The point in the Fareed video is that Musk himself has relied extensively on government handouts to build his companies in the first place, which is a dagger to the heart of the mythology that he’s some sort of capitalist savant who builds things by himself through the sheer audaciousness of his ideas, who should be revered and never castigated. It also casts his recent attacks on Sanders and Warren as that of a childish, hypocrite with a severe savior of humanity disorder, who can’t deal with people questioning him in any way.
No, of course he is not beyond reproach, nor should he be revered. But I think the attacks from Sanders and Warren are beyond childish and counterproductive.
He explains in the video: 'I helped built these two companies, I didn't sell stock in the companies - my impression was you shouldn't take money off the table and de-risk things, that the captain should go down with the ship. I don't want to take money off the table and if the companies fail I will be enriched while the investors suffer, that didn't seem right, that's the reason I didn't sell. I could have easily diversified and protected myself financially if TSLA and SpaceX went bankrupt, but I did not. SpaceX and TSLA came very close to bankruptcy many times. Even when bankruptcy was literally weeks away I did not sell stock.
And then TSLA and SpaceX became valuable - the value is not up to me it's up to investors. And they decided TSLA is worth a Trillion dollars in public markets. And I own 20% of the company.
This is not a function of hoarding, simply I own 20% of the company that became very valuable as decided by external investors. And 20% of a trillion dollar valuation is $200B dollars. And I've said that the stock price too high but investors ignored that. Kept pushing the price higher. I literally said it's too high. My wealth is not some deep mystery. It's simply my ownership percentage in TSLA and SpaceX, multiplied by the valuation, that's my wealth. It's super simple. I have no offshore accounts, no clever tax evasion schemes, I don't draw a salary or any cash salary or bonus from the companies at all. I thought that was morally good - to not do that.
Unless you sell stock there are no realized gains, so what am I supposed to do? Am I supposed to send shares to the government? Unless you sell shares, there's no actual mechanism to pay tax...'
Tell me what exactly he's done wrong here, because I don't see it. Remove TSLA and Musk from the example above, and that's exactly how we'd want founders to act. That's why Warren and Sanders' attacks are baseless and just trying to enrage the mob.
By the way, you never addressed my claim that Elon (or Bezos for that matter) is a superior capital allocator than the gov't will ever be, and as such he should be allowed to take his free cash flow and invest in into the future.