Just finished the campaign today. Been playing it pretty relentlessly over past few weekends to try to finish it. I’ve clocked 76 hours, finished the campaign and the vast majority of side quests including the prototeic quest line. Got no real ambition of finishing the combat challenges or mini games.
Overall, I really loved this game. It has a few issues to it but its strengths far out weigh the negatives. Its combat is excellent and much better than 16s, the graphics are top notch, the story is by far and large superb and ‘no promises to keep’ will live long in my memory.
My only gripes were:
A) the amount of mini games was ridiculous. I quite liked the chocobo racing, queens blood was great and playing the piano was actually a really fun addition to the game. However, there were loads which were just a pain. I hated Gambits and Gears, the frog game was annoying, Fort Condor was irritating and the workout game has given me PTSD after getting the top rank.
2) just a few fights which had too steep of a curve. I’m mainly looking at the big fight in chapter 12. On top of that the boss sequence in the final chapter was too long. I know they like to do a boss gambit at the ends of games but it was too much for someone like me especially when you leave the hardest one to last.
Overall, it was a pretty emotionally draining experience and the ending was very bittersweet. I would give the game a 9/10 or 9.5/10. Story is starting to get a little confusing, I kind of get it but hope that part 3 tidies it up a bit.