A lower xGA means goalkeeper B had the easier job. Saving 60% of easy shots isn’t as good as saving 50% of difficult shots.
1
Season Average Rating
- Appearances
- 36
- Clean sheets
- 12
- Goals
- 0
- Assists
- 0
- Yellow cards
- 0
- Status
A lower xGA means goalkeeper B had the easier job. Saving 60% of easy shots isn’t as good as saving 50% of difficult shots.
Not going to 'blame' De Gea.
We didnt kick on at any point in the game and despite all the play, they had the best chance in the first half which he saved. The second goal, Maguire as captain needs more composure. We've let in dumb goals at home; esp this season and that trend continues ...but just kick it out of play. Let the team clear its head if you want but don't play a really dumb ball back to the goalkeeper ....who at best could only kick it in to touch. The idea is to get the ball away from danger not risk anything but Maguire did with the pass back. Should have looked to just be a man...and clear it himself.
We didnt kick on at any point in the game and despite all the play, they had the best chance in the first half which he saved. The second goal, Maguire as captain needs more composure. We've let in dumb goals at home; esp this season and that trend continues ...but just kick it out of play. Let the team clear its head if you want but don't play a really dumb ball back to the goalkeeper ....who at best could only kick it in to touch. The idea is to get the ball away from danger not risk anything but Maguire did with the pass back. Should have looked to just be a man...and clear it himself.
This was my initial reaction too. Found it weird that people blamed him for the goal. But then caf has been giving him hate for over a year now. So was not expecting muchExactly. He had Maguire, Tuanzebe and a Sheffield player in front of him when he received the ball. His first thought was probably to not smash it into them and have it ricochet into the goal, so he side-footed it. Perhaps more power would've been appropriate, but the idea was sound.
Well to be fair he's been shite for a couple of years now so it's only fair he get criticised. Stop with this hate and haters nonsense.
18/19 and 19/20 seasons were littered with appalling mistakes regularly. This season he's cut out the dreadful errors but he's now just mediocre.
Blows my mind how most of our fans lay into Lindelof, Maguire, AWB and Rashford the moment they have a below average game, yet De Gea is somehow immune from this. Every time people come up with an excuse that he'll come good. And to be honest I don't understand how or why?
He's not an academy lad. He tried to leave us on numerous occasions and almost succeding. He literally broke our wage structure, and now we are stuck with a mediocre player on Sanchez type wages that nobody is going to touch with a 50 foot pole.
And to be honest, I don't understand why? Yes, he was good... once. Not anymore though. But wasn't our club famous once for letting go of players who are already past it or am I imagining it?
He's not an academy lad. He tried to leave us on numerous occasions and almost succeding. He literally broke our wage structure, and now we are stuck with a mediocre player on Sanchez type wages that nobody is going to touch with a 50 foot pole.
And to be honest, I don't understand why? Yes, he was good... once. Not anymore though. But wasn't our club famous once for letting go of players who are already past it or am I imagining it?
Huh?
Scroll back a few pages, there's plenty of people criticizing him on here - myself included. And he's nearly always been criticized for his ability on the ball and his reluctance to come out on corners. Even when he was performing at a high level he was criticized for those two things in particular.
So he's certainly not immune from it, to be fair.
xGA (Expected goal against, usually per match) is not the same as xG (expected goal, usually per shot) though.
An xG of 0.8 means 80% chance of scoring and 20% chance of saving.
If there are two shots at 80% chance of scoring (xg 0.8 and xg 0.8),
the xGA could be as high as 1.6 (exact calculation not known)
Low xGA does not mean easy shots. It just means lower goals likely to be scored (could be due to lower shots on target etc).
Low xG usually mean the shots are easier to save.
"Easy shots" was just a turn of phrase to explain the point being discussed. I appreciate it wasn't actual easier shots and could just as easily represent the same difficulty shots, but fewer of them.
As for xG vs xGA, in the case of fbref the only difference between those two is whether that's for or against a team. Whether that's per shot, per 90 or an absolute value depends on the particular stat being discussed. Often all three of those are provided. Different firms may treat that stat differently for all I know.
Arsenal 0:0 Man Utd
MOTM for me today. Made some great saves. One of the few players that can do his job right.
I agree that De Gea has dropped down from the usual levels. But I am not so sure he has turned to s**t. Besides, unless we are investing in a big name new keeper who is miles ahead. Our current replacement is Henderson who looks worse than De Gea every time he has played
Huh?
What did he do today to warrant MOTM?
The only save I can remember him really making was the shot by Smith Rowe. And it was a very, very routine save at his near post. The other two big chances they had were blocked by our defenders and the one where they hit the crossbar.
