Borys
Statistics Wizard
Fred does the CM role effectively, similar way to Tielemans let's say. He's not that good technically, but has better work ethic and energy levels, so it kind of evens out.I am trying to figure out what is your definition of decent? And you describe his as decent is every aspect if he is played in midfield and with a partner who can cover for him? Cover what? His inconsistent passing and ball control? His diabolic defensive play? Or attacking input? I agree about one thing, yes he is decent in chasing after people and winning the occasional ball, but is that enough in order for him to play that role? I don't think so, not with his inconsistent touch, passing and awful tendency to shoot at every semi occasion to a shocking standard.
With the 5 sub role, it even makes it easier, I'd play Eriksen, DVB actually even McT since I think he can be more useful like he demonstrated last night. Ultimately we need another CM.
By "cover" I mean he can't play the deepest midfielder role, he has to have some support. It's quite easy actually. He does play that role for Brazil effectively so it's even easier to see what he brings there, hopefully we will see that soon with Casemiro joining. I also think he is useful in keeping the ball in opposition half, recycling possession and progressing the ball forward. I do think those are his strengths rather than making him play deep.
Fred is not even close to being great midfielder, but he's also a victim of being forced to do two man job more often than not. Fair enough if you think he's thrash, just keep that in mind. Many midfielders better than Fred would look out of depth in United team.
Pogba had no defensive awareness and no discipline to track back. Eriksen seems to have those, he's just not athletic enough (or maybe not fit yet?), so those are different issues to last season. I think Eriksen will be easier to accommodate in midfield than Pogba, I just don't see a point to it since that's not where he's most effective. Why can't we just play two defensive minded players in midfield and have the front 4 plus fullbacks do the damage? Everybody else does that, it's just we at United seem to have obsession playing AMs in midfield.Yeah I thought we could get away with playing Eriksen at DLP for a season but he looked very leggy yesterday. Ceded control quite a few times because he couldn't do your basic CM sprint to cover wide and then get back in position as soon as the ball rotates.
I wonder if it's possible to cover for him by bringing Bruno a little deeper but as it is right now, we have a Pogba, Fred, Bruno midfield again