Trouble is, we've got Larry and Fergie is committed to him so I can't see us spending anything more on defenders, other than perhaps for a replacement for Irwin...which certainly wouldn't cost anything near as much as Duff.
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Trouble is, we've got Larry and Fergie is committed to him so I can't see us spending anything more on defenders, other than perhaps for a replacement for Irwin...which certainly wouldn't cost anything near as much as Duff.</strong><hr></blockquote>
which sums up that a fullback is needed
Originally posted by Tomo:
<strong>
which sums up that a fullback is needed </strong><hr></blockquote>
I think we need a striker as much as we need a full back. It's a 50-50 thing really...
Originally posted by RUDDY:
<strong>i really dont see us getting into a bidding war for duff, if somebody wants to pay over the odds for him let them but id say hes worth 10mil tops</strong><hr></blockquote>
Kinell, Ruddy and I agree twice without insulting each other.
There's no way I think he's worth more than 10m. As I've said before if the money's there and SAF sees fit to spend it then I couldn't gve a feck, but Souness is saying 20m for Duff which frankly is taking the piss big time.
Originally posted by Amir:
<strong>
I think we need a striker as much as we need a full back. It's a 50-50 thing really...</strong><hr></blockquote>
Ruud,Ole,
And i think Diego will be top class given time
Originally posted by corelive:
<strong>
Ruud,Ole,
And i think Diego will be top class given time</strong><hr></blockquote>
And you need a fourth, a good fourth. Isn't that clear to everyone? We needed all four we had to win the treble in 99 and we need all four again with the Champions League extended now.
We are all saying full back, but Silvestre and Phil can do the left, Phil, Gary and Wes the right. Like I said, we probably need both striker and full back, but it's a 50-50 thing and hopefully both will have been taken care of.
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>
Kinell, Ruddy and I agree twice without insulting each other.
There's no way I think he's worth more than 10m. As I've said before if the money's there and SAF sees fit to spend it then I couldn't gve a feck, but Souness is saying 20m for Duff which frankly is taking the piss big time.</strong><hr></blockquote>
That depends on how much you rate him, if he has the potential to be as good as Giggs (who was rated in the late 20 to 30 millions pounds) then sure he's worth that much. He was undoubtedly one of the stars of the world cup and his value was talked at being about that amount directly after the WC. That imo is what SAF was talking about, when he mentioned that three targets had gone up in value over the WC.
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>So Duff, who played 4 games in the WC against Saudi, Cameroon, Germany and Spain (the latter both played poorly against Ireland) is now in the 20m bracket? Not in my book he's not, he's not even half way to being a sensation. He'll be a good back up to Giggs and Beckham if he comes but no more for a few years. After that he'd need to be quite special for 3 or 4 years to justify a 20m outlay. He came onto the scene two or three years ago at Blackburn and played well in a few games but then what? He's still at Blackburn and that says a lot. I think his price is more because of the lack of wingers about rather than his quality. Fair enough that's the market talking, but I think somewhere there's better for less.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I'd put him above Overmars already, and he wasn't cheap. As you say though, there aren't that many good wingers around - the game just doesn't make enough of them, we're one of the few clubs to emphasise wing play. At least we were until last season. Thats why we need Duff, to ensure its strength in future years. Put another way I'd rather have him in my team than in their team come the derby this season - such games may well decide the title this season.
Originally posted by benny:
<strong>Look, Duff is a lot more than a "good little player"He is an awesome talent,the best dribbler in world football today and he is worth at least 20 mil in todays ridiculous transfer market.I am sure that Fergie will sign him,positive.It will be around 15-17 mill,with Yorkie,and Fergie will do his business soon.Duff is a Utd player if I have ever seen one,and we will all live to regret it if he isnt signed for Manchester United</strong><hr></blockquote>
Spot on. I think we'll see this happen this week or next.
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>Dans, Alex has said repeatedly signings plural, mentioned 3 targets, do you really think it'll be just the one signing?</strong><hr></blockquote>
Yes I do. It was also said that Ferguson has landed the one player he wanted this summer. Do you thnk they originally expected to pay up to 33m for Rio? Over one year or two it doesn't matter that's a lot of wonga.
The only chance of more signings will be, I believe, if we offload quite a few. So who might they be?
Barthez - AEBM says so, so he probably won't be going anywhere
Silvestre - Raoul reckons he's staying put
Yorke - 4m - that'll buy us Duff's right bollock at today's prices
Fortune - have you heard of anybody expressing an interest in him?
I reckon that's it.
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>
Yes I do. It was also said that Ferguson has landed the one player he wanted this summer. Do you thnk they originally expected to pay up to 33m for Rio? Over one year or two it doesn't matter that's a lot of wonga.
The only chance of more signings will be, I believe, if we offload quite a few. So who might they be?
Barthez - AEBM says so, so he probably won't be going anywhere
Silvestre - Raoul reckons he's staying put
Yorke - 4m - that'll buy us Duff's right bollock at today's prices
Fortune - have you heard of anybody expressing an interest in him?
I reckon that's it.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Fortune was linked with a move to a Japanese club a few weeks ago...somewhere in the 4m range I think.