Someone is eager to praise him
He had one standard save all game to make. We could have had Phil Jones in goal and we'd not have conceded.- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 18,284
- Supports
️
Solid today
We did well to restrict how much he had to do.
Arsenal missed a trick on corners by not crowding him (think they did this once)
Arsenal missed a trick on corners by not crowding him (think they did this once)
Man Utd 9:0 Southampton
Yet another clean sheet. Not much to do, but saved the free kick, was good at distribution, and it’s not his fault that Che Adams was 1 millimetre offside
Recall one moment where he actually punched it out from a JWP corner. At last.
Hey @Foxbatt
JWP would have had an easy goal if de gea took up your recommended positioning for the fk
JWP would have had an easy goal if de gea took up your recommended positioning for the fk
- Joined
- Sep 1, 2015
- Messages
- 18,284
- Supports
- ️
He swept he dealt with crosses and saved a FK that many would have conceded from moving too far right.
Solid
Solid
Ward-Prowse had two shots in that game including the free kick, for a combined xG of 0.1. It would be a bit strong to suggest it was anything other than a routine save.
On the plus side I thought he dealt with that early corner from Ward Prowse pretty well. He was being fouled (and it was given) but he still cleared the ball from under his bar quite cleanly.
Am I the ar$e for thinking he's very fortunate VAR ruled out Southampton's goal? Getting beat from that angle didn't impress me at all. I'm not a De Gea hater. I've been a De Gea cheerleader for a long time actually. However, letting that shot in was a reminder that this De Gea is still levels below the De Gea of three or four years ago.
Yeah a big positive and hopefully not a one off
He isn't getting the credit he deserves for JWP Freekick. Granted, it was straight at him but it had lot of power and is coming from such a short distance. Also, majority of the keepers would expect the ball in the other corner.
Yes, almost.
It was a great finish from that tight angle. Many keepers would not be able to stop it in time. The defense should never have allowed the player to shoot from that angle.
It was a superb stop. That ball had some power on it.
No. The goal didn’t happen so it’s not relevant. Next time de Gea will save it, and this time it didn’t count - so it’s a clean sheet
Said this in post match but, I do like that he was furious with the defending for the set piece and losing the clean sheet at the time. We to be a lot more switched on and ensuring we are keeping a lot more clean sheets through rest of season.
Think you might a bit harsh. It's not a matter of him being levels below. I rewatched it after because someone made a comment in the post match thread. It was an excellent finish. DDG had the near post covered as he should have and it was hit hard enough for him not to get his leg out fast enough for the shot across and it was right into the post.
Think you might a bit harsh. It's not a matter of him being levels below. I rewatched it after because someone made a comment in the post match thread. It was an excellent finish. DDG had the near post covered as he should have and it was hit hard enough for him not to get his leg out fast enough for the shot across and it was right into the post.
Quietly having a very good season. Not a season filled with epic saves, but he’s getting the job done.
Hes not having a good season by his standards in my opinion. He’s been very much good or crap, more good than crap, but still the flaws in his game are there for all to see and exploited. Been a long time since he looked impenetrable.
Pretty much. He's obviously been better than he was the last two seasons, but he's still not been anywhere near as good as he was before that. Overall it's been a decent season at best.
Yeh I wouldn’t say he’s having a good season as good by his standards is relatively very high for the goalkeeping average.
He’s been better than the last 2 seasons for sure, if he’d continued that form he’d have lost the starting spot to Henderson by this stage so maybe the latter’s presence has helped light a fire under his arse somewhat.
He’s been better than the last 2 seasons for sure, if he’d continued that form he’d have lost the starting spot to Henderson by this stage so maybe the latter’s presence has helped light a fire under his arse somewhat.
Even in the last game what Southampton did to get back in the game is to man mark De Gea during a corner.
I feel like I cant complain about De Gea whilst we are challenging for the title because he does bring some benefits alongside all his weaknesses- however still as expensive as he is, he is an aspect that a manager may have to change in the third season or 4th to address a weakness that arguably effects all of the defensive line.
I'm not calling him Karius by any means, but the replacement for Allison for Liverpool helped that defence just as much as Van Dijk. You wonder if we could replace De Gea for the benefit of our defence as a whole - replace a goal keeper 85% good enough but 15 % fails doing the same thing.
De Gea is now the Top 4 keepers this season in terms of clean sheets made. And let's not forget De Gea is the only goalkeeper who has made Premier League Team of the season 5 times or more!
He is good this season. Maybe not brilliant, but good, reliable and consistent - significantly better than the last season
Man Utd 3:3 Everton
Dreadful.
I swear he's an Everton Fan
Coward of a goalkeeper
Coward of a goalkeeper
Em... finished here?
Clown.
At least he didn't get hurt at the end. That could have hurt, had he done his job there. Silver lining tonight is that De Gea isn't hurt.
- Status