Greenwood was a much better player. Garnacho will go on to be a great player though.
Garnacho: What is his potential?
- Thread starter Samid
- Start date
- Status
Greenwood was a much better player. Garnacho will go on to be a great player though.
He needs to work on his defensive and off the ball game, and he will be a star. And he has Antony to learn from on those.
he worked much more defensively yesterday than in previous games, good signs.
Obviously he'll be inconsistent and frustrating at times, and we can't be sure how he'll develop. But watching kids like this is what makes football so exciting, we've been really fortunate at United over the years to see several young players break through with this combination of complete fearlessness and skills to match, and I think we're in for some very good times in the next few years watching Garnacho grow into a star.
I can't praise this player enough.
He's better than Greenwood imo.
He's got everything you can ask of a leftwinger.
His ball control and first touch is outstanding.
Great turn of pace and can leave his marker for dead (unlike the show pony on the other side).
Can use both feet (also unlike him on the other side)
Lets just say an exceptionally talented young footballer.
I reckon he can reach Giggs level definately.
He's better than Greenwood imo.
He's got everything you can ask of a leftwinger.
His ball control and first touch is outstanding.
Great turn of pace and can leave his marker for dead (unlike the show pony on the other side).
Can use both feet (also unlike him on the other side)
Lets just say an exceptionally talented young footballer.
I reckon he can reach Giggs level definately.
Last edited:
Yeah, all very good points - albeit i think Mata/Eriksen at their best was nothing to be scoffed at and debatably as close to world class as you could get, if not world class themselves. I think, as mentioned, Januzaj might have had a better career developing into a 10 or so, as he lacked the explosiveness but had an excellent eye for a pass.
Anyway, admittedly i really liked Januzaj and hoped he made it here
At the same age, 18 and 8 months I believe, Garnacho > Ronaldo.
It’s really hard to see Garnacho, or anyone else really, reaching the height Ronaldo reached at his peak or even at the age of 21, but this Garnacho today is just better than the Ronaldo at this age.
It’s really hard to see Garnacho, or anyone else really, reaching the height Ronaldo reached at his peak or even at the age of 21, but this Garnacho today is just better than the Ronaldo at this age.
Garnacho has better finishing than Ronaldo at 18, but thats about it. Ronaldo (and Rooney for that matter) were a different class to Garnacho - as good as he is.
Everything is just wrong with this. Supporting and using media terms to discredit our player Anthony isn't right at all. It is not an either/ or , ffs, why bring Antony into it. The guy who help us defeat Barcelona.
Argentina not taking him to the World Cup and locking him down will be a funny decision if he turns around and plays for Spain
Ronaldo was more exciting to watch -- the multiple stepovers were a revelation -- but his end product at 18 years and 8 months was nowhere near the end product of Garnacho.
I'm trying to be careful to refer to the age -- 18y/8m -- as there's no doubt that at 20 and then 21 Ronaldo was astonishing and there's no way we can expect Garnacho to reach that level, but as Garnacho stands right now at the place where Ronaldo stood at the same, and I'm sure most of us here remember CR then at that age like it was yesterday, Garnacho is simply the better footballer.
As for Rooney at that same age, Rooney > Garnacho without question.
Is that still a possibility?
100% will be better than Bebe. Pin this, and applaud me later on
I dunno, that’s some expectation level
Doesn’t even rhyme.
https://www.90min.com/posts/alejandro-garnacho-snubbed-by-argentina-could-still-play-for-spain/amp
Daily mirror reported something similar, so yes
After what Argentina did to him in 2022, Alejandro should definitely be thinking about playing for Spain instead.
I will wait a season more before I make any judgement. He definitely has potential but whether he reach for instance Giggs level, has probably more to do with him having the right mindset than his technical skills
Garnacho is a much better player than Greenwood at the same age.
Greenwood was an unbelievable finisher but goals aside, he had very little influence on the game over 90mins. At times you'd even forget he was on the pitch.
I'd bet full backs would much rather play against Greenwood as Garnacho must be a nightmare.
Greenwood was a striker, just because he played a lot of games out wide doesn't make him a winger, you're not comparing like for like, we'll probably never know who would have turned out the best
Greenwood had far more quality and composure to his game. As a striker under the right manager, he would of become one of the best players in the world. I think Garnacho will become a great player but he looks much more raw than Mason ever did.
And not taking him has proved to be the right decision, they won the WC so they had the right players there
Greenwood all day everyday.
