I think he’s absolutely right, in a broader sense. It’s the continuous nostalgia, harking back to the past, seeking answers from a time which is long gone instead of adapting to, seeking and fashioning new solutions for the present.
The reason why it resonates is I’ve seen an exact facsimile of this situation play out at my own club as a matchgoing fan at Anfield since the mid 80s to our detriment, the famous ‘boom-bust‘ decades you used to laugh about where we continuously harked back to the past instead of adapting to and progressing with the times.
I was too young for shankly and paisley but I starting being taken to games as a child during the fagan years in the mid 80s and have since seen at first hand dalglish, souness, evans, houllier, Benitez, hodgson, rodgers and dalglish again come and go before we arrived at klopp.
Throughout this period it was one continuous history lesson about the glorious past whilst the club stagnated, watched others overtake us on and off the pitch, became a laughing stock and a salutary lesson on how great dynasties decline, etc etc.
Then klopp arrived, and the first thing he did was take down the ‘this is Anfield‘ sign, signalled definitively that the past was glorious but no longer relevant, that we had to change everything and start building as he put it ‘our own history’ instead of harking back to the past. I think it’s fair to say he achieved his targets and has made us relevant again on an ongoing basis.
I see all of this reflected at United. For Ferguson substitute shankly and paisley, for ‘the United way’ sub in the boot room, for solskjaer I give you souness and evans and the second coming of dalglish. The class of 92 pundits continuously discussing what fergie would’ve done is reflected in Hansen and lawrenson and others continuously harking back to their own times from a decade or more earlier. Bringing back Ronaldo, all of it is just futile nostalgia. In the meantime the club stagnates and with that, slowly but surely, will come a loss of relevance. Until the direction of travel changes.