Gaming FM 17 Club Draft | Final update is out

What should we do transferwise?

  • Allow a fixed maximum number of transfers each summer

  • Let in-game managers make transfer each summer

  • Stick with original squad


Results are only viewable after voting.
Lewa picked 3 times :lol:
 
Hopefully start making it through the third round soon. The mass pm rounds should be quick aswell. Think this will be done quicker than originally thought
 
Sorry mate picked for you I'll change it if you want
No fine mate, after he failed with Lewa thought he might have gone for muller, all good.
 
Change of rules: managers will be drafted after the fifth round. You can state your preferred and second preferred formation and I'll change it on your manager if you want. I'll update the op with this.
 
1. Spontaneous1- Lionel Messi
2. @Skizzo - Neymar
3. anant - Dybala, Weigl
4. harms - O. Dembele, Jerome Boateng
5. 2mufc0 - Bale, Muller
6. hbgreg - Martial, Thomas Lemar
7. Adjudicator - Griezmann, Kante
8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke
9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos
10. iammemphis - Alexis Sanchez, Courtois
11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, Kingsley coman
12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil
13. Damien - Kylian Mbappé, Christian Pulisic
14. Samid - Renato Sanches, Marco Asensio
15. JTW95 - Harry Kane, Varane
16. oneniltothearsenal- Verratti, Gabriel Jesus
17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi
18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski
19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne
20. Mazhar13 - Saul Niguez, Leroy Sané
 
Change of rules: managers will be drafted after the fifth round. You can state your preferred and second preferred formation and I'll change it on your manager if you want. I'll update the op with this.
Awesome. Can you make a list of various formations please.
 
1 possible suggestion for when we do the whole 5 players at once thing. Rather than pick 5 players, maybe we should pick as a positional priority.
Lets say I hadn't drafted a keeper yet. If I made this list:

1. Donnaruma
2. Messi
3. Neymar
4. Hazard
5. Ronaldo

If somebody also had Donnaruma top of their list and I miss out, I've completely missed out on that position. I could in theory have had Courtois second on my list just in case, but at the same point, I wouldn't want to draft 2 keepers

Instead, I could have had
1a. Donnaruma - 1b. Courtois

------

This is just a suggestion. Even I am not sure if its better or not yet.
Pros - You are more likely to fill the position you want
Cons - Maybe you lose some of the strategy by doing this

Hmmm
 
Awesome. Can you make a list of various formations please.

4-1-2-3 DM Wide = Classic 433 with 1 defensive midfielder
4-2-1-3 DM Wide = 433 with 2 defensive midfielders and 1 central midfielder
4-2-3-1 DM Wide = Classic 4231 but with the midfielders in a defensive role
4-2-3-1 Narrow = The 3 advanced midfielders all play centrally
4-2-3-1 Wide = The more usual 4231 playing with central midfielders and wingers
4-4-2 = Classic 90s football :lol:
4-4-2 Diamond = 1 Defensive midfielder, 2 central midfielders, 1 number 10 and 2 strikers
4-4-1-1 = Similar to 442 but one of the strikers plays as a number 10
3-5-2 = 3 At the back, 5 across midfield and 2 strikers
5-3-2 WB = 3 defenders, 2 wing backs, 3 in midfield and 2 strikers

--------

I can see the top 5 being the most popular. If anybody has an idea of a formation, I can check up on it
 
Last edited:
Right I'm off for the night. Some formations are left above.

Also just so everybody knows. Lewandowski has been chosen already
 
Awesome. Can you make a list of various formations please.
DM = defensive midfielder
WB = wingback

3-1-3-1-2 DM
3-1-4-2 DM
3-2-3-2 DM
3-4-2-1 DM
3-4-3 DM Wide
4-1-2-3 DM Wide
4-1-2-3 DM Narrow
4-1-3-1-1 DM Narrow
4-1-3-2 DM
4-1-3-2 DM Narrow
4-1-4-1 DM
4-1-4-1 DM Asymmetrical (RW)
4-1-4-1 DM Asymmetrical (LW)
4-2-1-3 DM Wide
4-2-2-2 DM
4-2-2-2 DM Narrow
4-2-3-1
4-2-3-1 Wide
4-2-3-1 Narrow
4-2-3-1 DM
4-2-3-1 DM Wide
4-2-3-1 DM Narrow
4-2-3-1-0 DM
4-2-4 DM Wide
4-2-4-0 DM Wide
4-3-1-2 Narrow
4-3-2-1 DM Narrow
4-3-2-1 Narrow
4-3-3 Narrow
4-4-1-1
4-4-1-1 2DM
4-4-2
4-4-2 Diamond Narrow
4-4-2 Sweeper
4-5-1
5-1-2-2 DM Narrow
5-1-2-2 DM WB
5-1-2-2 Sweeper DM WB
5-1-3-1 DM WB
5-2-1-2 Sweeper WB
5-2-1-2 WB
5-2-2-1 DM
5-2-2-1 WB
5-2-2-1-0 DM
5-2-3 Narrow
5-3-2 Sweeper WB
5-3-2 WB
5-4-1
5-4-1 Diamond WB

