Evan Ferguson - Top Irish Prospect
- Thread starter Pogue Mahone
- Start date
-
In the latest episode of the United Hour Podcast, Nik and Imran discuss a horrific month of December and a depressing FOUR defeats in a row - the latest coming against Wolves and Newcastle.
They discuss how much blame is on Ruben Amorim and rank our squad against other Premier League teams.
Do we have any chance of avoiding defeat at Anfield?
You should do some research on Irish players that have played and managed the club.
Top player, don't care what anyone says
Don't know much about him but in my FM23 run with Brighton he becomes world class. That's enough for me.
I've come to terms with those parts of our history but they are not to be repeated.
You seem like a genuine person who will last a long time on here
You wouldn't be biased by any chance?
Shorter than you imagined.
We're extremely lacking in centre forward options, we cannot expend a huge portion of our budget on a guy who has got 6 league goals so far in his career, as promising as he may be. It just doesn't work for us this summer.
Rumours of my demise at the hands of The Green Menace are greatly exaggerated.
Out of interest, why do you think Brighton would want to do this?
I know there's a dearth of strikers in Europe at the moment, but but Ferguson is not a 'sure' talent like Rooney at the age of 18. Ferguson may or may not be an elite talent.
Secondly, he is not ready to lead the line for a club like United, even Rooney came to a settled United with RvN carrying the responsibility.
Brighton are a more settled side than us,they have Welbeck and Undav to share the burden with,for his own sake,it's better he stays at Brighton.
Secondly, he is not ready to lead the line for a club like United, even Rooney came to a settled United with RvN carrying the responsibility.
Brighton are a more settled side than us,they have Welbeck and Undav to share the burden with,for his own sake,it's better he stays at Brighton.
I don't think it's a good idea and I certainly don't think it's a serious possibility.... but given how many years you have spent dreaming of having a striker capable of putting the ball in the back of the net I think it'd be odd if you turned your nose up at getting another season of this one who's looking pretty good at it.
I think we'd be far better off keeping him for two more seasons, developing him and then selling him for 3 times what we'd get now.
I was imagining this would involve a fee that if multiplied 3 times would break the world transfer record, I don't know if that's the level you think it's probable he will reach in two years?
Why would we need to worry about getting another season, when he has literally just signed a new long term contract and we have no need to sell? Surely we’d just not sell him? It doesn’t make any sense to me.
Teams sometimes decide a bid is high enough to be worth selling the player.
Maybe an exaggeration, but we will likely get more for him in 2-3 seasons than we would this summer with only one more season if he was loaned back to us, there is just no motivation for us to do that.
The motivation would be if someone offered you more money than it would be sensible to turn down.
If, hypothetically, that was the case - then why would a club spend an enormous fee on signing a player only to loan them to a rival? If a club did indeed make an offer the club felt bound to accept, then the player would unquestionably involved in the buying club’s first team squad.
If Manchester United spent, let’s say, £70m of their limited funds on a striker, you can be sure he will be at least on the bench come the first game of the season. Not even the richest clubs like Real Madrid, Manchester City or PSG would spend such an astronomical sum and then let a rival club use their expensive new asset free of charge.
It makes absolutely zero sense.
I don't disagree with any of this. I'm not sure the narrowness of my argument is being appreciated.
Big mouth sitting behind your keyboard.
I'll take the lot of you.
Ooh. Look at you. Too cool to sing a song. How do you feel about signing Irish players?
He’s talking about singing
Jeeze guys don’t take him so literal
Maybe you guys will do our cooking and cleaning too
@DOTA stop poking
I will. Did I get reported?
He's made the smart choice to stay at Brighton and continue his development with European experience as well next season.
He doesn't start consistently for Brighton, I understand how people expect him to do it for us. It's not like he's setting the PL on fire either.
No I just happened to be reading this threadI will. Did I get reported?
Daddy want want want
The is exactly what Man Utd wouldn't do.
I think the issue is people are taking him illiteratly.
They are a selling club, plus they still get to keep him for another year
He's not ready for a move to United yet, we need to see a few more seasons of him in the PL.
He's not a Rooney, who was a precocious talent, but at the same time he's ahead of where Kane was at the same age. But the test for Ferguson will come next season when defences work him out.
But right now we need an experienced, proven goalscorer. And right now, that's Kane, not Ferguson.
He's not a Rooney, who was a precocious talent, but at the same time he's ahead of where Kane was at the same age. But the test for Ferguson will come next season when defences work him out.
But right now we need an experienced, proven goalscorer. And right now, that's Kane, not Ferguson.
Like Hojlund he's obviously talented but he isn't ready for the step up to United yet and we're not in a position to be able to gamble on a new forward. We need a guaranteed world class goalscorer.
and it’s giving genuine irish hating fans like me a bad rep.