Ok, I think some of you have clearly forgot what a player Greenwood actually was for us. Garnacho is fantastic and I enjoy every moment of him... But Greenwood was a generational talent and way above just striking ability.
Let's put it this way, If Greenwood was playing for us we would be seriously looking at winning all 4 competitions - we'd be top of the PL IMO
The way you guys seemingly live life in such a binary scale is type of scary.
The guy that reportedly competed with Garnacho for a spot was Correa, who had like a 4 minute nothing appearance against Croatia. Those 4 minutes could have gone to locking Garnacho in as an Argentinian international and I very much doubt the outcome of the tournament hindered on Correa being there. I don't need to hear some butterfly effect type of argumentation either, but alas
Last edited:
Garnacho is better than Greenwood ever was and I was fecking stoked about Greenwood. That's saying a lot though
He may be better than Greenwood but to say at this stage that Garnacho is better I think is a bit premature.
Greenwood as striker/RW and Garnacho as LW would be very tasty. Shame that it is unlikely to happen.
Licha would have a word with him.
Well let's wait for the manager's decision.
Think recency bias is coming into play a bit here. Greenwood wasnt just applauded for his finishing. His all round game was great too. Had great vision and could play a decent pass. We relied on him a lot to create something. He was a full blown first teamer at the same age Garnacho is now.
That's doesn't mean garnacho wouldn't have ended up the better player longer term though (if the Greenwood shit hadn't gone down). Hard to tell when players are that young how good they will be. Everyone devolps at different rates.
So many come through that look like they are guaranteed to become world beaters but then just disappear due to various reasons. Attitude, injury, or just bring a cnut the main ones.
Hopefully garnacho keeps on this tragectory but keeps himself grounded in terms of attitude and how he is outside of football. Luckily we have Ten Hag around who seems to be doing a good job of that.
I'd say Garnacho is quite significantly below Rooney at the same age and also below Ronaldo and "He who shall not be named" at the same age.
The thing about Ronaldo in particular is that his development went crazy in his early 20s. We knew he was a special talent but it was impossible to know he would become as good as he became.
A lot of this was down to a crazy work ethic. Right now I don't have insider knowledge on how driven Garnacho is but if he is half as driven as Ronaldo he can become a top tier player. It really is down to how hard he works and how much he wants to be the best.
The thing about Ronaldo in particular is that his development went crazy in his early 20s. We knew he was a special talent but it was impossible to know he would become as good as he became.
A lot of this was down to a crazy work ethic. Right now I don't have insider knowledge on how driven Garnacho is but if he is half as driven as Ronaldo he can become a top tier player. It really is down to how hard he works and how much he wants to be the best.
I really want him to play for Spain, he's got the directness already, all he needs is to develop his off the ball game and his involvement during buildup.
You need help lad. That final sentence is Fcuking disgusting.
To get back on track. This Garnacho lad looks to have a great future and that will be down to how much he wants it.
Great potential. Ronaldo vibes. Not many players have his ability to take on defenders like that.
Looks like a bit like a one trick pony, to become world class he needs to develop in other aspects of his game: crossing, passing, assisting.
Looks like a bit like a one trick pony, to become world class he needs to develop in other aspects of his game: crossing, passing, assisting.
Also helps that he now is in an environment that will help his development. Having Ten Hag as the manager and United back on the right track. Imagine if he came through when Mourinho was in charge.
Curious how he will develop. Given that he has no injury that might mess it all up.
Agree with this. A youngster needs a positive environment, with the right characters in it.
Garnacho not having the right mentality is something completely different to Greenwood though, isn't it? Look, I'm not sure what the point you're trying to make here is. Domestic violence is a thing that messes completely with victims, we shouldn't talk about it because it's disrespectful to those that have actually suffered. It often goes unpunished and is hard to prove.
Unless the pictures and audio leaked online are completely fabricated, Greenwood shouldn't play for the club again. Clearly United agree, or else he wouldn't have been suspended from the onset of the investigation.
I'd rather spend my time being excited about Garnacho and discussing it here, instead of speculating whether Greenwood beat his girlfriend and whatever else or not, and if he's learnt his lesson or not.
I think that's very harsh. He has shown signs of having that in his locker though. The assist for McTominay on the EFL vs Villa, the winner vs City.
He goes on the outside to the byline as much as he cuts in, as opposed to a one-trick pony like Grealish who's always looking to come inside. Has scored a couple of winners with his left too.
To be honest, I think he's shown enough that as an 18 year old he has a lot of strings to his bow.
- Status