Interesting. I wonder who'd we choose if prices are similar. What has been quoted so for Costa is 20-30 mil over the supposed Onana fee
Diogo Costa Porto keeper
- Thread starter Red_toad
- Start date
- Status
Interesting. I wonder who'd we choose if prices are similar. What has been quoted so for Costa is 20-30 mil over the supposed Onana fee
Come on then Porto, make us a deal! Hope we get this over the line.
That's what happens when you're greedy cnuts wanting their release clause paid.
I actually prefer Costa, but Onana is much cheaper, plus it's funny to see Porto not getting the fee they wanted.
Who fits Erik's style better?
Their business model is selling players they develop for ridiculous prices, they need to sell every summer to keep things sustainable.
Hmm, I did a fair bit of research on Onana but not so much on Costa(bar 5-6 games that I watched post WC). Both are supposed to have similar qualities but , to me at least, Onana seems like a much more composed player, especially in big games. That being said, Costa is younger, so his ceiling might be higher.
Last edited:
Cheers for the information
I get your point about the ceiling, and you may be right but Onana only just turned 27, VdS was almost 35 when he joined us, Smeichel 28. The age thing isn't a benefit to me at all in a goalie. If anything it feels like not being very young seems to result in a more confident and mature rock in the back. I just want who is most ready for prime time now.
I think the GK is the last piece of business for the summer.
If the other additions put us in "compete now" then I think we move for Onana because he is more ready-made. I believe Costa may have higher potential but it may take a season or two until we see his best.
It absolutely should not be. We are (supposedly) signing a keeper who should be proactive and pass from the back. That requires team cohesion and understanding. Otherwise we risk a start similar to last season and we can't afford that.
Quite so. Keepers generally "peak" later in their careers and terms like "ceiling" are highly speculative anyway.
Pretty sure , there will be plenty of suitors for Costa
He isn’t that rated by Portuguese fans so I’ve eased up on him especially at his prices.
Why's that? Due to his WC performance?
So they know he’s coming to England, they just don’t know where?
What kind of statement is that? 
He’s coming to the prem but no prem team have put in a bid for him? If he’s going for 50m the same price as Onana then we should be all over it
He’s coming to the prem but no prem team have put in a bid for him? If he’s going for 50m the same price as Onana then we should be all over itSounds like it
Probably Chelsea - on a 18 year deal.
Yeah it's us or Chelsea
Onana is the obvious choice as he had played for Ten Haag before.
Costa is more rounded than Onana, more like Alison probably, while good with his feet, but Onana is another level in that area. His long kicks are really accurate which has been more of Inter's style, but at Ajax he played short more, coming of his box to create different passing angles.
Costa is a better shot stopper but his world cup made me doubt his big game mentality (though he is young still). Onana couldn't care less who he is playing against, he just does his thing.
Yeah the big games mentality could be a real wildcard in the choice between the two
What happened in the WC?
I was pretty sure we'd switch to Onana if he was available, but if Porto keep dropping their price, maybe he'd be better value.
Yeah maybe
He looked shaky, but the blame he got for the Moroccan goal was a bit unfair. En-Nesyri's jump for that header was incredible.
He made a major rick in group game against Ghana towards the end iirc
Maybe to Wolves?
Don't see that this time
Ta.
Just watched both of these and they don't worry me that much. The Inter keeper's vids terrify me, however.
That'll blow up in our face if DDG leaves on a free in a few days. Every club in Europe will know we're desperate.
Personally I have concerns with either but both are significant style upgrades on DDG. Costa I have worries about his big game mentality but assured on crosses. Compare that to Onana who seems to love big occasion but worry about him on crosses. No doubt both of them distribute the ball superbly well so no issues on that.
Newcastle written all over him
Exactly, if Porto need the cash get this done now!! Saves us a big headache later in the window or starting the season with Heaton as our no.1!
Nah they have Pope and the mighty Dubravka. Think they are set!
Onana wandering off is my concern. He seems to have a thing for taking it round players who close him down that can result in him ending up miles out of position.
Yeah that is also a very valid concern
He kind of looks like a white Kanye
That’s his own business
- Status