[/I]Have you ever seen the quality of football the likes of Fermanagh, Monaghan, Cavan, Down etc. typically play....absolutely beautiful to watch...as you might say "the way it should be played ! Alas, how much silverware have any of those teams collected in Ulster alone recently. Fermanagh are still left in the All-Ireland, and if you get a chance to watch 'em, then do !...football in it's purist form !
Footballers are getting faster & fitter, even professional like. To put it simply, if they are fitter, why not get forwards to defend as well as attack & defenders to attack as well as defend....... and that is exactly what Tyrone & Armagh have been doing in the past few years.
Yes, we all love the "catch & kick" etc., but because of the evolving process of fitness levels this will never return unless some drastic rule changes are introduced.
You have mentioned Kerry, Galway & to a lesser extent Cork !........ They have all adapted the blanket defence style in the last year or so !....... Obviously this has escaped your attention.... they are still adopting to it !