade a marker and usually are more effective with space in front of them
As I said players usually are a mix of all types but I am breaking it down to illustrate the players that use more of the others.
The best I have seen in each category are:
Type 1 Xavi, Modric, Iniesta, Maradona (later career), Gundogan, Osvaldo Ardiles, Johan Cruijff (later career), Didi, Rivelino.
Honorable mentions. Messi (last few seasons), Bergkamp (later career)
Laudrup was weak in this area and Zidane was effective but not as good as the players mentioned. He tried to use his body more than technique and when he couldn't escape he dived or got dispossessed similar to Busquets. Pirlo was good in this area but not excellent which is why he was relatively easy to man mark out of games compared to the top players in this category.
Players today have to be more press resistant than at any point in football history due to the improved vertical and horizontal compactness.
My top 3: Xavi, Modric and Iniesta.
Type 2: These are the types that are seen as classically great dribblers and mostly over represented in discussions.
Messi, Maradona, Johan Cruijff, Zidane, Zico, George Best, Ronaldo (inter), Ronaldinho, Pele, Ribery, Del Piero (pre injury), Bobby Charlton, Figo, Okocha, Dejan Savicevic, Denilson, Romario, Zola, George Weah, Laudrup, Jesper Olsen (Messi before Messi), Hazard, Rui Costa, Bergkamp, Gianni Rivera, Gascoigne, Omar Sivori, Platini, Roberto Baggio.
The mentioned players usually had the acceleration to go past in addition to their excellent ball control. They don't necessarily have the top speed to cover space so might be caught up but they keep the ball superbly when facing the opposition goal. Honorable mention goes to Iniesta and Modric who are more strategic with this but don't have the physical capacity to extend this over distances. van Basten was not on the level of the mentioned but he had excellent technique before his ankle injury when he played for us.
Top 3: Maradona, Sivori and Messi
TYPE 3 Cristiano Ronaldo, Gareth Bale, Preben Elkjaer, Gaarincha, Gento, Kubala, Pele (earlier career), Johan Cruijff ( earlier career), Ronaldo (PSV & Barcelona), Piet Keizer, Kaka, Michael Owen, Ryan Giggs,
Top 3: Cristiano Ronaldo, Gaarincha, Ronaldo de Lima.
Also when comparing players, most change their style of dribbling as they get older. The players that are slow are usually type 2 from the start throughout and then you have players that are type 1 mostly thay start to be type 2 as their physical faculties decline. For example, Johan Cruijff started out as mostly type 3 because he was one of the fastest forwards of his era but as got injured he became a type 2 and 3 because he dropped deeper and could no longer just rely on his speed. The transition requires the player to already have exceptional technical ability so dropping deeper means your technique and ball control have to be excellent.
These different types of dribbling are effective in different areas but if I was to pick an overall player that is complete in all 3 at any point in their career it would have to be Diego Armando Maradona