Sell him ASAP, yesterday would be nice, even if it is for £15m
Fellaini | Mou: "It's easier for Galatasaray to get me than Marouane. He is too important to me."
- Thread starter GM K
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik (@Rood) and Imran (@Annihilate Now!) are here to discuss Amad saving our blushes in a win against Southampton as well as our now annual loss at home to Brighton. They discuss Amorim's post-match comments, revisit how mid-table we may or may not be, and discuss some transfer news.
- Status
No point selling him when we need more midfielders, not less.
If we get James, then Mata will be the one leaving. The new DM won't affect this because Fellaini won't be a starter. You can tell by the way Jose used him last season that he's not leaving. And Pereira will certainly be below Fellaini as backup. Unless we get a very good offer, we should keep him.
I know that's the trouble
Mata shouldn't be leaving. Aside from being a backup for the right side as well as number 10, he's a great super sub. We already don't have enough effectiveness off the bench so would be disappointing to lose him for me.
Fecking hell, I want this so much - both him gone and to see Messi-Iniesta-Neymar-Busquets playing alongside him
You just put a dampener on my morning, K.
Proved he's more than worth keeping last season.
Fecking hell, I want this so much - both him gone and to see Messi-Iniesta-Neymar-Busquets playing alongside him
As much as I detest Barsa, I would buy a Fellaini shirt to remember such a glorious operation forever.
Alas it was a fake account.
Sorry bhai!
x
This. I think if some people had their way we’d actually only have 11 players left.
I like Mata, but can't see us keeping Mata, Mikhi and Lingard if James signs. While Mourinho has used him a lot last season, I don't think he trusts him because he's defensively good (not the player's fault). So if one of Fellaini or Mata has to go, I think Jose would prefer we keep Fellaini, as he seems to genuinely trust him.
Anyway that was my last post of the day, so we'll continue this tomorrow XD
If we get James we are in the situation where we have sold Memphis, Rooney and released Ibra and replaced them with Perisic James and Lukaku. If anything there's an argument we need more depth.
Those defending him are still laughing at the notion that Barcelona could have any remote interest in him. Highlights the difference in teams. Surely the sort of players that interest them would be similar to us, and at the very least we shouldn't be laughing at them wanting one of our 'key players'?
Personally, I'm happy enough for him to stay by the way. Still not what I'd consider a 'Manchester United midfielder' but he's proven himself useful a number of times. In addition, the manager's primary plan seems to be to beat everyone up as opposed to outplay the so he will definitely be handy.
Personally, I'm happy enough for him to stay by the way. Still not what I'd consider a 'Manchester United midfielder' but he's proven himself useful a number of times. In addition, the manager's primary plan seems to be to beat everyone up as opposed to outplay the so he will definitely be handy.
As of now we have pogba Herrera him and carrick in CM. carrick isn't getting younger so we need another holding player. Pereira could be another option but it's highly unlikely we will keep him as a serious option. Neither of James and perisic are midfielders.
TFM would probably be loaned
Memphis hardly played last season. Even Rooney was reduced to a squad player. The only starter who left is Zlatan, and we have already replaced him. So in addition to this, if we sign James and Perisic, we'll have more depth, especially considering Periera can also cover those positions. All of Lukaku, James and Perisic will be starters next season. If Mikhi plays on the other side, that'll leave us with Rashford, Martial, Fellaini, Periera and also Young. Plenty of good and different options if you ask me. All this is assuming it's a 4231, if we play 433, we'll have all these players (except Fellaini) competing for 3 places.
Yes and we looked short on quality because of all this.
I like Lingard and Rashford a lot, but if we're in a situation next season when they're getting regular games as starters (and Ashley Young is getting minutes full stop) then we aren't going to win the league.
True.
Pereira is more of an attacking midfielder though.
Meanwhile, am I the only one who would take James over Mata?
In that scenario, even 4th place isn't guaranteed. It's just the same argument everybody has been having for a while - whilst the likes of Fellaini, Lingard and Rashford (at this stage in his career) are good squad players, if we want to be challengers for the league, they need to be the worst players in the squad, rather than first choice, especially in the 'big' games.
It's not even controversial (I think) - we need a big injection of attacking quality if we are to compete. Earlyish days but from now, new signings are missing out on vital preseason groundwork - it needs addressing quickly.
Chesti Chesta 
We need his aggressive play. I want him as a sub when things need to get going. He's the only one with some tendencies of wanting to fight.
He needs to stay.
Chesti Chesta
Lolz.
Exactly, and some fans like to pose as the toughest thing known to man by constantly agreeing with Keane on everything yet cant get behind him. A player thats truly physical. Yes not nearly as talented as Keane, or the midfielders united is used to, but hes a very valuable squad player.
Much more valuable then a Lingard, a Young, etc. I'd take Oxlade over those two in a heartbeat as a squad player (just a player whos versatile, english, pacey, a workhorse etc.)
Can't think of many players that are as good as Fellaini in the unique attributes he brings to a football match, especially in his position (players that can help teams dominate aerially completely).
Personally think this will be Mata's last season at United, especially if we keep the same manager (hopefully we do).
Imo Fellaini is the obvious heir to Xavi
Worlds tallest corner flag.
I am growing fond of Fellaini... Like him to stay as he has his uses ..
I'd swap him for a bag of Revels.
Absolutely not, i think most on here would view James as a Mata 2.0, but the problem is dealing with perez and getting James for a reasonable price. I would think there would be a lot who would take him, but just not for 70-80m.
Unless if we buy 2 midfielders cant see him leaving
A full bag? Think you'll struggle to find someone to take you up on that offer.
Good to hear that. I had the impression that most people here don't rate James at all.
Id be disapointed if he left. He does his bit.
Absolutely , it will be a bad decision to sell him , similar to selling Javier - a good squad player
Yeah, hes a good player but number 10's arent hard to come by or expensive to sign. And when its a player who cant get a game at his club and they clearly want to sell the prices theyre quoting are a pisstake.
I would much rather keep him. Great player to have in the squad, as Jose says, there are just a load of poets about.
We need to keep him, sod all the football purists.
I don't want him to leave, he was actullay impressive at times last season and he fits a certain game type.
- Status