Nighteyes
Another Muppet
- Joined
- Nov 14, 2012
- Messages
- 25,467
The only good thing about the ending was Debra dying.
Yup, Quinn owed him from the blood on his shoe thing though.Still can't believe Batista and Quinn let him go.
Agree, on the nosedive. I didn't think it went that bad.
Didn't like the ending though. Deb didn't deserve to be killed off if Dexter wasn't but then again it would be hard for her to live with it all coming out publicly.
Should have ended when she walked in on him in the church and gasped, cut to credits. Done!
Possibly even when he found Harrison in Rita's blood cause that would have been cool symmetry IMO. It all 'started' from him being 'born in blood' and I think it would have been cool to end it like that giving an obvious not to the characters beginnings while ending it at the same time.
Just a thought anyway...
Yeah I'd have liked it to end with him ending up in custody. Just him sat in the interview room (like the last Lumberjack scene where he just looks into the camera)They could have changed the order of seasons around. Have it finish in four seasons with the last season having the plot from the 2nd one where they find the bodies. The show ends with Dexter getting caught/dying. Eight season was far too long for a show which had about 2 or 3 interesting characters at best.
They should make a spin off for Quinn.
A Quinn off.
As @Damien said, it's probably not as bad as when you're discussing each episode on here and notice all the issues. I actually rewatched the show a few months back and I wasn't as bored with the latter seasons as I expected to be. If you ignore some of the plot holes and inconsistencies (yeah, I know how that sounds!) it's still decent entertainment in the last seasons. It could've been so much better though, which is probably the biggest problem.Only just watched this over the last month.
i don't think it nosedives the way people let me to believe, but one things for sure, it was an incredibly shit ending. The lumberjack thing? fecking hell what an awful cliche.
I also found Deb's death very depressing, keeping Dexter alive and having Deb die was just horrible, should have been the other way.
The first four were all good, but Trinity was pretty epic.People always say the 4th was the best season but the 1st was for me. Brian
Yeah Lithgow was fantastic but for me Personally I loved Rudy. Just proper Dexter without the wife/kids. I liked that Dexter better.The first four were all good, but Trinity was pretty epic.
It ended after season 4, not sure what you're all on about.
If it had ended that day, this TV show would have been remembered as a true classic, as one of the best shows of last decade, if not ever.Should have ended when she walked in on him in the church and gasped, cut to credits. Done!
Possibly even when he found Harrison in Rita's blood cause that would have been cool symmetry IMO. It all 'started' from him being 'born in blood' and I think it would have been cool to end it like that giving an obvious not to the characters beginnings while ending it at the same time.
Just a thought anyway...
If it had ended that day, this TV show would have been remembered as a true classic, as one of the best shows of last decade, if not ever.
Season 1, 2 and 4 were really fantastic. The finale of season 1 and 4 are two of the best episodes I have ever seen.
My rating too. Fourth was fantastic, but I liked the first one slightly more. As emotional as the last scene of the fourth season was, Dexter killing his brother was even more emotional IMO.Totally agree. I'd rank it 1-4-2-3 out of the first four.
A lot of writers left, yeah. That was another huge problem with the later seasons, that the writers seemingly forgot what had happened in earlier seasons and on more than a couple of occasions wrote something that completely contradicted what had happened earlier in the show.Yep, also agree with 1,4,2,3.
I think what didnt help was this show pretty much aired the same time with Breaking Bad (especially the last seasons). I think Season 5 was the season where nothing really happened and by the end, it all returned to how it was at the beginning of the season, nothing actually progressed for any of the characters.
I also agree that if it had the first four seasons, with 2 possibly as the last one and him being caught (by Doakes haha) then it would be remembered more for that but its remembered for the freakin lumberjack lol.
Didnt they change directors / writers at the end of season 4?
Called it 3 years ago.Deborah dying is the only way to resolve this crap.
Agreed.Doakes was also killed off too early IMO. Should have been the one to bring him down.
I've motored through all 8 seasons in the last 6 weeks or so! I avoided any spoilers, so had no idea what the end game would be.
I can't judge which seasons were better as I can't recall where one started and one finished. Interesting to read people say it nosedived after season 4, I didn't feel that way watching it on loop so to speak.
That said, the finale was very disappointing - the fake fade away was clever as i'd have been even more pissed had he killed himself as he is a king of self-preservation. I just found it a bit crap that his "cover" became who he wanted to be and that opening himself up to human emotion and human connection was simply overwhelming and exiled himself as a lumberjack.
Disappointing ending, but i'd have been even more disappointed had I spent 7-8 years building up to that conclusion.
Agreed.
"surprise motherfecker!"
Five was a waste though. If you cut out the whole of five, you can actually jump from 4 to 6 and it wouldnt matter. Nothing actually changed.