I've included it in the OP as well.
 
First one is a no-go with it being a wingerless formation and my first two signings being wingers. Second one seems kinda interesting but eh... will see.
You should draft LvG, he'll turn them into wing backs.

No but seriously, there are so many stupid formations. Those two were some of them, especially the latter one. Who would ever play with five at the back and no strikers
 
1 possible suggestion for when we do the whole 5 players at once thing. Rather than pick 5 players, maybe we should pick as a positional priority.
Lets say I hadn't drafted a keeper yet. If I made this list:

1. Donnaruma
2. Messi
3. Neymar
4. Hazard
5. Ronaldo

If somebody also had Donnaruma top of their list and I miss out, I've completely missed out on that position. I could in theory have had Courtois second on my list just in case, but at the same point, I wouldn't want to draft 2 keepers

Instead, I could have had
1a. Donnaruma - 1b. Courtois

------

This is just a suggestion. Even I am not sure if its better or not yet.
Pros - You are more likely to fill the position you want
Cons - Maybe you lose some of the strategy by doing this

Hmmm
If you end up not getting all your players, I'll PM you telling you that you didn't get player X and that you need to find a replacement. You'll then give me another player that will replace player X on your list. In the scenario you mentioned where you missed out on Donnarumma, you'd most likely get Courtois since he'd take up the #1 spot on your list.
 
If you end up not getting all your players, I'll PM you telling you that you didn't get player X and that you need to find a replacement. You'll then give me another player that will replace player X on your list. In the scenario you mentioned where you missed out on Donnarumma, you'd most likely get Courtois since he'd take up the #1 spot on your list.

Yeah this method is better as you'll only have 4 players you still have a spot for the keeper.
 
Well, at least Skizzo appears to be off to bed as well, so I might get my turn next morning.
 
1. @Spontaneous1 - Lionel Messi
2. Skizzo - Neymar, Dele Alli
3. anant - Dybala, Weigl
4. harms - O. Dembele, Jerome Boateng
5. 2mufc0 - Bale, Muller
6. hbgreg - Martial, Thomas Lemar
7. Adjudicator - Griezmann, Kante
8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke
9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos
10. iammemphis - Alexis Sanchez, Courtois
11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, Kingsley coman
12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil
13. Damien - Kylian Mbappé, Christian Pulisic
14. Samid - Renato Sanches, Marco Asensio
15. JTW95 - Harry Kane, Varane
16. oneniltothearsenal- Verratti, Gabriel Jesus
17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi
18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski
19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne
20. Mazhar13 - Saul Niguez, Leroy Sane
 
1. Spontaneous1 - Lionel Messi, James
Rodriguez
2. Skizzo - Neymar, Dele Alli
3. anant - Dybala, Weigl
4. harms - O. Dembele, Jerome Boateng
5. 2mufc0 - Bale, Muller
6. hbgreg - Martial, Thomas Lemar
7. Adjudicator - Griezmann, Kante
8. limerickcitykid - Ronaldo, Koke
9. P-Nut0712 - Pogba, Kroos
10. iammemphis - Alexis Sanchez, Courtois
11. Party Boy - Donnarumma, Kingsley coman
12. Igor Drefljak - Hazard, Ozil
13. Damien - Kylian Mbappé, Christian Pulisic
14. Samid - Renato Sanches, Marco Asensio
15. JTW95 - Harry Kane, Varane
16. oneniltothearsenal- Verratti, Gabriel Jesus
17. Red-Man-Walking - Suarez, Icardi
18. Tuppet - Alaba, Lewandowski
19. MJJ - Aguero, De Bruyne
20. @mazhar13 - Saul Niguez, Leroy Sane
 
Did Mazhar leave his pick with anyone?
 
Hopefully MJJ

I makes sense to leave your pick with the person after you I guess. That way they can at least move the draft on two spots