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>Well that's told me hasn't it? Or would have if I agreed with you. Your opinion versus mine - we disagree let's leave it at that. Besides, I don't think we'll be signing anyone else unless Mickey's decided he's off or Ferguson shows him the door. We've already spent 15m of this years 20 or 30 whatever it was profit. Dividends need to be paid etc etc. I think Rio was the one and only signing.</strong><hr></blockquote>
Such a pessimist!
Utd's half year profits were announced by the BBC a while back as £30 million. It is probable that they exceded £50 million for the full year. In addition to that figure there is £23 million of the first instalment of the £300 million Nike deal to add. That means Utd have a conservative profit margin of around £73 million this season. The Rio deal requires a £15 million payment this season and £14 million next.
Utd will not be just signing Rio this season. Duff is a target and a n other. Cheer up, Dans!
Originally posted by Dans:
<strong>We've already spent 15m of this years 20 or 30 whatever it was profit. Dividends need to be paid etc etc. I think Rio was the one and only signing.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I'm not in the know on the PLCs numbers. However, I would assume the profits are after transfers (which includes Veron's). If we made 20-30m profit including transfers, we could well be spending a similar amount as Veron's + X more due to the expected increased income from Nike (difference relative to UMBRO).
So the transfer kitty is probably in the 35-40m region and that's why, needing extra reinforcements, Rio was negotiated over two years to allow more purchases this Summer (while restricting the kitty for next Summer). That would leave Duff coming for 15m plus Yorke and a handy 10m for a fullback (this could actually be tied to receiving the Stam money).
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Rio, Duff, and a young LB would be a perfect for this year. And then next year a replacement for Larry and a striker.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I still think we should have got rock solid Ayala to partner Blanc and cultured Rio on better terms next year. Oh well...
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>Ronny would be too expensive. Gudjhonsen would probably be cheaper, though I doubt Chelsea would sell him to us for a reasonable price after what Leeds extorted out of us for Rio.</strong><hr></blockquote>
TBH i can't see us getting Ronaldo now.. feck knows it took us long enough to get Rio, besides there's not been any Ronaldo to United rumours... however Liverpool and ourselves have been linked to Duff... and even Souness said a couple of clubs have shown interest...
i'd be happy with Duff, Eidur's good but Ole's better.. Duff on the other hand has a that extra little bit of magic, which will help us when other teams go all out defensive at OT...
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>I think it might be:
OUT
Barthez 5m
Silvestre 8m
Yorke 4m
Veron 30m
TOTAL 47m
IN
Rio for 14.9m this year
Duff for 17m
Sorin 7m
Lopez 15m
TOTAL 54m
DIFF 7m
You can see from the above that there is plenty of room to manouevre.</strong><hr></blockquote>
all that in a space of a month??
veron and co aren't going anywhere... altho' it wouldn't surprise me if Yorke was sold.
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>I think it might be:
OUT
Barthez 5m
Silvestre 8m
Yorke 4m
Veron 30m
TOTAL 47m
IN
Rio for 14.9m this year
Duff for 17m
Sorin 7m
Lopez 15m
TOTAL 54m
DIFF 7m
You can see from the above that there is plenty of room to manouevre.</strong><hr></blockquote>
That looks like the panic buying transfer shufflings of a Serie-A side.
How about
In:
Rio 14m
Duff 12m
Escude 4m
Out:
Yorke (for Duff)
Fortune (for Duff)
Johnsen
Irwin
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>That would've worked as well, but I think there was alot of pressure for us to sign a big name defender like Rio after not winning any trophies last year.</strong><hr></blockquote>
I agree. Bringing Ayala would not look as ambitious and if it didn't pay off with instant wins everyone would soon be pointing out at him being Argentinian and not used to the EPL, the stingy plc, etc.
Long term, with Blanc here, I don't see why we couldn't wait another year for Rio and bring in his future hard-tackling partner to play with Blanc now and Rio later. I just hope O'Shea makes giant strides or else I would still not have much confidence in our defensive unit.
Originally posted by Raoul:
<strong>
That looks like the panic buying transfer shufflings of a Serie-A side.
How about
In:
Rio 14m
Duff 12m
Escude 4m
Out:
Yorke (for Duff)
Fortune (for Duff)
Johnsen
Irwin</strong><hr></blockquote>
THe Veron swap depends on Lazio coming up with a deal that interests us. THey've loaned out Mendieta to Barca, so Barca won't want Veron anymore, while Lazio have even more reason to. Did you know that he's having a tennis court built at his home in italy? After being rumoured to be leaving all year, it wouldn't exactly be beyond the imagination. I'm not saying its odds on, but its definitely very possible.
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>I think it might be:
OUT
Barthez 5m
Silvestre 8m
Yorke 4m
Veron 30m
TOTAL 47m
IN
Rio for 14.9m this year
Duff for 17m
Sorin 7m
Lopez 15m
TOTAL 54m
DIFF 7m
You can see from the above that there is plenty of room to manouevre.</strong><hr></blockquote>
where exactly is our w class keeper onna come from?????? in todays market
Originally posted by Neil Thomson:
<strong>
Did you know that he's having a tennis court built at his home in italy? </strong><hr></blockquote>
You want to stand up for him but whenever you feel you are winning the battle and he is staying he does something stupid like that. He certainly doesn't help the case FOR him, does he? FFS
Originally posted by gulli_G:
<strong>
where exactly is our w class keeper onna come from?????? in todays market</strong><hr></blockquote>
Neil didn't mention no keepers. I think he intends to give Carroll a run for his money.