Rossa
Full Member
If Nani goes I think we could do with a bit more proven quality than two young wingers with very little top flight experience between them.
Indeed, and I truly hope Nani will stay. If Moyes prefers to use wingers who tuck in and for the fullbacks to provide width, then Nani is certainly a better option than Valencia. Young is an OK option on the left who likes to tuck in and has a fairly decent delivery and shot, but he isn't world class, imo.
McManaman is very exciting though, so signing him could be worthwhile.
If we sell Nani, I do think we probably need a new winger who can operate both sides. However, selling Nani for 20m won't give us the same quality in return.